U.S. Appeals Court Draws Bright Line Between Software Owners, Licensees

SAN FRANCISCO — A federal appeals court on Friday ruled that copyright’s "first sale doctrine" doesn’t apply to software, and possibly DVDs and other licensed content, as long as the vendor saddles the transfer with enough restrictions.

The decision is significant because it ensures software buyers will rarely be software owners, and the potential effects of the decision could turn simple breach of contract claims into copyright infringement suits for violating end-user license agreements.

The first sale doctrine limits a copyright holder’s right to exclusive distribution by allowing owners of copies of copyrighted works to resell those copies, but it makes no such exception for a person who possesses such a copy without owning it, such as a licensee.

Limiting the first sale doctrine’s applicability to so-called “shrinkwrap” licensing agreements, the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals agreed with software producer Autodesk Inc. that the terms it required customers to accept before they could install its software made the customers licensees of the copies — not owners.

The ruling by a three-judge panel tossed out a U.S. district judge’s ruling that an eBay merchant could sell used copies of software regardless of any agreement binding those from whom he purchased the copies.

Timothy Vernor bought four packages of Autodesk's AutoCAD software at a garage sale and tried to sell them on eBay but Autodesk threatened Vernor with a copyright lawsuit, claiming that its software is only “licensed” — never sold — pointing to the fine print on the end-user license agreements it had with the original purchaser.

Vernor filed suit in Seattle against Autodesk, asking the court to clarify his right to resell the computer-aided design software packages that he purchased. He prevailed before a lower federal court in 2009, when a federal judge held that he was a successive owner and entitled to resell copies he purchased under the first sale doctrine. Autodesk later appealed to the 9th Circuit.

Writing for the 9th Circuit, Judge Consuelo M. Callahan ruled that “a software user is a licensee rather than an owner of a copy where the copyright owner (1) specifies that the user is granted a license, (2) significantly restricts the user’s ability to transfer the software and (3) imposes notable use restrictions.”

The Electronic Frontier Foundation, which filed an amicus brief in the case, called Friday's decision "deeply disappointing" and "very bad news for consumers."

"We understand Mr. Vernor may seek en banc review of this decision," Corynne McSherry, an EFF senior staff attorney, told XBIZ. "We hope that the court agrees to review the case and treats it as an opportunity to put consumer rights and expectations ahead of the overreaching demands of software vendors."

The case is Vernor vs. Autodesk Inc., 09-35969.

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Kitana Montana Makes Directorial Debut With New DVD Release

Kitana Montana has made her directorial debut with her new DVD release, “Goddess Cuckold.”

Jason Luv on Balancing Stardom, Strength and Self-Mastery

For Jason Luv, it all started with being in the right place at the right time. “Vixen Media Group was looking for new male talent,” he recalls. “They found me from a previous modeling shoot and reached out. That’s where my career began.”

Nata Gold, Zazie Skymm Star in Latest From MixedX

Nata Gold and Zazie Skymm star in the latest release from MixedX, titled “Love Me or Hate Me.”

British Documentary Spotlights XBIZ Amsterdam With Candid Conversations

British creator and host Josh Pieters traveled to XBIZ Amsterdam to film a documentary about the annual European adult industry conference.

Zariah Aura, Emma Rosie Front Latest From TransAngels

Zariah Aura and Emma Rosie star in the latest release from TransAngels, titled “Trick or Treating Ourselves.”

Krystal Sparks Stars in Latest Release From TeamSkeet

Krystal Sparks stars with Joshua Lewis in the latest scene from TeamSkeet’s “Freeuse” series, titled “Suck My Cock, Stepmom! Captain’s Orders!”

Frenchy Makes Her WIFEY Debut

Frenchy stars with her husband Bruce in the latest release from Vixen Media Group studio imprint WIFEY.

Gia Derza Toplines Bryan Gozzling's 'Hookup Hotshot: Internet Sex Addicts Volume 4'

Gia Derza headlines director Bryan Gozzling’s “Hookup Hotshot: Internet Sex Addicts Volume 4” from Evil Angel.

XBIZ 2026 to Debut 'New Talent Go-See' Special Event

XBIZ 2026, North America’s premier adult industry conference, will debut a special event designed to help new talent jump-start their careers: the New Talent Go-See.

Octavia Red on Channeling Loss, Love and Liberation Into Her Craft

Octavia Red makes no bones about her life before porn. “I was working a shitty little casino job, getting sexually harassed by toothless drug dealers,” she recalls. “And they don’t even tip!”

Show More