Porn Piracy Defendant Uses 2257 as Weapon

CHICAGO — A John Doe defendant fingered for allegedly poaching porn off a file-sharing site made charges last week that adult producer Malibu Media's 18 U.S.C. § 2257 record-keeping  documents may be "incomplete, deficient or even fabricated."

Malibu Media brought a suit against Doe in July after it said it traced 19 copyrighted movies downloaded from a BitTorrent site to his IP address. Titles such as "Spilled Milk," Mutual Orgasm" and "Circle of Bliss" were poached by Doe, the suit said.

But Doe, responsding to the accusations, has filed a counterclaim seeking declaratory relief because of copyright misuse on the part of Malibu Media. He also is asking for the case be dismissed because Malibu Media hasn't attached his true name to the suit.

Malibu Media produces and distributes content mostly through X-Art.com and has become one of the most prolific companies when it comes to consumer piracy litigation. Records obtained by XBIZ show the studio has waged 1,421 copyright infringement lawsuits in the past two years.  

Doe said that Malibu's claims fail partly because many of the models performing in the movies, all available on X-Art.com, appear to be young females hailing from former-Soviet block countries, such as the Czech Republic, Slovakia, Russia, Hungary and Romania, where record-keeping requirements for porn performers are much less stringent.

If the record-keeping requirements fail for a film, Doe said, so does its copyright protection.

"Doe is informed and believes ... that the 2257 records for certain of the  pornographic movies at issue in the complaint in this action may be incomplete, deficient or even fabricated," Doe said.

"[T]he problem of unscrupulous agents, managers, talent scouts and sometimes the performers themselves providing incomplete, insufficient or even fake identity documents is particularly acute with female performers from former-Soviet-block countries, among other problem areas."

Doe also charged that Malibu Media has made a business model out of porn copyright infringement litigation by seeding some of its content onto BitTorrent services.

"Malibu, under the overall direction of plaintiff’s law firm Lipscomb, Eisenberg & Baker of Miami and with day-to-day assistance  from regional local counsel, has been systematically suing John Doe defendants for infringement and then seeking settlements on a scale seldom seen in the history of federal litigation," he said.

Attorney Morgan Pietz, who represents the Doe, wouldn't comment on the Malibu Media  case specifically. But the Manhattan Beach, Calif., attorney said that the 2257 weapon for porn file-sharing defendants is worth looking at.

"I know the adult industry views Section 2257 compliance as frustrating and difficult, even unconstitutional. But that law serves to safeguard important public policy interests, namely preventing illegal child pornography," Pietz told XBIZ.

"Should the Copyright Act extend protection to a movie that was produced in violation of a law designed to protect that strong public policy? It is an interesting legal issue and one I look forward to exploring," he said.

"The recent phenomenon of adult content  owners using their copyrights as swords, rather than shields, in industrial-scale, end-user litigation, would seem to invite this kind of scrutiny."

Mary Schulz, a Geneva, Ill.-based attorney representing Malibu Media and its X-Art division, did not respond for comment by post time.

View John Doe's answers over Malibu Media/X-Art.com lawsuit

Related:  

Copyright © 2023 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

New Mexico AG: Pornhub, OnlyFans Safer Than Facebook, Instagram

The office of New Mexico’s Attorney General Raúl Torrez admitted in a statement announcing the state’s lawsuit against Meta that some instances of CSAM are ten times “more prevalent” on Facebook and Instagram than on Pornhub and OnlyFans.

Fiji Government to Launch Task Force to Reduce Porn Viewership

Fiji’s government has decided to take action after a political and media campaign that sensationalized the issue of access to adult material in the island nation, and has announced a forthcoming “task force” aiming to reduce porn viewership among its citizens.

Skinfluential Media Launches New 'Cosplayground' Site

Skinfluential Media has debuted a new site, Cosplayground, focused on cosplay and porn parodies.

Tennessee Republican Proposes Felony Charges in Copycat Age Verification Bill

Republican state Rep. Patsy Hazlewood on Wednesday filed an age verification bill with the Tennessee state legislature, a copycat version of the numerous age verification bills being advanced by religious conservatives and anti-porn crusaders around the country.

Byborg's Le Shaw Research Institute Appoints New Directors

LiveJasmin parent company Byborg Enterprises has appointed Bobbi Bidochka and Simon Dubéof to head its Le Shaw International Sexual Health and Wellness Research Institute.

Amie Harwick's Murderer Sentenced to Life Without Parole

The convicted murderer of Pineapple Support therapist Amie Harwick was sentenced on Wednesday to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

UK Government Unveils Controversial Age Verification Guidelines for Adult Content

U.K. media regulator Ofcom, the government authority tasked by the recently enacted Online Safety Act with online content restriction enforcement, issued on Tuesday its first guidance to adult websites regarding age verification.

Ethical Capital Partners' Solomon Friedman to Deliver XBIZ 2024 Keynote

XBIZ is pleased to announce that Ethical Capital Partners (ECP) partner and VP of Compliance Solomon Friedman will deliver the keynote address at XBIZ 2024, set for Jan. 15-18.

The Guardian Continues Publishing Anti-Porn Articles Funded by U.S. Billionaire

Over three years after XBIZ reported on how an obscure U.S. foundation was sponsoring anti-porn content in The Guardian newspaper, the self-proclaimed “world’s leading liberal voice” continues publishing slanted pieces calling for state regulation of adult content online.

Ron Jeremy's Release to Private Residence Granted at Hollywood Mental Health Court

An LA County judge in the Hollywood mental health courthouse granted on Thursday a petition by Ron Jeremy’s conservator to release him to a private residence.

Show More