Backpage Appeal Is of ‘Critical Importance,’ Industry Attorney Says

Backpage Appeal Is of ‘Critical Importance,’ Industry Attorney Says

CHICAGO — A recently filed amicus brief from the CATO Institute and the Reason Foundation in the Backpage case debunks the repeated myths circulated about sex trafficking and highlights the governmental efforts to conflate prostitution with trafficking, according to industry attorney Lawrence Walters.

CATO and Reason’s friend-of-the court brief to the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals asks for the court to reverse a lower court’s decision to deny a preliminary injunction request that would have forced Cook County Sheriff Tom Dart to retract statements he made in lobbying credit card companies to block their cards from being used to buy sex ads on Backpage.com.

In August, U.S. District Judge John Tharp wrote that the “cease and desist" letters Dart wrote to Visa and Mastercard warning them that Backpage was a haven for prostitution and human trafficking could have been construed as threats.

However, Tharp said that they did not amount to censorship, since the sheriff had no legal authority to force the credit card companies to act.

The ruling doesn’t affect Backpage’s lawsuit against Dart seeking damages for what website claims was a crippling blow to its business model.

Dart has maintained that there have been years of growth in sex trade, driving demand even higher and increasing the enslavement of prostituted individuals, including children.

Backpage claimed that the sheriff’s actions have "effected an informal extralegal prior restraint of speech without due process.”

“The facts laid out in this amicus brief convincingly debunk the oft-repeated myths regarding the scope and nature of sex trafficking in the U.S.,” industry attorney Lawrence Walters told XBIZ. “Media outlets feed on the hysteria, and eagerly recite claims that trafficking is on the rise — usually without any verification of the underlying facts.

“However, as pointed out in the brief, the incidence of sex trafficking victims may actually be on the decrease in recent years. Previous estimates regarding the shocking number of ‘victims’ appear to be no more than guesses, or calculations of ‘at risk’ juveniles.”

Even the Government Accountability Office has expressed doubt regarding their accuracy, Walters noted.

“Nonetheless, these faulty statistics have been the basis for numerous recent trafficking laws, which impose harsher penalties and permit enhanced surveillance techniques. Add in the perverse incentives given to law enforcement to make more arrests, and the parallels to the failed ‘War on Drugs’ could not be more apparent.

Walters said it was interesting to note the increasing conflation of the concepts of sex trafficking with garden variety prostitution.

“Blurring the lines between these two very distinct offenses is at the heart of the anti-sex trafficking movement’s effort to eliminate the entire sex trade,” he said.

Walters said that ironically, as noted by amicus curiae, Sheriff Dart’s focus on cutting off credit card processing for Backpage eliminates an important tool for law enforcement to investigate and prosecute real trafficking cases.

“Credit cards leave a digital footprint that can provide critical evidence in criminal prosecutions. By eliminating this payment method, Sheriff Dart appears to be imposing a self-inflicted wound, resulting in less effective law enforcement.

“Perhaps most importantly, the brief points out the key error committed by the trial court in denying the injunction requested by Backpage: It presumed that most if not all escort ads on Backpage were illegal, without any actual review of the evidence.

“The First Amendment requires the opposite. Speech — even commercial speech — is presumed to be protected until proven otherwise by the government. The outcome of this case will be of critical importance to advertising networks and the development of free speech jurisprudence.”

CATO and Reason were joined by other non-party groups in separate friend-of-the court briefs in Backpage's appeal at the 7th Circuit. The Center for Democracy & Technology, Electronic Frontier Foundation and Association of Alternative Newsmedia filed their cases against the lower court ruling.

View amicus brief

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Trump Administration Issues Executive Order Against 'Debanking'

The White House on Thursday issued an executive order limiting financial institutions’ ability to restrict access to financial services for people or groups involved in lawful industries, a longtime goal of adult industry advocates and stakeholders.

Go.cam Launches Free Age Verification Solution, Anti-Fraud Features

Go.cam has announced that its age verification solution is now free with updated anti-fraud and identity protection features.

Florida AG Sues EU-Based Adult Companies for Failing to Age-Verify Users

Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier filed a lawsuit Monday with the 12th Judicial Circuit Court of Florida against five EU-based adult companies for allegedly failing to require age verification before allowing access to adult content.

SkyPrivate Launches 'Telegram Pay-Per-Minute' Feature

SkyPrivate has launched a new pay-per-minute (PPM) private show option on Telegram.

Pineapple Support to Host 'Money and Mental Health' Online Event

Pineapple Support is hosting a free, online event to help performers balance financial wellbeing with mental health, Aug. 18-19.

Arcom Warns 5 Adult Sites Over Age Verification

French media regulator Arcom has sent enforcement notices to the operators of five adult websites that the agency says have failed to implement age verification as required under France’s Security and Regulation of the Digital Space (SREN) law.

MojoHost Debuts NVIDIA Blackwell-Powered Hosting

MojoHost has announced the launch of NVIDIA Blackwell-powered hosting featuring RTX 6000 Pro MaxQ GPUs.

FSC: Identity Theft Targeting Adult Performers

The Free Speech Coalition has put out an alert warning of an individual found to be targeting adult performers for identity theft.

Assylum.com Implements New Age Verification System

Assylum.com has introduced an age verification system across its member sites.

European Commission to Assess Pornhub, XVideos, XNXX Compliance With Digital Services Act

The European Commission plans to conduct a study to determine how well adult sites Pornhub, XVideos and XNXX are addressing illegal content and other potential harms under the EU’s Digital Services Act.

Show More