opinion

Flirting With the FBI

Something happened a few months ago that was reported in the adult media but which caused barely a ripple in the industry, and you really have to ask yourself why there was no outcry about it on the boards, and no phone calls or emails into the office asking for clarification or follow-up information.

That something was a "secret" meeting in Washington between seven adult companies and the FBI. The subject under discussion was 18 U.S.C. § 2257, the notorious federal labeling and record-keeping regulations that continue to haunt the industry, and purposelessly so.

Actually, I knew about the meeting in advance and even saw a copy of the letter sent by the FBI to one of the seven companies, but the name of the company in question was redacted. The gist of the letter was that the FBI wanted to talk about the 2257 inspections process, but it was unclear what they wanted to discuss or why they invited the particular companies. There was, as I recall, a reference to "leaders in the industry."

What struck me about the letter was the fact that no confidentiality was requested, which one would certainly expect the FBI to request unless they wanted the fact of the meeting — and what happened at the meeting — to go out to the adult industry. I planned on writing about the upcoming meeting, but was asked — no, implored — by an industry attorney not to write about it beforehand, and to drive the point home he told me that I would do "inestimable damage" if I did. I wrote and said nothing, but I did stay in close contact with the attorney up to the date of the meeting, attempted independent contact with the coordinating FBI agent (to no avail), and received a guarantee by another lawyer who was going to be in attendance that coverage would be provided us.

It was and it wasn't. Adult media got a story to post afterwards, but we could have written the copy ourselves without even having been there! No details were forthcoming, and certainly no specifics as to what the FBI said or what was said to the FBI. At the time, it made me wonder what the point was.

As a result, I was in this column going to excoriate those in attendance for staying so mum, but then Greg Piccionelli sent in his column, which will appear here tomorrow, in which he provides a great deal of detail about the meeting, much of it very interesting but some of it confusing.

He says, for instance, that the supervising agent called the meeting in part because of "concern about a number of adult media industry stories that were inaccurately reporting information regarding the inspection process." This is a particularly interesting comment considering the fact that in the process of writing coverage of each of the inspections XBIZ writers placed calls to the FBI for comment and to fact check. Unfortunately, all they were ever told is that inspections took place.

So the FBI can hardly complain about the results of adult media coverage if they decline to comment for that coverage. Piccionelli also states that at the end of the meeting the supervising agent "reiterated his sincere desire to establish a dialogue with the industry," and seemed enthusiastic about the prospect of communicating directly with adult media companies.

I hope so. We have calls in. We are waiting to hear back.

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

profile

Stripchat's Jessica on Building Creator Success, One Step at a Time

At most industry events, the spotlight naturally falls on the creators whose personalities light up screens and social feeds. Behind the booths, parties and perfectly timed photo ops, however, there is someone else shaping the experience.

Jackie Backman ·
opinion

Inside the OCC's Debanking Review and Its Impact on the Adult Industry

For years, adult performers, creators, producers and adjacent businesses have routinely had their access to basic financial services curtailed — not because they are inherently higher-risk customers, but because a whole category of lawful work has long been treated as unacceptable.

Corey Silverstein ·
opinion

How to Build Operational Resilience Into Your Payment Ecosystem

Over the past year, we’ve watched adult merchants weather a variety of disruptions and speedbumps. Some even lost entire revenue streams overnight — simply because they relied too heavily on a single cloud provider that suffered an outage, lacked sufficient redundancy and failover, or otherwise fell short when it came to making sure their business was protected in case of unwelcome surprises.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

Building a Stronger Strategy Against Card-Testing Bots

It’s a scenario every high-risk merchant dreads. You wake up one morning, check your dashboard and see a massive spike in transaction volume. For a fleeting moment, you’re excited at the premise that something went viral — but then reality sets in. You find thousands of transactions, all for $0.50 and all declined.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

A Creator's Guide to Starting the Year With Strong Financial Habits

Every January brings that familiar rush of new ideas and big goals. Creators feel ready to overhaul their content, commit to new posting schedules and jump on fresh opportunities.

Megan Stokes ·
opinion

Pornnhub's Jade Talks Trust and Community

If you’ve ever interacted with Jade at Pornhub, you already know one thing to be true: Whether you’re coordinating an event, confirming deliverables or simply trying to get an answer quickly, things move more smoothly when she’s involved. Emails get answered. Details are confirmed. Deadlines don’t drift. And through it all, her tone remains warm, friendly and grounded.

Women In Adult ·
opinion

Outlook 2026: Industry Execs Weigh In on Strategy, Monetization and Risk

The adult industry enters 2026 at a moment of concentrated change. Over the past year, the sector’s evolution has accelerated. Creators have become full-scale businesses, managing branding, compliance, distribution and community under intensifying competition. Studios and platforms are refining production and business models in response to pressures ranging from regulatory mandates to shifting consumer preferences.

Jackie Backman ·
opinion

How Platforms Can Tap AI to Moderate Content at Scale

Every day, billions of posts, images and videos are uploaded to platforms like Facebook, Instagram, TikTok and X. As social media has grown, so has the amount of content that must be reviewed — including hate speech, misinformation, deepfakes, violent material and coordinated manipulation campaigns.

Christoph Hermes ·
opinion

What DSA and GDPR Enforcement Means for Adult Platforms

Adult platforms have never been more visible to regulators than they are right now. For years, the industry operated in a gray zone: enormous traffic, massive data volume and minimal oversight. Those days are over.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
opinion

Making the Case for Network Tokens in Recurring Billing

A declined transaction isn’t just a technical error; it’s lost revenue you fought hard to earn. But here’s some good news for adult merchants: The same technology that helps the world’s largest subscription services smoothly process millions of monthly subscriptions is now available to you as well.

Jonathan Corona ·
Show More