Supreme Court Ruling Upholds Right to Register 'Immoral,' 'Scandalous' Trademarks

Supreme Court Ruling Upholds Right to Register 'Immoral,' 'Scandalous' Trademarks

WASHINGTON, D.C. — The Supreme Court struck down today a federal law provision banning the registration of "immoral" or "scandalous" trademarks, calling it an infringement of the First Amendment, but Judge Alito called for Congress to legislate more explicitly against what he considers "vulgar" terms.

“The justices' ruling clears the way for a clothing designer to apply for a federal trademark for his clothing line called FUCT,” CNN reported.

Justice Elena Kagan wrote the majority opinion. The ruling was unanimous in part and 6-3 in part. Kagan was joined by Justices Clarence Thomas, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Samuel Alito, Brett Kavanaugh, and Neil Gorsuch in full, while Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Stephen Breyer and Sonia Sotomayor dissented in part.

"We hold that this provision infringes the First Amendment," Kagan wrote, because it "disfavors certain ideas."

The ruling, according to CNN, “could open the doors to more requests to register words or phrases that have been considered vulgar, a concern that the court's minority feared.”

Justice Alito, however, suggested Congress should legislate to more explicitly prevent people from trademarking “vulgar terms,” which he apparently thinks do not play real part in ideological debates.

For the Conservative Justice, nominated by George W. Bush in 2006, Congress should define “vulgar terms” as words that “further coarsen our popular culture.”

FUCT owner, Erik Brunetti, named his brand in 1990 allegedly “to question authority.” Brunetti claims the made-up word, homophone for “fucked,” is actually an acronym for “FRIENDS U CAN'T TRUST."

Brunetti attempted to register his trademark in 2011, but the United States Patent and Trademark Office refused him.

The Patent Office, according to the CNN report, told Brunnetti that FUCT was “the ‘phonetic equivalent’ of the past tense of a vulgar word, and determined that federal law prohibits the registration of trademarks that consist of ‘scandalous’ subject matter.”

"This decision represents a significant victory for First Amendment rights, and will provide broad opportunity for adult businesses that use explicit brand names," Lawrence G. Walters, First Amendment attorney and owner of Walters Law Group told XBIZ. "Some of our clients have been waiting for this decision for many years. The idea that the USPTO could deny trademark registration based on a moral viewpoint has always conflicted with free speech rights. This case finally puts any doubt about that issue to rest."

"The opinion itself," Walters continued "is important for First Amendment jurisprudence going forward, particularly in viewpoint discrimination cases. As Justice Alito said, 'viewpoint discrimination is poison to a free society.' The Court made clear that the First Amendment will not tolerate government censorship based on viewpoint."

The Supreme Court Justices were more concerned with the wording of the federal law, which could be interpreted as preventing “the expression of ideas.”

Kagan’s opinion stressed that the law "does not draw the line at lewd, sexually explicit, or profane marks,” but could be applied to "the universe of immoral or scandalous" material. "A law disfavoring 'ideas that offend' discriminates based on viewpoint, in violation of the First Amendment," wrote Kagan.

According to CNN, the partial dissent, by Chief Justice Roberts and Justices Breyer and Sotomayor, “would have saved part of the statute that prohibits ‘scandalous’ trademarks. Breyer said he would do so because "these attention-grabbing words" may lead "to the creation of public spaces that many will find repellant, perhaps on occasion creating the risk of verbal altercations or even physical confrontations."

"Just think about how you might react if you saw someone wearing a t-shirt or using a product emblazoned with an odious racial epithet,” Breyer wrote.

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Ashby Winter Performs Her 1st DP in Finale of VMG Cross-Site 'In Vogue' Sequel

Ashby Winter performs her first DP alongside Dimitri Shadow and Troy Francisco in the final scene from Vixen Media Group (VMG) cross-site feature "In Vogue 2."

Addison Vodka on Playing Nice - and Playing Rough

‘It’s such a funny story,” says Addison Vodka, tossing her long, beachy blonde waves over her shoulder. “I discovered that my boyfriend at the time was using camming websites behind my back. So I was like, ‘Well, if you’re going to go on there, then I’m just going to go on there.’”

Rana Katana Stars in Latest From TransAngels

Rana Katana stars with Raj and Ram Sivan in the latest release from TransAngels, titled “Submissive Hookah Slut.”

Ana Foxxx Returns to Elegant Angel for 'A Night Out'

Ana Foxxx stars with Chad Alva in the new release from Elegant Angel, titled “A Night Out.”

Nothosaur Marks Pride Month With Rainbow-Colored Pleasure Products

Pleasure brand Nothosaur has introduced its rainbow color series of fantasy dildos for Pride month.

ULoversDoll Debuts Transgender Love Dolls

ULoversDoll has introduced a new line of transgender dolls from its Dolls Castle collection.

Teasy Agency Joins Pineapple Support as Supporter-Level Sponsor

Teasy Agency has joined the ranks of over 70 adult businesses and organizations committing funds and resources to Pineapple Support.

Scarlett Alexis, Chloe Surreal Topline 'Lesbian Stunners 2' From Lesbian X

Scarlett Alexis and Chloe Surreal headline the second volume of "Lesbian Stunners" from X Empire studio brand Lesbian X.

'Golden Age' Director Paul Thomas Passes Away at 76

Legendary adult filmmaker Paul Thomas has passed away after spending most of his life in the porn business. He was 76.

Unpacking the Pleasure Industry's Friend-or-Foe Status With Mainstream Outlets

Over the years, pleasure products have increasingly made their way into big-box stores and mainstream marketing channels. As a result, brands now face a complicated balancing act.

Show More