TheEroticReview Founder Ordered to Pay $20,000

LOS ANGELES — The founder of TheEroticReview.com has been ordered to pay $20,000 in a default judgment to the online adult model who sued him for copyright infringement.

The Long Beach, Calif., model, named as a Jane Doe in the lawsuit, sued David Elms, along with Elms Web Services for copyright infringement involving photographs from four different shoots.

Doe, who owns a members-only subscription website through her Kentucky-based company BFN LLC, not only made infringement claims but also included charges of defamation and intentional infliction of emotional distress, because TheEroticReview.com’s David Elms allegedly used the model's real birth name in a domain name.

The original complaint also alleged that “Elms directed his anger and vengeance at Doe because she refused to engage in sexual intercourse with him and because Doe refused to allow her name to be published on a website he controls.”

But last year, the court indicated that it would decline to hear most of Doe’s claims against Elms and his company, Elms Web Services, with the exception of copyright infringement.

Last year, Elms and website representatives didn't show up in court despite being incarcerated, leading U.S. Judge George Wu to sign off on the default judgment last month.

At post time, it wasn't clear whether Elms continues to operate TheEroticReview.com. He has been serving time in Arizona, stemming from aggravated assault and conspiracy convictions in Phoenix.

Police said that Elms was seeking to contract out a hit to have a 32-year-old online adult model and escort killed, as well as a 62-year-old webmaster who owns a competing escort review site, SexWork.com.

Elms later fled the U.S. after posting bail of $150,000, possibly traveled to Dubai and then tried to return back to the U.S. through Mexico, authorities said.

Elms is scheduled to be released from prison in March 2013.

Related:  

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Blake Blossom, Derek Kage Cap AEBN's Top Stars for 4th Quarter of 2025

AEBN has revealed its most popular performers in straight and gay theaters for the fourth quarter of 2025.

Eli Cross on Long Days, Lasting Careers and Making Porn That Works

Even after more than 35 years of working in adult, Eli Cross still loves it.

Adult Time Renews Silver Sponsorship for Pineapple Support

Adult Time has renewed its sponsorship of Pineapple Support at the Silver level.

Pornhub to Block UK Users Without Accounts Starting Feb. 2

Pornhub parent company Aylo will block access to its free video-sharing platforms in the United Kingdom starting Feb. 2 unless users have already set up accounts prior to that date, the company announced Tuesday.

Aylo Wins Another Major Piracy Lawsuit

For the second time in recent weeks, Pornhub parent company Aylo has prevailed in a copyright infringement case against sites pirating its content.

FSC Supports OpenAge Initiative and Adoption of AgeKeys for User-Centric Age Assurance

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) announced today that it will support the OpenAge Initiative and its AgeKey cryptographic age assurance solution.

SWR Data Publishes 2026 'Hot List' Report

Adult industry market research outfit SWR Data has published its 2026 Hot List report on the top creator platforms of 2025.

Adult Chat Platform Arousr Sets Human-Only Host Policy

Adult chat platform Arousr has announced a policy to only use verified human hosts, not chatbots.

Arizona State Legislator Proposes Porn Ban

A member of Arizona’s House of Representatives on Wednesday introduced a bill that would make it illegal to produce or distribute adult content in that state.

SinfulX AI to Roll Out New Video Generator

AI companion platform SinfulX AI is launching an upgraded video generator in February.

Show More