Criticism Escalates for N.Y. Porn Tax Proposal

ALBANY, N.Y. — In light of a $15 billion state budget deficit, N.Y. Gov. David Paterson (D) has proposed an additional 4 percent tax on all "digitally delivered entertainment services," including online adult content.

Following the proposition, the "iPod tax" was immediately met with criticism from not only the adult entertainment industry, which has largely dismissed the tax as a publicity stunt, but also from the conservatives, who fear that such a tax would "legitimize" the downloading and viewing of adult content.

"You're sending a message to children, and you're sending a message to teenagers: If you're taxing it, how can it be wrong?" said state Conservative Party Chairman Michael Long. "I don't know how you can sink much deeper."

David Lazarus, a business columnist for the Los Angeles Times, also criticized the tax, calling it "knuckleheaded" and "incredibly shortsighted," but disagreed with Long's point about legitimization.

"When it comes to online porn," Lazarus told XBIZ, "the critics seem to be misplaced when they say this would legitimize the practice that many feel is wrong. The simple fact is that if it's something that millions of people are already using, it's already legitimized."

Diane Duke, executive director of the Free Speech Coalition, added that, "A tax focused on adult entertainment is a tax on expression plain and simple. Having to pay extra just because some folks don’t like our message is censorship - whether on a page or online, censorship is censorship."

Paterson's proposed tax is the most recent of a seemingly popular trend in that it follows similar propositions in California and more recently, Washington.

Washington's porn tax, recently proposed by state Rep. Mark Miloscia (D), would impose an 18.5 percent tax increase on all products and services that "are primarily oriented to an interest in sex," with the exception of online adult material.

The proposed 25 percent porn tax in California, issued by Assembly Member Charles Calderon (D) in 2008, was rejected because the majority feared the adult entertainment industry would leave the state and take its billions with it, particularly since Southern California's San Fernando Valley is considered by many to be the "porn capital of the world."

Lazarus agrees that imposing a tax increase on Internet porn in New York could have a negative impact on the state.

"New York's loss would almost certainly be Southern California's gain," he said. "[The tax] will only apply to New York companies, so in theory, any online porn merchant closes down in New York and moves out to the thriving Southern California porn industry. People will continue moving away from the tax. If you tax New York, they will move to California; if you tax California and Washington and all the other states, they will move to France. And with online porn, it doesn't really matter where you are."

He added that the main problem with Paterson's iPod tax, as well as the other proposed statewide taxes, is that they are "isolated to one state. It's not like porn is going to go away. It's simply going to find the path of the least resistance."

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Choice Talent Management Launches Fan Platform 'ChoiceFilmz'

Choice Talent Management CEO Chris Crisco has launched a new fan platform called ChoiceFilmz.

Dredd to Launch Official Site

Dredd has announced his new website OfficialDreddXXX.com, launching April 20.

New Pleasure Product Review Site 'ToyChats' Launches

ToyChats.com, a pleasure product review and discussion site, has officially launched.

AEBN Reveals Jade Venus as Top Trans Star for Q1 of 2025

AEBN has named its top trans stars for the first quarter of 2025, with Jade Venus landing atop the leaderboard.

SexLikeReal Debuts 'AI Passthrough' Feature

SexLikeReal has introduced an AI Passthrough for video editing during VR livestreaming.

Ron Jeremy's Accusers Reach Settlement With Rainbow Bar & Grill

The Rainbow Bar & Grill has reached confidential settlements with a group of women who filed a negligence lawsuit against the Sunset Strip restaurant over alleged sexual assaults committed by Ron Jeremy, according to Rolling Stone.

Cherry Kiss, Jordan Starr Top AEBN for Q1 of 2025

AEBN has announced its top-selling stars for the first quarter of 2025, with Cherry Kiss landing atop the leaderboard for straight theaters and Jordan Starr heading up the gay rankings.

Sportsheets Joins FSC as Gold Member

Sportsheets has joined Free Speech Coalition (FSC) as a Gold-level member.

Age Verification Watch: Two End Runs, Two Failed Bills

Industry stakeholders and free speech advocates have anxiously been awaiting the Supreme Court’s decision in Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton, which could significantly impact state age verification laws around the country. In the meantime, state legislatures continue to weigh and pass AV bills, AV tech providers continue to tout their services, and legal challenges continue to play out in the courts — with some cases on hold pending the SCOTUS ruling in Paxton.

FSC Helps Defeat Colorado AV Bill

Free Speech Coalition (FSC) has announced that, with its help, Colorado's recently introduced age verification bill has been defeated.

Show More