FSC Files Another Response to DOJ in 2257 Saga

FSC Files Another Response to DOJ in 2257 Saga

PHILADELPHIA, Pa. — Lawyers for the Free Speech Coalition (FSC) and the other plaintiffs in the years-long litigation challenging the constitutionality of 18 U.S.C. § 2257 (known more commonly in the adult industry as “2257”) today filed a response to this month’s brief by the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) before the U. S. Court of Appeals for the 3rd Circuit, which had challenged the government’s initial arguments.

The attorneys for the plaintiffs (called in this stage "appellees/cross-appellants"), J. Michael Murray and Lorraine R. Baumgardner, repeated their April assertion that 2257 — described by the FSC as “a federal record-keeping law aimed at preventing the use of minors in adult productions" — does not serve a "compelling governmental interest,” is not “narrowly tailored” to provide such a service and does not provide the “least restrictive” way to reach that outcome.

Murray and Baumgardner also mentioned the recent Supreme Court decision (Brunetti, aka FUCT), striking down a federal law provision banning the registration of "immoral" or "scandalous" trademarks, calling it an infringement of the First Amendment.

Last August, U.S. District Judge Michael Baylson in Philadelphia gave the FSC and co-plaintiffs a partial victory, finding that large parts of 2257 were unconstitutional on First Amendment grounds. The plaintiffs had also obtained an earlier victory on Fourth Amendment grounds from a 3rd U.S. Circuit ruling.

The Justice Department appealed Baylson’s final judgment and decree late last year. The DOJ filed its brief on March 27. On April 26, FSC attorney Murray filed a response alleging that the plaintiffs’ partial August victory was in fact incomplete (Judge Baylson had upheld two provisions), since given that 2257 “failed the narrow tailoring and least restrictive means components of strict scrutiny,” the lower court “erred in not striking down the Statutes in their entirety.”

The Justice Department filed its own reply to the April 26 response earlier this month. Today’s reply by attorneys for the FSC and other appellants is available in full via the PACER website (login necessary).

As the FSC has previously explained, the 2257 requirements (i.e., anyone who films sexual content must  "maintain and keep detailed records and IDs of the persons depicted in the film, cross-referenced in files, with dates of production, nicknames and copies of the movies,” etc.) do not achieve their stated goal.

“This isn’t about keeping minors out of adult film,” the FSC website explains to newer producers. “The industry is already incredibly stringent about age-verification, as the production of child pornography is not only morally and ethically despicable, it also carries a mandatory minimum of fifteen years in prison. A record-keeping requirement means nothing to a child pornographer. But for legitimate producers, the burdensome and byzantine requirements create numerous ways for producers to be prosecuted and harassed by law enforcement, that have nothing to do with the age of performers.”

Oral argument before the Third Circuit is scheduled for September 10.

For more XBIZ coverage of 2257, click here.

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Romi Rain Fronts Latest From New Sensations

Romi Rain and Codey Steele star in the latest release from New Sensations.

JD Directs New Grazyeli Silva Showcase

Evil Angel has released JD’s Grazyeli Silva showcase, titled "Grazyeli Silva Sexcapades."

Heidi Jo Makes Her WIFEY Debut

Heidi Jo stars with her husband Jerri, Isiah Maxwell, and Hollywood Cash in the latest release from Vixen Media Group studio imprint WIFEY.

Anna Claire Clouds Leads Elegant Angel's 'Shared: A Hotwife Origin Story'

Reigning XMAs Female Performer of the Year Anna Claire Clouds stars in Elegant Angel's new feature thriller "Shared: A Hotwife Origin Story," part of the site's annual "Superstar September" initiative.

Gender X Drops 'Vampirella' Parody

Gender X Films has released its latest feature, "Transpirella," a parody of the 1970s sci-fi horror comic book "Vampirella," directed by Jim Powers.

Aylo Fined $5 Million as FTC, Utah Settle Safety Practices Complaint

The Federal Trade Commission and the state of Utah on Wednesday settled a complaint against Aylo, requiring the company to pay a $5 million penalty and implement measures to prevent illegal content from appearing on its sites.

Jonni Darkko Directs New Chloe Amour Showcase

Evil Angel has released Jonni Darrko’s Chloe Amour showcase, titled "Mon Amour."

Bella Reid Named Penthouse's 'Pet of the Month' for September

Penthouse Magazine has named Bella Reid as Pet of the Month for September.

Andi Avalon Fronts Latest From New Sensations

Andi Avalon and Ken Feels star in the latest release from New Sensations.

Ricky's Room Drops Final Installment of Baby Gemini Showcase

Ricky’s Room has released the final installment of its Baby Gemini showcase, titled "Six Bodies In Motion."

Show More