Florida Court Denies Shield for iPhone Passcode

Florida Court Denies Shield for iPhone Passcode

LAKELAND, Fla. — A Florida man suspected of voyeurism can be compelled to tell police his iPhone passcode so they can search it for incriminating photos, a Florida appellate court ruled last week.

Aaron Stahl was arrested after a woman who was shopping in a store saw him crouch down and extend an illuminated cellphone under her skirt, court records said.

The victim confronted him, and the man told her that he had dropped his cellphone. While yelling for assistance, the victim attempted to detain the man, but he was able to free himself and flee the store before assistance arrived.

Police were able to identify him using his car’s license plate number, and he was was arrested for third-degree voyeurism.

In a police interview, Stahl initially gave verbal consent to a search of his Apple iPhone 5, but he withdrew his consent before telling police his four-digit passcode.

Once police obtained a warrant for the phone, they were still unable to access the photos on the phone.

But without the four-digit passcode known only to the user even Apple cannot extract the data from the phone because the encryption key is tied to the passcode. After 10 failed attempts to enter the passcode, an iPhone will lock and likely erase its contents.

A Florida judge earlier denied the state’s motion to compel Stahl to give up his passcode, ruling that it would be tantamount to forcing him to testify against himself in violation of the Fifth Amendment.

But the Florida Court of Appeal’s Second District, in an opinion written by Judge Anthony Black, reversed that decision last week, ruling that the passcode is not related to any criminal photos or videos found on the phone.

“Providing the passcode does not ‘betray any knowledge [Stahl] may have about the circumstances of the offenses’ for which he is charged,” Black said, writing for the three-judge panel.

Black further said that he questioned the viability of any distinction between passcodes and use of touch ID fingerprints as technology advances. 

“[W]e are not inclined to believe that the Fifth Amendment should provide greater protection to individuals who passcode protect their iPhones with letter and number combinations than to individuals who use their fingerprint as the passcode,” Black wrote.

“Compelling an individual to place his finger on the iPhone would not be a protected act; it would be an exhibition of a physical characteristic, the forced production of physical evidence, not unlike being compelled to provide a blood sample or provide a handwriting exemplar.”

Industry attorney Larry Walters of Walters Law Group told XBIZ today that the Stahl case is another example of how digital privacy rights are being chipped away.

“There is a conflict in the courts regarding whether the Fifth Amendment protects a citizen’s right to refuse to give up a password,” Walters said. “Some courts have concluded that enforcing such an obligation requires the citizen to reveal what’s in his or her mind. That seems to be obviously within the scope of what the Fifth Amendment was designed to protect.

"If we believe in the right against self- incrimination, how can we say the government should be able to force you to reveal ‘secret’ codes that only you know?"

Walters said that the appellate court “took a very narrow view of the importance of a cellphone passcode.”

“Basically, the court said that the state already has all of the information that the passcode will reveal, so forcing the defendant to reveal the passcode doesn’t add much to the state’s case,” Walters said. “So, the court decided it would be OK to force the defendant to reveal the passcode, since the information was a foregone conclusion.

“However, that’s not accurate since the state would not likely have any of the crucial evidence necessary to prove the voyeurism offense without the passcode.

Unfortunately, Walters said, in the law bad decisions can produce other bad decisions.

“Part of this court’s ruling was based on a prior case that said the government can force you to use your thumbprint to unlock a phone, since that’s different from providing the actual password. That’s more like providing a mugshot, blood sample or fingerprint, according to the prior decision.

“Based on that case, this court reasons that there should be no real difference in whether you unlock a phone using your fingerprint or a passcode. The court is right on that one — but both should be deemed ‘testimonial’ and protected by the Fifth Amendment.”

View appellate decision

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Creator of Hentaied, Parasited Launches New Site 'Vampired'

Romero Mr. Alien, the creator of Parasited and Hentaied, has launched Vampired.com as both a stand-alone paysite and part of the Hentaied.Pro streaming platform.

Australian eSafety Commissioner Demands Stricter Child Protection Codes

Australia’s online safety regulator, eSafety, is once again reviewing a “final” draft of industry codes to protect children from pornography and other age-inappropriate content, after eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant rejected the previously announced “final” codes as insufficiently stringent.

Nerdgasm: A Look at the Naughty Side of Pop Culture Geekdom

From “Call of Duty” to cosplay, from tabletop dice rolls to dungeon-inspired dirty talk, the worlds of geek fandom and fantasy are no longer confined to the basement. They’ve kicked down the door, shed the “Firefly” tee and gone full frontal.

Kyrgyzstan Parliament Moves to Outlaw Internet Pornography

A parliamentary committee of the Supreme Council of Kyrgyzstan on Tuesday approved a measure to outlaw online adult content in the country.

Sweden Bans Purchase of 'Remote' Sexual Services

The Riksdag, Sweden’s parliament, has approved a proposal to criminalize purchasing sexual services performed remotely by streamers and custom content creators.

Asa Akira to Deliver XBIZ Talk at Miami Conference

XBIZ is pleased to announce that decorated performer, Pornhub brand ambassador, and author Asa Akira is set to deliver an exclusive talk at XBIZ Miami.

JustFor.fans Launches 'Fentanyl Test Strip' Initiative

JustFor.fans (JFF) has launched a test strip initiative to combat the nationwide fentanyl crisis.

2025 XBIZ Miami Speaker Lineup Announced

XBIZ is pleased to announce the release of the full speaker lineup for XBIZ Miami, the latest edition of the adult industry’s premier summer conference, set to take place May 19-22 at the Nautilus Sonesta Miami Beach hotel in South Beach.

AV Bulletin: Arizona's About-Face, What New Laws Mean for Adult

Industry stakeholders and free speech advocates have anxiously been awaiting the Supreme Court’s decision in Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton, which could significantly impact state age verification laws around the United States. In the meantime, state legislatures continue to weigh and pass AV bills, the U.K. and the EU are moving ahead with their own AV mandates and strategies, and legal challenges continue to play out in U.S. courts — with some cases on hold pending the SCOTUS ruling in Paxton.

Million Billion Media Launches New Website

Management and PR agency Million Billion Media (MBM) has launched a new website.

Show More