FSC Case Against Tennessee AV Law Can Go Forward, Court Rules

FSC Case Against Tennessee AV Law Can Go Forward, Court Rules

MEMPHIS, Tenn. — A U.S. district court on Tuesday denied the Tennessee attorney general’s motion to dismiss a Free Speech Coalition lawsuit challenging the Protect Tennessee Minors Act.

The Protect Tennessee Minors Act (PTMA), that state’s age verification law for adult sites, was enacted in 2024, prior to the Supreme Court’s pivotal decision in Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton. In November 2024, FSC and co-plaintiffs MelRose Michaels, sex education platform O.school, sexual wellness retailer Adam & Eve and adult fan platform JustFor.Fans filed a legal challenge, prompting a Tennessee district court to temporarily block the law. However, the 6th Circuit Court of Appeals lifted that preliminary injunction, allowing the law to go into effect.

Following the Supreme Court’s June 2025 decision in FSC v. Paxton, FSC reps vowed to retrench in order to define “sensible limits” on AV laws so that anti-porn legislators cannot keep chipping away at the right of adults to access protected speech.

In an amended complaint, FSC and its co-plaintiffs argued that the PTMA violates the First Amendment by imposing a content-based burden on protected speech, unlikely to survive even the “intermediate scrutiny” required under the SCOTUS ruling. The complaint also asserted that the law’s vagueness violates the 14th Amendment’s due process clause, and that treating website operators as publishers of material produced by other content providers conflicts with Section 230 of the federal Communications Decency Act.

The amended complaint acknowledged the change in the legal landscape since the Paxton ruling, but maintained that Tennessee has overstepped even the expanded bounds defined in that ruling.

In response, Tennessee Attorney General Jonathan Skrmetti filed a motion to dismiss, contending that the plaintiffs lacked standing to sue him and that FSC and the other plaintiffs failed to present “sufficient facts to state a plausible claim.”

On Tuesday, Chief Judge Sheryl H. Lipman of the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Tennessee denied Skrmetti’s motion, ruling that the case can go forward.

The FSC’s counsel in the case, Jeff Sandman, praised Lipman’s “thorough, thoughtful, and reasoned decision.”

“We are excited to vigorously pursue our claims as the case enters its next phase,” he said.

FSC board chair Jeffrey Douglas commented, “This was an important winning step in these early stages of the litigation. Most importantly, the court ruled that we have ‘standing,’ the essential requirement in any federal lawsuit. Standing is an increasingly difficult hurdle to overcome in recent years, with conservative courts using it to block access to federal relief. The attorney general lost on a number of other important issues, allowing us to proceed on the substance of all of our constitutional challenges — that the definitions are vague, that the requirement that websites hold verification of the age of adult users for seven years violates privacy, that reverifying the user hourly is too burdensome, the law is overbroad and underinclusive, and finally, that the law is preempted by existing federal law, the Communications Decency Act. None of our claims were dismissed by the court!”

Tuesday's ruling notes that while the Constitution recognizes “a valid governmental interest” in dealing with obscenity, the mere assertion of that interest does not automatically trump constitutional protections.

While Lipman did not rule on the plaintiffs’ assertion that the PTMA violates the First Amendment and is therefore unconstitutional, she did rule that the FSC and the other plaintiffs do indeed have standing and have indeed stated a plausible claim, as specific provisions of the Protect Tennessee Minors Act — such as a requirement that a user’s age must be reverified every 60 minutes — could be argued to impose a heightened burden on adult users’ access to sexual content.

In addition, Lipman called it “plausible” that certain terminology in the law is so vague that a person of ordinary intelligence might not understand what is or is not prohibited by the PTMA.

“Plaintiffs plausibly allege that the PTMA as amended may substantially burden more speech than necessary,” Lipman writes.

One area where the law could potentially be deemed too vague is its definition of a covered website as one on which a “substantial portion” of the material on the website is harmful to minors. Like a number of other state AV laws, the PTMA defines “substantial portion” as one-third or more of the total data, but without specifying exactly what this means.

As a result, Lipman notes, the law allows Tennessee to decide what constitutes a “substantial portion” using an “excessively subjective” standard. While she did not rule on whether that vagueness renders the law unconstitutional, Lipman did agree with the plaintiffs that their allegations that the terms are unconstitutionally vague are plausible.

Should the court ultimately rule that the "substantial portion"/"one third" rule is indeed unconstitutionally vague, such a decision could ultimately have ramifications in other states where AV laws include that provision.

Lipman likewise found the plaintiffs’ argument that the PTMA may be preempted by Section 230 protections to be plausible.

Importantly, Lipman also ruled that “intermediate scrutiny” should apply in the case. The FSC argued that the highest level of judicial review, “strict scrutiny,” should apply, while the state of Tennessee argued for intermediate scrutiny. While the case can now move forward, Lipman’s ruling that only intermediate scrutiny applies will almost certainly make it more difficult for the plaintiffs to prove that the law violates the First Amendment.

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

FSC, Texas Ask for Summary Judgment in AV Law 'Health Warnings' Case

Both sides in a lawsuit challenging the “health warning” requirements of Texas’ age verification law for adult websites have motioned for summary judgment in the case.

AEBN Publishes Popular Searches for September, October

AEBN has published the top search terms for September and October from its straight and gay theaters in all 50 states and the District of Columbia.

BranditScan Launches Black Friday Creator Promo

BranditScan has launched its annual Black Friday promotion, offering creators a 69% discount for the first month to creators signing up for the DMCA leak protection and takedown anti-piracy subscription service.

Ofcom Proposes Requiring Adult Sites Hosting UGC to Use Hash Matching Tech

U.K. media regulator Ofcom on Monday asked Parliament to approve proposed new codes that would, among other changes, require adult platforms hosting user-generated content to implement hash matching technology in order to detect CSAM.

Flirt4Free Wins Trademark Infringement Case Against Copycat Website

The World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) has ruled in favor of Flirt4Free in a case against a copycat website using an infringing domain.

Irish PM Affirms Plan for UK-Style Ban on 'Extreme' Content

Ireland’s prime minister on Wednesday confirmed that his government is moving ahead with plans to introduce legislation criminalizing possession and distribution of “extreme” pornography, which he hopes to see passed by early 2027.

UK Parliamentary Group Calls for Outlawing Cam Platforms

The U.K. Parliament’s All-Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) on Commercial Sexual Exploitation has published a report in which it calls for banning adult livestreaming platforms.

Ofcom Escalates Sun Social, Superb Convert Investigations

U.K. media regulator Ofcom has ramped up its ongoing Online Safety Act (OSA) compliance investigations into PlayVids/PeekVids operator Sun Social Media and PimpBunny operator Superb Convert.

Centrobill Integrates Apple Pay, Google Pay

Centrobill has added Apple Pay and Google Pay options for merchants.

Judge Preliminarily Approves Pornhub Class Action Settlement

A U.S. District Court judge on Monday granted preliminary approval to a settlement between Aylo and the plaintiffs in two class-action lawsuits over allegations that former Pornhub parent company MindGeek knowingly allowed and profited from CSAM on its sites.

Show More