EFF Seeks Rehearing in Takedown Notification Case

EFF Seeks Rehearing in Takedown Notification Case

SAN FRANCISCO — The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has been asked to revisit the “dancing baby” case by the Electronic Frontier Foundation.

Last month, a 9th Circuit panel found that copyright owners must consider the fair use doctrine before sending Digital Millennium Copyright Act takedown notices to online hosts.

The panel affirmed a lower court’s decision for summary judgment in an action under the DMCA alleging that Universal Music Group's violated 17 U.S.C. § 512(f) by misrepresenting in a takedown notification that plaintiff Stephanie Lenz’s home video of her baby dancing constituted an infringing use of a portion of a Prince composition.

The appeals court last month said copyright owners like Universal can only send takedown notices if they’ve come to a good faith conclusion that the targeted upload is not a protected fair use of the copyrighted work.

Now, in an petition for rehearing made this week, the EFF on behalf of Lenz asked the court to rehear en banc to address the question: Whether Congress, in drafting the safe harbor provisions of the DMCA intended to grant private parties the practical power to censor speech based on an unreasonable belief that a copyright has been infringed, as long as that belief is (like all beliefs) subjectively held.

Lenz, who acquired pro bono counsel from the Electronic Frontier Foundation, sued Universal in 2007, arguing that the media giant’s takedown practices violated the DMCA.

The EFF in its brief submitted to the 9th Circuit this week stated that it is concerned about the court’s suggestion that copyright holders should be held to a purely subjective standard.

“In other words, senders of false infringement notices could be excused so long as they subjectively believed that the material they targeted was infringing, no matter how unreasonable that belief,” the EFF wrote. “The panel felt that this holding was required by an old 9th Circuit case called Rossi vs. MPAA. As we explain in our brief, the Rossi case involved very unusual facts — the website owner fraudulently represented that his site contained full movies for download — and its adoption of a subjective standard was both unnecessary and inconsistent with the statute.

“Ultimately, a purely subjective standard rewards sloppiness and creates a perverse incentive for copyright owners to not learn about the law before sending a takedown,” the EFF wrote. “The DMCA gives private parties an unprecedented tool for silencing online speech. By simply sending an email or filling out a web form, it is possible to remove speech on many of the sites people use every day to communicate.”

The EFF noted that Universal has also filed a petition for rehearing asking the court to find that Lenz was not injured by the removal of her video from YouTube and that the court therefore lacks jurisdiction to hear the case.

“We strongly disagree,” the EFF said.

The 9th Circuit has not yet ruled whether to grant an en banc review of the decision.

View EFF's petition

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

JustFor.fans' Dominic Ford Featured in Wired Magazine

JustFor.fans Founder and CEO Dominic Ford is featured in a new article in Wired Magazine, titled "The Internet Revolutionized Porn. Age Verification Could Upend Everything."

Dr. Charlotte Gaydos Joins ProDx Health Advisory Board

Dr. Charlotte Gaydos has joined the Advisory Board of ProDx Health.

Aylo Fined $5 Million as FTC, Utah Settle Safety Practices Complaint

The Federal Trade Commission and the state of Utah on Wednesday settled a complaint against Aylo, requiring the company to pay a $5 million penalty and implement measures to prevent illegal content from appearing on its sites.

New AI Companion Platform 'Pornstar.love' Launches

Pornstar.love, a new AI companion platform, has officially launched.

Pineapple Support, Stripchat to Host 'Navigating Thoughts of Suicide' Support Group

Pineapple Support and Stripchat are hosting a free online support group to help performers deal with suicidal ideation.

Plaiir Names Cade Maddox as Lead of Creator Relations

Networking platform Plaiir has appointed Cade Maddox as its new lead of creator relations.

Go.cam Launches 'One-Line Integration' Verification Solution

Go.cam has introduced a one-line code integration for age verification.

XBIZ Amsterdam to Debut 'Behind the Lens' Screening Series

XBIZ is pleased to announce the debut of “Behind the Lens,” a new screening series presenting discussions with noted directors, taking place at the upcoming annual European conference, XBIZ Amsterdam.

'White Rabbit' Party Headed for XBIZ Amsterdam

XBIZ is pleased to announce the White Rabbit Party, an XBIZ Amsterdam special event set to take place Wednesday, Sept. 3.

2025 XBIZ Amsterdam Speaker Lineup Announced

XBIZ is pleased to announce the release of the full speaker lineup for XBIZ Amsterdam 2025, the latest edition of Europe’s biggest adult industry conference, set to take place Sept. 2-5 at the Jakarta Hotel in Amsterdam.

Show More