AUSTIN, Texas — Both sides in a lawsuit challenging the “health warning” requirements of Texas’ age verification law for adult websites have motioned for summary judgment in the case.
The actions continue the legal battle over Texas’ HB 1811, the AV law at the heart of the Supreme Court’s pivotal 2025 decision that established the legal framework for age verification laws in the United States.
That legislation originally included provisions requiring adult websites to post warnings detailing numerous alleged harmful effects of pornography, and directing users to a mental health helpline. However, those provisions were blocked by a district court as unconstitutionally forced speech.
That temporary injunction, later upheld by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit, has prevented the “warning” provisions from being enforced even after the Supreme Court upheld the broader law.
The Free Speech Coalition and fellow plaintiffs WebGroup Czech Republic and NKL Associates continued the court battle over HB 1811 by seeking a permanent injunction against the law’s health warning provisions. This week, both the plaintiffs and the state of Texas filed motions seeking summary judgment in the case.
The FSC asked U.S. District Judge David Ezra to rule that the health warnings and notice provisions of HB 1181 are unconstitutional under the First and 14th Amendments because they violate free-speech and due-process rights, and to declare a permanent injunction against their enforcement.
WebGroup and NKL additionally moved for a declaration that not only the warnings but also the law’s age verification requirement are unconstitutional under the Supremacy Clause of the U.S. Constitution, arguing that the law wrongly treats the companies as “publishers” of third-party content when in fact, Section 230 of the federal Communications Decency Act exempts interactive computer services from such a designation, which entails civil liability.
On behalf of the state of Texas, Attorney General Ken Paxton motioned for judgment against the plaintiffs on all issues. Paxton’s motion argues that the notices pass constitutional muster, that the adult companies are not being treated as publishers under Section 230, and that liability under the law does not stem from third-party speech.
Judge Ezra has the option of ruling on all of the issues in the case, ruling on some but letting others proceed to trial, or letting all issues proceed to trial.