Federal Court: No Constitutional Right to Engage in Consensual BDSM

Federal Court: No Constitutional Right to Engage in Consensual BDSM

ALEXANDRIA, Va. — A federal court recently ruled that there is no constitutional right to practice consensual BDSM sex.

The case at hand centers on plaintiff John Doe, a student who was expelled from George Mason University for allegedly having sex with a woman without her consent by refusing to stop a BDSM sexual act when his sexual partner uttered their safe word — “red.”

Doe sued the university when administrators expelled him after he was probed by the school’s Sexual Misconduct Board, which held a 10-hour hearing on the matter.

Jane Roe, Doe’s BDSM partner, claimed a “substantial procedural irregularity” had occurred since his first exoneration— “in Roe’s view, plaintiff confessed” after he later replied to a conversation with Roe via a taped telephone conversation made by school detectives.

According to court documents, Roe asked him “why [he] never stopped when [she] used the safe word.” Doe replied that he “felt like [she] could handle it.” 

In his lawsuit against the school, Doe contended that George Mason University administrators “disregarded” the context of his relationship with Roe and instead acted like BDSM sex was “per se sexual misconduct.”

Doe argued that the university administrators’ decision to not understand the context of the relationship between Roe and him stood in violation of the U.S. Supreme Court case Lawrence v. Texas, which struck down laws against consensual same-sex intimate activity between adults.

Last month, U.S. District Judge T.S. Ellis III dismissed the case through summary judgment, ruling that the university had violated Doe’s right to due process by not handling the appeals process properly.

However, Ellis in his ruling, said there is no constitutional right for consenting adults to engage in BDSM.

“Engaging in BDSM sexual activity is clearly not protected” under the U.S. Constitution, Ellis said. “[T]here is no basis to conclude that tying up a willing submissive sex partner and subjecting him or her to whipping, choking, or other forms of domination is deeply rooted in the nation’s history and traditions or implicit in the concept of ordered liberty.”

Because such activity “poses certain inherent risks to personal safety,” the court said, governments could claim a legitimate interest in regulating it for “the protection of vulnerable persons” who have chosen to enter BDSM relationships.

Ellis in his decision said that, “consistent with the logic of Lawrence, plaintiff has no constitutionally protected and judicially enforceable fundamental liberty interest under the Due Process Clause of the 14th Amendment to engage in BDSM sexual activity.”

View ruling

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Natassia Dreams, Foxxy, Banksie to Host TEAs Red Carpet

The Trans Erotica Awards has announced a trio of red carpet hosts for 2024: Natassia Dreams, Foxxy and Banksie.

MYLF Premieres 'Everyone Cums Everywhere, All at Once' Finale

MYLF has released the final episode of its Milfwood title "Everyone Cums Everywhere, All at Once," featuring February MYLF of the Month Suki Sin.

Bazowie Awards to Livestream Today

SexyFandom.com has announced their 2024 Bazowie Awards, presented by Zinetastic, with Platinum Sponsor Bad Dragon, will be held virtually today. There will be an interactive chat, for ticketed guests only, available during the event.

Sensex Debuts 'Feature Fridays' Live Events

Sensex is launching Feature Fridays, a series of gatherings where fans can meet, chat with and watch content alongside their favorite performers.

Adult Creative Unveils PPC Services

Web design and marketing firm Adult Creative has launched a new suite of pay-per-click (PPC) services.

Roxy Shaw is March 2024 'Hustler Honey'

The March 2024 issue of Hustler magazine is out, featuring Roxy Shaw as this month’s cover model and Hustler Honey.

Gov. DeSantis Vetoes Florida's Age Verification Bill, Endorses Forthcoming Alternative

Gov. Ron DeSantis has vetoed HB 1, a bill in the Florida state legislature that originally restricted anyone under 16 from accessing social media, but was then combined with a separate bill mandating age verification of adult content.

Digital Playground Debuts Ricky Greenwood's New Western 'Gold Diggers'

Digital Playground has premiered new western feature “Gold Diggers,” directed by Ricky Greenwood.

Adult Time Adds Casey Calvert to Ambassador Program

Adult Time has added performer, director and multiple XBIZ Award winner Casey Calvert to its ambassador program.

Bemefi.com Launches Through YourPaysitePartner

Bemefi.com, the official website of fetish and gonzo studio Bemefi Video, has launched through YourPaysitePartner (YPP).

Show More