$4.85M Stagliano Infringement Suit Targets Mallcom Operator

LOS ANGELES — A Jan. 21 trial date has been set for John Stagliano Inc.'s multimillion-dollar copyright infringement suit against the parent company of Mallcom.com and BlingBucks.com, which is said to have infringed on Evil Angel content by allowing complete downloads of its movies on PornStar.com.

John Stagliano Inc.'s  $4.85 million suit, filed at U.S. District Court in Los Angeles, alleges that PornStar.com without permission sold monthly memberships to consumers who were able to stream and download movies from Evil Angel's catalog of licensed content.  

Prior to the alleged infringing conduct, Direct Distributions Enterprises Inc. — the parent company of Mallcom.com, BlingBucks.com and PornStar.com — approached Stagliano execs and requested to license its movies for distribution through its VOD  section of  the Mallcom.com, according to court documents. 

Stagliano execs, however, declined the offer.

But in July 2009, the same execs discovered Direct Distributions had reproduced Evil Angel movies, placing them on PornStar.com under an "unlimited consumption" sales model.

The alleged infringement includes 19 Evil Angel films from directors Giacinto Fusco, Jon Rutkowski, Joseph Nassivera, Carlton Shurman, John Leslie Nuzzon and Michelle Kelly, as well as Gilbert Grosso’s Christoph Clark line,

Direct Distributions, however, contends in court documents that it had a Mallcom.com licensing deal with director Grosso.

But Grosso, who agreed to video-on-demand distribution via Mallcom.com, said in testimony that "he didn't contemplate and would not have accepted an invitation" to license his works through PornStar.com under an unlimited consumption model.   

Further, Stagliano attorney Gill Sperlein said that the contract entered into evidence has "irregularities" and that Grosso never agreed to unlimited consumption for subscribers.

"This model is extremely unattractive for premium brands such as Gilbert Grosso’s  Christopher  Clark line, because the producer would receive the same share of the  revenue as producers of discount brands, even though the consumers were likely only watching the premium brands," Sperlein said. "Grosso has never permitted the sale of his films in this manner, nor would he."

Sperlein, answering Direct Distributions' motion to dismiss in the case, offered an alternative.

 "It is plausible, perhaps even likely, that [Direct Distributions owner Jerry] Aharony intentionally deceived Mr. Grosso and then held the unilaterally executed agreement so that he could to attempt to enforce provisions of the agreement only if he later found it to be to his advantage (as he has now done) ... ," Sperlein said. "Only when Mr. Grosso filed this action against Direct Distributions Enterprises Inc. did Mr. Aharony attempt to revive the document and use it to his advantage."

Sperlein told XBIZ on Tuesday that he's focusing on a clue from a recent joint case management conference statement of where this case is headed.

Direct Distribution's counsel in the joint case management conference statement said: "As a threshold matter, plaintiff will have to establish ownership of valid copyright. Defendants contend that plaintiffs do not own elements of some or all of the asserted designs and that, therefore, plaintiffs’ copyrights are invalid and/or it lacks standing to assert infringement.  Even if plaintiff can establish ownership of some valid copyrights, it will also have to establish that the movies used were copied from plaintiffs’ works."

An attorney for Mallcom, Sean Macias, did not return XBIZ requests for comment by post time.

John Stagliano Inc.'s suit seeks statutory damages of $150,000 for each infringed work, plus $2 million for infringement of the Evil Angel trademark.   

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Ryan Reid Talks Fights, Firsts and the 'Deadly Vows' Finale

When “Deadly Vows,” the latest feature from director Ricky Greenwood, premiered on Digital Playground, it delivered more than high-gloss eroticism. The series unveiled a full-throttle action spectacle with sword fights, betrayals, and a main character who combines Jackie Chan’s martial artistry with a thirst for vengeance worthy of the Bride, Uma Thurman’s memorable assassin character in “Kill Bill.”

Jade Venus, Zariah Aura Star in Latest From Evil Angel

Jade Venus and Zariah Aura star in a scene from Evil Angel.

Lilly Bell Stars in 3rd Installment of Elegant Angel's 'Cheaters Anonymous'

Reigning XMAs Girl/Girl Performer of the Year Lilly Bell stars with Quinton James in the third installment of "Cheater's Anonymous," from Elegant Angel.

Angela White Delivers a 'Pizza Party Blowbang' for Brazzers

Angela White stars in the latest release from Brazzers, titled "Pizza Party Blowbang."

Elegant Angel Releases All-Girl Orgy From '2025 Performers of the Year'

Elegant Angel has released an all-girl orgy from the 2025 edition of its annual series "Performers of the Year."

Digital Playground Drops Finale of Action Feature 'Deadly Vows'

Ryan Reid stars in the final installment of Digital Playground’s action feature “Deadly Vows.”

Ricky's Room Drops 3rd Installment of Roxie Sinner Showcase

Ricky’s Room has released the third installment of its Roxie Sinner showcase, titled "Roxie In Rotation."

Maitland Ward Featured in A&E's Docuseries 'Secrets of Celebrity Sex Tapes'

Multi-XMAs winner Maitland Ward is featured in the A&E documentary series "Secrets of Celebrity Sex Tapes."

Andi Avalon Stars in Latest From TeamSkeet

Andi Avalon stars with Scarlet Skies and Mike Mancini in a new scene for TeamSkeet’s “Shoplyfter” series, titled “Case No. 8004034 — Guards Need to Cool Off Too.”

Sarah Arabic Performs Her 1st Anal for Brazzers

Sarah Arabic performs her first anal scene alongside multi-XMAs winner Mick Blue in the latest Brazzers release.

Show More