Attorneys Comment on Court's 'Obscene Device' Ruling

NEW ORLEANS — Attorneys for Reliable Consultants Inc., the plaintiff in the “obscene device” on which the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled this week, and for Sherri Williams, who has challenged a very similar law in Alabama, applauded the court’s ruling and were hopeful that the court’s reasoning would withstand further review.

“The fact that we got two judges from the second highest court in the land to agree with us is tremendous,” said Jennifer Kinsley of Sirkin Pinales & Schwartz , who represented Reliable Consultants in the case. “It’s a very emotional day for our clients.”

Asked whether she expected the state to request an en banc (full circuit) review of the panel’s decision, Kinsley said “it’s anybody’s guess, but I wouldn’t be at all surprised.”

Reliable Consultants does business in Texas under the names “Dreamers” and “Le Rouge Botique.” Joining the case as a plaintiff after it was initiated by Reliable was PHE, Inc. — better known within adult industry circles as Adam & Eve.

Kinsley said that she thought the ruling was very good news for Williams, as the Alabama statute that Williams has challenged is “virtually identical” to the Texas statute that the 5th Circuit shot down.

“There’s really no intellectually honest way to distinguish between them,” Kinsley said of the two statutes.

Reed Lee of JD Obenberger and Associates, who represented Williams in her challenge of the Alabama statute, concurred with Kinsley, and said that the 5th Circuit’s decision was clearly “in conflict” with the 11th Circuit’s decision in Williams’ case.

“The [5th Circuit] panel majority got it right,” Lee told XBIZ. “This would be pretty straightforward and unremarkable, but for Sherri William’s troubles in the 11th Circuit.”

Lee said that the 5th Circuit panel correctly interpreted Lawrence vs. Texas, the landmark case that resulted in the state’s anti-sodomy law being struck down as unconstitutional.

Asked why it has taken so long for some courts to reach the conclusion that “obscene device” laws are unconstitutional (similar laws have already been struck down in Colorado, Georgia, Kansas and Louisiana), Lee said that the complex nature of the legal issues involved render progress slow.

“This area of substantive due process is a difficult area of law,” Lee said. “It’s because it is so difficult that the courts move so slowly.”

Kinsley said that slow process makes the efforts of plaintiffs like Reliable and Williams all the more remarkable.

“We really appreciated the support and backing of our clients,” Kinsley said of Reliable, adding that their business probably did not stand to profit financially all that much from the law being overturned. “They just felt strongly that their customers were being infringed upon, so they challenged this law and have seen that challenge through, every step of the way.”

As for Williams, whose case the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear last year, Lee said that the 5th Circuit’s ruling this week — assuming it is not overturned by way of an en banc rehearing — “dramatically raises the chances” that the nation’s highest court will at last hear the case.

“The Supreme Court sees one of its primary roles as resolving splits between the circuits,” Lee said.

If the case does reach the Supreme Court, Lee said he’s optimistic that the court will uphold the 5th Circuit panel’s reasoning, especially in light of the court’s ruling in the Lawrence case.

“Five of the justices who decided Lawrence are still there,” Lee noted. “It’s very hard for me to imagine that the same justices who reached the conclusion that a law against sodomy is unconstitutional would decide that a law against sexual devices is not.”

Read the Panel's Decision

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

ProDx Health Introduces 'Power Femme' Test

ProDx Health has introduced its new Power Femme Home Collection Kit.

Orion Expands Cottelli 'Accessoires' Line

Orion Wholesale has introduced five new “It” pieces from its Cottelli Accessories line.

ANME Wraps With Product Drops and Partnerships

ANME wrapped on Wednesday, the event’s third day, after delivering a mix of product launches, power meetings and networking — all while preserving the laid-back vibe that attendees say always makes ANME feel like a homecoming.

Playharda Wholesale, Secret Dome Ink U.K. Distro Deal

Playharda Wholesale and BDSM brand Secret Dome have signed a deal for UK distribution.

Hankey's Toys Releases 'Kitsune's Knot' Dildo

Mr. Hankey's Toys has introduced its new Kitsune’s Knot dildo.

France Reinstates Age Verification Rule for EU Sites

France’s highest court, the Council of State, on Tuesday reinstated age verification rules for EU-based sites under the country’s Security and Regulation of the Digital Space (SREN) law, ruling in favor of the French government and against Hammy Media.

Velvet Thruster Signs Distro Deal With ECN

Velvet Thruster has inked a distribution deal with East Coast News (ECN).

Kiiroo Introduces New Agatha Vega Stroker

Kiiroo has debuted the new Agatha Vega stroker sleeve from its FeelStar line.

European Commission Approves AV Guidelines, Unveils Prototype App

The European Commission on Monday released its final, approved guidelines for protecting minors online under the EU’s Digital Services Act (DSA) and made public a “white label” age verification app intended to help sites and platforms comply with age verification rules under the DSA.

Show More