opinion

The Payback of Taking Back ‘Defective’ Items

We all love a returning customer but not so much a customer that returns products. Given the nature of our industry, whether you are my favorite bricks-and-mortar kind of store or just work your magic on the Internet, returns have always been a really tricky topic to address. Do you take returns? Does your distributor take returns? Does your supervisor support you in accepting returns from customers? What do you tell a customer who wants to return a product? Will they give you a bad Yelp review because you told them you couldn’t return a product, even after six months? There is certainly no easy answer when it comes to sex toys and returns.

When I had my store, Grand Opening!, I told customers that our return policy was for 30 days for defective items. Now, the term “defective items” is broad enough to apply to something that doesn’t function properly but is it always the product’s fault or that of the owner? Did they know how to use it in the first place? (Believe it or not, that can sometimes be an issue). Were they returning that item because they were simply not happy with it and thought by maybe breaking it, you’d think it was simply a defective item? As you can read right here, there are tons of things to take into consideration whether you take returns or not. Let’s look at a few examples.

What if you don’t take any returns? Is it worth upsetting a customer with this day and age of Yelp reviews? The way a customer can vent on the World Wide Web can affect your company in ways that no public relations company can save you from.

But first, let’s look at actually taking in a used sex toy as a returned item. Yes, you can find out if something doesn’t work right away but what if the customer noticed it didn’t work after using it a few times in her beloved snatchland? Or him on his willing (and maybe disappointed) dick or wait, inside his, um, you know. And then the customer comes in your store and tries to return it? Hopefully they have taken the time to thoroughly wash the product prior to returning it (and they do pretty much most of the time). This is what I have done…

Being one to always want to know what failed in a sex toy or anything else for that matter, I actually enjoy getting returned products so I can see what failed, what needs to be improved, if there have been several of the same items returned, etc. but I’m getting ahead of myself. When I worked for a home sex toy party company, we imported products directly from manufacturers in China and I was in charge of quality control, making sure the product we ordered was exactly the same as the sample we received (and I can see your eyes rolling if you’ve ever been involved with doing this because you know what I mean). If we started getting returns for the same product because of malfunctioning, I wanted to know why so I encouraged our reps to have the customer return the product to me so I could inspect it and send the consumer a replacement item.

When we received the product, which 99 percent of the times was clean and carefully wrapped (although not always in the original packaging), I was able to dissect the gizmo with a scientific eye, looking for what might be causing the defect.

I know that some of you reading this are thinking of the ick factor: “You mean, you handled someone’s sex toy that was in their pussy???” Yes, as a matter of fact, I did, wearing latex gloves and handling the toy like it was covered in germs (which it wasn’t because they were usually well washed prior to my receiving them).

And I was actually criticized by the home sex toy party company’s owners by my incessant interest in trying to find out what was wrong with the products we sold. “I can’t believe you are handling sex toys that someone else used,” they bellowed. Well, frankly, I always wore my trusty latex gloves when handling these toys and, truth be told, the owners of the home party company were the parents of two young daughters and I often felt like asking “How many shit-filled diapers have you changed without wearing latex gloves? You can catch a lot more doing that than I ever will wearing latex gloves handling someone else’s sex toys.” Geesh!

I wanted to know what the problem was with these items, why they failed, and if it was the mechanics of the product or simply the owner’s fault. Believe it or not, it was usually the owner’s fault of not correctly putting in the batteries! I simply dropped a friendly email to the customer stating what they did incorrectly and sent them either the original product back or if I felt particularly benevolent, sent them a new one.

But that’s just one situation and we know we are always faced with others. Let’s look at them…

What if you don’t take any returns? Is it worth upsetting a customer with this day and age of Yelp reviews? The way a customer can vent on the World Wide Web can affect your company in ways that no public relations company can save you from. Is it worth it? These are things to consider, for sure.

Many times, a company will back the product with a warranty. Some major manufacturers guarantee their product by “registering” it with them so encourage your customer to do that, as well as hold on to their receipt (their proof of purchase which, while we casually toss it into the trash, is actually pretty important to hold on to, especially if it’s a high-ticket item). Packaging isn’t usually that important to hold on to but the receipt is.

What if your store/website claims “all sales final?” What do you do? Is the customer out of luck if something fails? This is where you really need to be up on warranty information, which varies from product to product, company to company. It’s pretty difficult to stay on top of, that’s for sure. Perhaps a bit of training by the manufacturers or someone at your company can stay on top of these things to share with staffers such as “Company XXX offers a one-year warranty on all of their products.” It would be a good thing to know.

Does the product get returned to you or to the manufacturer or even your distributor? Several distributors have a deal with manufacturers that cover returns because if the distributor absorbs the returns, they sometimes can get a bigger quantity discount from the manufacturer. Sometimes you can have a very cooperative distributor who will gladly accept returns and cover your ass in replacement products or a credit. Some distributors are better than others on their return policy and make sure you familiarize yourself with it when you do business with them.

When I had my bricks and mortar store, Grand Opening!, I would, of course, get the occasional customer who wanted to return a product. If it was a battery operated toy, I would don my trusty latex gloves (there they are again!), and discreetly test the toy at the counter. The overwhelming majority of the time, the issue was simply how they installed the batteries! I would put them in properly and the gizmo would start twirling or shaking, proving to the customer with their own eyes that the product was not defective and it was simply a brain fart on their part. I would point out how to put the batteries in properly and even give them the batteries I installed in their vibe for free. I figured the new batteries cost me only a few bucks (if that) and it left the customer feeling happy that they were able to “save” their toy and I saved the cost of giving them a new replacement product. In the meantime, I was able to save my reputation and continue to create a loyal customer, “defective” product be damned!

So when dealing with returns, remember that a happy customer can tell 10 friends and a pissed off one can tell the whole world. I’d rather have 10 friends become happy new customers knowing that my company did the right thing than the whole world being pissed off. Hope you can agree.

Kim Airs is the founder of sexuality boutique GrandOpening.com. She is a consultant for all aspects of the adult toy industry: training, sales, marketing, etc. She loves her job!

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

opinion

A Hands-On Review of AI Camera Monitoring for Retail

Last month, I outlined the main AI-powered loss prevention options available to businesses: DIY solutions, hosted services and enterprise platforms. This time, I decided to test one out myself. I contacted a cloud video platform that integrates with Lightspeed POS and scheduled a demo.

Zondre Watson ·
opinion

Turning Fantasy Fans Into New Creature Play Shoppers

Adult “creature play” is no longer just a niche novelty. There’s even a term for this kink: teratophilia, meaning sexual attraction to monsters. A heady mix of sensory novelty, curiosity about unfamiliar bodies and potential power dynamics has made lusting after and role-playing mythological creatures more widely accepted. The erotically captivating allure of otherworldly beings has even become prevalent across pop culture, from “True Blood” and “The Shape of Water” to Guillermo Del Toro’s “Frankenstein” and “monster boyfriend” romantasy literature trending on TikTok.

Naima Karp ·
trends

Signals Ahead: Pleasure Brands Track the Rapid Convergence of Tech and Intimacy

It’s complicated. As the pleasure industry enters 2026, many industry observers predict that the coming year will be shaped not by a single game-changing breakthrough or standout celebrity partnership, but rather by the slow, powerful alignment of consumer psychology, economic reality, cultural openness and shifting demographic needs.

Ariana Rodriguez ·
profile

Kyrie Hara Fuels Tenga's Growth as U.S. Sales Lead

Kyrie Hara is making significant moves. After racking up sales and general management experience during her 14-year run with Hawaiian retailer Sensually Yours, Hara has quickly embraced her role as the newest U.S. sales lead with Japanese manufacturer Tenga.

Women In Adult ·
profile

Alex Feynerol Discusses Svakom's Male-Focused Brand, Kaotik Labs

Over the past 13 years, Svakom has built its brand on sensuality and emotional intimacy, focusing on elegant design, wellness-oriented messaging and accessible pricing for vibrators and couples’ products — what the company often describes as “affordable luxury.” Recently, however, the company has had to adjust its traditional marketing tactics to fit one particular category steadily gaining prominence: male masturbators.

Jackie Backman ·
opinion

Why Midlife Men Are the Next Big Bet in Sexual Wellness

The recent shift toward supporting pleasure for perimenopausal and menopausal women — a topic once treated as taboo — has clearly been a major breakthrough for the sexual wellness industry. However, there is an equally important yet often neglected market to consider: midlife men.

Karen Bigman ·
opinion

Retailer Tips for Building Customer Trust, Loyalty

Want to increase customer traffic and deepen engagement in 2026? Then it’s time to look beyond quick wins and start building true loyalty.

Staci Cruse ·
opinion

How AI-Powered Loss Prevention Can Help Your Store

Years ago, I was deeply involved in upgrading the security camera system at a store in Hawaii. The process took several months. We provided store diagrams, mapped out camera lines of sight, waited for quotes, then coordinated with a contractor to install everything. It cost thousands — and by the time I left that position, the system still wasn’t fully operational.

Zondre Watson ·
opinion

5 Product Trends Retail Buyers Should Bet On in 2026

In 2026, expect consumers to prioritize one thing above all else: comfort.

Sunny Rodgers ·
opinion

Exploring the Shift Toward Pleasure Products Designed for All Bodies

The last few years have seen a positive change in our industry, as more brands and innovators are finally prioritizing accessibility. Whether they call it inclusive design, adaptive pleasure or accessible intimacy, the aim remains the same: Pleasure should be accessible to everyone, including people with limited mobility or physical disabilities.

Alexandra Bouchard ·
Show More