U.S. Judge Blocks Porn BitTorrent Suits Filed in W. Va.

MARTINSBURG, Va. — A federal judge has quashed thousands of subpoenas that were requested in seven porn BitTorrent suits, ruling that the cases improperly join mass defendants together.

U.S. District Judge John Preston Bailey, in each of the orders, threw out all of the defendants with the exception of one John Doe for each claim. As a result, 5,462 unnamed defendants have been pared from suits filed by Combat Zone, Elegant Angel, Third World Media and West Coast Productions.

Bailey, in his ruling, said that the cases reeked of misjoinder, finding that it is an " undeniable fact that each defendant will also likely have a different defense."

In each of the cases, Bailey said that he would sever all Doe defendants except the first Doe of each suit. He also said that because so many ISPs were identified with each suit, "[allegations making] the propriety of joinder even more tenuous."

Bailey also said that if plaintiffs' counsel want to proceed they can do so by filing fees for each of the amended complaints, which would be assigned separate civil action numbers, but only if the defendants are located in West Virginia, where the cases were filed.

In the seven cases, Time Warner Cable moved to quash subpoenas seeking the identities of accused filed sharers.

Kenneth Ford of the Adult Copyright Co., which filed the suits, did not immediately respond to XBIZ for comment.

The Electronic Frontier Foundation, which filed amicus briefs in the cases, lauded the judge's ruling, calling it a "big victory in the fight against copyright trolls."

The EFF said that the studios in the seven suits were "abusing the law in an attempt to pressure settlements."

"In these cases — as in many others across the country — the owners of the adult movies filed mass lawsuits based on single counts of copyright infringement stemming from the downloading of a pornographic film, and improperly lumped hundreds of defendants together regardless of where the IP addresses indicate the defendants live," the EFF said in a statement.

"The motivation behind these cases appears to be to leverage the risk of embarrassment associated with pornography to coerce settlement payments despite serious problems with the underlying claims."

The West Virginia order comes on the heels of a ruling by a judge in the District of Columbia earlier this month that dismissed hundreds of individuals from across the country named in the U.S. Copyright Group's campaign due to lack of personal jurisdiction in Washington, D.C.

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Ed Seeman, Famed Filmmaker From Porn's Golden Age, Passes Away at 93

OCALA, Fla.— Ed Seeman, who worked as an adult filmmaker during the Golden Age of porn in the ‘70s, has passed away. He was 93.

North Dakota Legislature Backs Off on Device-Based AV

A North Dakota state senator who sponsored a device-based age verification bill that Free Speech Coalition (FSC) endorsed is now seeking to amend the bill to require site-based age verification instead.

PLBY Group Taps Byborg Principal Gyorgy Gattyan for Board of Directors

Playboy parent company PLBY Group has appointed Gyorgy Gattyan to its board of directors.

Addis Fouche Stars in Latest 'UpClose VR' From Adult Time

Addis Fouche stars with Dante Colle in the latest episode of Adult Time series "UpClose VR."

Adult Time Wraps Production on Bree Mills Feature 'The Party's Over'

Adult Time has announced that production has wrapped on its new Pure Taboo drama, "The Party’s Over," written, produced, and directed by studio CCO and 2025 XMAs winner Bree Mills.

Angel Youngs Makes Her Vixen Debut

Angel Youngs has made her Vixen debut alongside Milan.

NYC Adult Stores May Face Enforcement of 2001 Zoning Law

Adult retail stores in New York City are bracing for a potential crisis as an appeals court considers whether to allow enforcement of a 2001 city zoning law aimed at forcing them out of most parts of the city.

Andie Anderson Stars in Latest From Brazzers

Andie Anderson stars with Alex Jones in the latest release from Brazzers, titled “My Daughter's Too Good for You! (But I'm Not).”

Jenna Starr Stars in Latest From New Sensations

Jenna Starr stars with Jayden Marcos in the latest release from New Sensations.

Chloe Amour Stars in Latest From Erotica X

Chloe Amour stars with Codey Steele in the latest release from XEmpire studio brand Erotica X, titled “Seduction Games.”

Show More