The Secrets We Share

When Anna (Lilly Bell) arrives at the quaint, suburban home of Margaret (Penny Barber) for her college summer immersion program, she's beyond excited. But the longer she is in this house, the more strange she finds the family dynamic. Margaret seems overly interested in her stepsons Paul and Henry, Margaret's husband Edward (Charles Dera) feels like he might be hiding some unsavory desires, and Margaret's son John (Max Fills) seems unstable but oddly approachable. Is Anna imagining all of this angst, or is there more to this family than meets the eye?

Bree Mills and her Pure Taboo studio are known for pushing the boundaries of sexual expectations, and "The Secrets We Share" is a twisted tale of manipulation, depravity, and debauchery. The tale belongs to Anna, a 20-year-old exchange student taking part in a summer immersion program. Margaret, the sultry woman of the house, greets her warmly before introducing her to her two boisterous stepsons Henry (Axel Haze) and Paul (Tyler Cruise) as well as her reclusive biological son John. At first, things seem fine. But the more time Anna spends in Margaret's home, the more things seem off to her. Margaret is a little too friendly with Henry, and Paul is a little too cold with John. She reaches out and is shocked to find John to be quite personable, albeit eccentric. His drawings of his mother are borderline creepy, but Anna's friendly demeanor causes John to open up to her in a way that feels much more genuine than Margaret's carefully curated persona. John tells Anna about the tension that grew between him and his mother after his father left, and how that tension only grew after Margaret married Edward.

John's suspicions that his mother is regularly fucking her new stepsons turns out to be true as Anna witnesses the family matriarch having the time of her life astride Henry's thick cock one night. Axel gives it to Penny nicely, filling her pussy to the brim with his meat and causing the busty MILF to squirt all over him several times.

Meanwhile, Anna and John share a vulnerable moment that really works to build not only their dynamic, but also, to paint John in a very different light than how Margaret describes him. I love when porn uses its sex scenes to further the narrative, and this scene is the definition of that device. Anna rocks John's world (my goodness, the cowgirl!) and she gets rocked by a number of powerful orgasms in return. Later on, Margaret gets a chance to show the audience exactly why Edward married her as she peels his lid off with her mouth and pussy. I mean, what a sexual dynamo Penny is! From the way she presents her pussy for Dera to use, to the wanton way she sucks on his toes as she fingerbangs herself to a wet orgasm all over him, she is the perfect slut for her man — and it's awesome.

Things get a lot more taboo when Edwards comes calling for Anna. Before the sex starts, Lilly puts on an acting clinic, and it makes the scene work 10 times better than had they just gotten right to the horny bits. The timidity, hesitance, and fear Bell portrays steams things up and nails the Pure Taboo vibe in a way that must be seen to be believed.

The final sexual encounter comes in the form of Margaret taking advantage of Anna in a much different way than Edward. It's still creepy, and the power dynamic is still unbalanced. But the way she coerces Anna into folding is more insidious than Edward's smarmy approach, and it will trigger suppressed desires in the audience. My goodness, Penny is a helluva performer.

The story ends on a twist that I won't spoil. "The Secrets We Share" is recommend it to anyone who loves a good plot to go along with their smut.