Michigan Case Could Update Child Porn Penalties

EGELSTON TOWNSHIP, Mich. — A U.S. Circuit Court this week will begin preliminary hearings in an online child pornography case that could dramatically change punishments for downloading sexually explicit images of minors.

At issue is whether the act of burning downloaded images to a disc should be considered production of child porn, a crime that carries a much harsher penalty than the one for simple possession, even if the defendant never intended to distribute the images.

Former Township Treasurer Brian Lee Hill already has pleaded guilty to charges that he downloaded thousands of pictures of children in sexual acts and burned them onto discs.

He also pleaded guilty to secretly videotaping teenage foreign exchange students left in his care. Over the course of several years, Hill took enough footage of boys taking showers to fill 50 videotapes.

Police last November seized the videotapes and discs of downloaded images, which Hill had ontained from Russian websites, during a raid after receiving a tip.

Saving child porn images to a disc is a felony in Michigan, but has previously been a “tier-three” felony, meaning the defendant is considered a consumer of the images only. Convictions for such simple possession have typically carried a maximum penalty of four years in prison, and sentences often run less than one year.

But prosecutors in Hill’s case are arguing that the law needs to be updated for the Internet age. Specifically, they say that when Hill copied the images, he became a producer of child porn, which is considered a “tier-one” felony, making Hill eligible for sentencing of up to 20 years in prison for each production charge.

Distribution, a “tier-two” penalty, carries a maximum seven-year sentence.

Hill was charged with 16 counts ranging from abusive sexual activity to eavesdropping, including eight “tier-one” counts of producing child pornography in relation to the content he downloaded from the Internet.

A District Court judge agreed with the prosecution's request to charge Hill with the more serious felonies for production, but Hill’s lawyer has asked a Circuit Court judge to overrule that decision.

In his motion, defense attorney Frank Stanley asserted that burning the images onto a disc is merely a transference of data since Hill saved the images for his personal use only and was not involved in the original production.

The state’s prosecutor’s office, in its response, argued that Michigan law does not specifically state that an individual has to be the original maker of images to be charged with production, just that he or she must create images that previously did not exist. In other words, reproduction equals production in the eyes of the law.

Prosecutors also said they are exploring yet another possible avenue for charging Hill with production. Since he paid a monthly subscription fee to the illegal websites, they argued, he was in essence financing the production.

Preliminary hearings in the case begin scheduled for May 26, with trial scheduled to begin Aug. 23. Stanley has already said he will appeal the case to the Supreme Court, if necessary.

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

VPN Usage Surges in France After Aylo Restricts Access to Pornhub

France has experienced a surge in virtual private network (VPN) signups after Aylo, which operates Pornhub, Redtube and YouPorn, cut off access to those sites in the country in the wake of new age verification regulations, business news site MENAFN is reporting.

US Arcades Introduces Multi-Language Support

U.S. Arcades has introduced multi-language support to its arcade units.

New Creator Directory 'TrustyFans' Launches

TrustyFans, a newly launched directory designed to help fans discover their favorite creators, is now live.

Corey Silverstein to Host Webinar on 'SCOTUS Age Verification Ruling'

Where Does Age Verification Go From Here," to livestream July 10 at 4 p.m. (EDT).

FSC Publishes Guidance on Google Analytics Lawsuits

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) has published guidance on how adult websites can protect themselves in the wake of several consumer class action lawsuits filed against sites for using Google Analytics.

BranditScan, CreatorTraffic Partner for 'Creators & Agencies' Initiative

BranditScan and advertising network CreatorTraffic have partnered for an initiative to help creators and agencies generate traffic and protect their content.

Teasy Agency Joins Pineapple Support as Supporter-Level Sponsor

Teasy Agency has joined the ranks of over 70 adult businesses and organizations committing funds and resources to Pineapple Support.

Aylo, Pineapple Support Partner for Mental Health Video Series

Aylo has teamed up with Pineapple Support to create a safety video series aimed at educating performers and creators about mental health.

Ofcom Investigates FTV Sites for Possible AV Noncompliance

U.K. media regulator Ofcom is investigating First Time Videos, which operates the sites FTVGirls.com and FTVMilfs.com, for possible failure to comply with age assurance requirements under the Online Safety Act.

Stalwart Defender: Jeffrey Douglas on 30 Years Fighting for Free Expression

“If you had told me in 1995 that I would be on the FSC board for 30 years, I would have laughed out loud,” says Jeffrey Douglas.

Show More