N.Y. Court Changes Definition of 'Depict' to Include Text

ALBANY, N.Y. — In a 5-2 decision, the Court of Appeals decided that the word "depict," when used in regards to sending material depicting obscenity to minors, is no longer limited to just images — reserve reversing a previous ruling that left graphic words protected from prosecution.

The court determined that someone can be charged with disseminating material harmful to minors over the Internet even when the material contains only text. This went against a 2004 ruling by a lower N.Y. court, in which charges were dismissed after the emails in question were found to be without images and therefore, by then-definition, did not depict offensive acts.

"This is a truly dreadful ruling," 1st Amendment attorney Jeffrey Douglas told XBIZ. "The worst part is that in order to reach a verdict, the court distorted the meaning of the law."

Douglas said this ruling was "sadly typical" in the sense that the high court distorted the intentions of the original legislation to protect imaginary children, rather than dealing with reality.

Writing for the court's majority, Judge Eugene Pigott Jr. said, "The Legislature [in 2004] was surely aware that a sexually explicit text may be used as a means of seduction just as effectively as a sexual image. They could not have thought that this process was limited to the transmission of pornographic images. Indeed, the logic of communication dictates just the opposite — that images alone would not enable toe sender to entice a minor to a meeting."

The 2004 case involved Jeffrey Kozlow of Westchester County who was arrested after having sent a months-long series of emails to a 14-year-old boy explicitly describing sexual acts. He later scheduled a meeting with the minor, at which he was arrested.

His dissemination of indecent materials conviction was reversed after a mid-level court said prosecutors failed to prove Kozlow had "depict[ed]" obscene materials, since no images were sent in any of his email messages.

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

North Dakota Legislature Backs Off on Device-Based AV

A North Dakota state senator who sponsored a device-based age verification bill that Free Speech Coalition (FSC) endorsed is now seeking to amend the bill to require site-based age verification instead.

NYC Adult Stores May Face Enforcement of 2001 Zoning Law

Adult retail stores in New York City are bracing for a potential crisis as an appeals court considers whether to allow enforcement of a 2001 city zoning law aimed at forcing them out of most parts of the city.

FSC Brings Adult Industry Debanking Issues to Congressional Hearing

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) recently had its "Statement for the Record" on the debanking of adult industry members read to the U.S. House of Representatives.

Solomon Friedman of Ethical Capital Partners Profiled in Canada's National Post

Solomon Friedman of Ethical Capital Partners, the investment group that controls Aylo and its flagship website, Pornhub, is profiled this week in Canada's National Post newspaper.

Under EU Rules, Apple Permits 1st Porn App on iPhone

Apple has begrudgingly approved the first porn app for use on iPhones, which is now available in Europe.

Ofcom Closes OnlyFans Age-Gating Investigation

U.K. communications regulator Ofcom has discontinued an investigation into whether OnlyFans violated the Online Safety Act (OSA) by failing to prevent minors from viewing adult content.

New York Joins List of States Weighing AV Bills

New York is the latest state to consider legislation that would require adult sites to verify the ages of users seeking to access adult content.

New Mexico State Rep Gets Pushback on Copycat AV Bill

A New Mexico state legislative committee on Friday sent the conservative Republican sponsor of new age verification legislation back to the drawing board, citing concerns about the proposed bill’s effectiveness and practicality.

Professor Fired Over Adult Content Sues U Wisconsin

Veteran communications professor Joe Gow this week filed a civil lawsuit against the University of Wisconsin board of regents for violating his First Amendment rights by firing him for creating and appearing in adult content.

Ofcom to Hold Online Sessions on OSA Compliance

U.K. communications regulator Ofcom will hold an online conference Feb. 3-5, titled “The Online Safety Act Explained: How to Comply,” to explain new duties and deadlines required of adult businesses to implement age assurance under the Online Safety Act (OSA).

Show More