Supreme Court Hears Arguments on Pandering Child Porn

WASHINGTON — The U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments Tuesday regarding whether a child pornography law could be limited so that it would not apply to legitimate creative expression, vivid adolescent imaginations or innocent emails with provocative headings.

A 2003 federal law that sets a five-year mandatory prison term for promoting child porn is being challenged, and opponents have said the law could apply to mainstream movies, including "Traffic" and "Titanic," that depict underage sex.

The 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals struck down the provision, saying it makes a crime out of merely talking about illegal images or possessing innocent materials that someone else might believe is pornography. In the appeals court's view, the law could apply to an email sent by a grandparent and entitled "Good pics of kids in bed," showing grandchildren dressed in pajamas.

In the 2002 Ashcroft vs. Free Speech Coalition decision, the Supreme Court struck down provisions of a 1996 child pornography law because they called into question legitimate educational, scientific or artistic depictions of youthful sex.

Congress responded in 2003 with the PROTECT (Prosecutorial Remedies and Other Tools to End the Exploitation of Children Today) Act, which contains the "pandering child pornography" provision under challenge.

Richard Diaz, the lawyer for Michael Williams, a Florida man convicted under the law, told the court: "It is unconstitutionally vague and overbroad, because on its face it captures protected speech about materials. And it captures protected speech about materials that may not even, in fact, exist."

Williams also was convicted of possession of child pornography. That conviction and the resulting five-year prison term is not being challenged.

"After the victory in Ashcroft vs. Free Speech Coalition, Congress passed a new law that addressed part of what we prevailed in," 1st Amendment attorney Jeffrey Douglas told XBIZ. "They enacted another attempt to criminalize what they characterize as pandering child pornography; that is, offering for sale material which could be interpreted as an offer of sale of child pornography.

"The Supreme Court struck that down, and this was an attempt to evade the court's ruling in the hopes that a different court would come along."

According to Douglas, the definition of "pandering child pornography" could cover constitutionally protected materials.

"The government's argument was, in essence: Trust us, we wouldn't go after someone offering to sell the movie 'Lolita,' we'll only go after bad guys. This is rampant nonsense. As long as you give prosecutors discretion you can be certain that there will be abuse, because there are people out there who don't like mainstream movies. When 'The Exorcist' was released, a prosecutor in Alabama said he was going to prosecute it for violating the state's blasphemy laws — although the blasphemy laws had been repealed generations before.

"When you put your freedom in the good faith of prosecutors, your liberty will be short-lived."

The court's decision will be handed down before the end of the Supreme Court's term next summer.

The case is U.S. vs. Williams, 06-694.

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

NextGen Payment Joins ASACP as Corporate Sponsor

NextGen Payment has signed on as the latest corporate sponsor for the Association of Sites Advocating Child Protection (ASACP).

Lauren Phillips, Derek Kage Cap AEBN's Top Stars for 3rd Quarter of 2025

AEBN has revealed its most popular performers in straight and gay theaters for the third quarter of 2025.

XBIZ 2026 Conference to Debut All-New Company Lounges, Community Track

The event website for XBIZ 2026 is now live, unveiling details for North America’s largest adult industry conference, including two all-new show features: Company Lounges and a Community Track.

Mymember.site Integrates VR Functionality

Mymember.site has added virtual reality playback capability to its website management platform.

Texas Patti to Launch Fetish Platform 'EmpireDom'

Performer and content creator Texas Patti is launching a new platform for doms and fetish creators, EmpireDom.com.

Ohio AG Threatens Action Against 'Major' Adult Sites Over AV Law

Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost announced today that his office is sending "notice of violation" letters to 19 adult websites for failure to comply with the state's recently enacted age verification law.

Chaturbate Announces 2025 Music Contest Winners

Chaturbate has revealed the winners of its 2025 music competition.

2026 XBIZ Exec Awards Pre-Noms Open With Debut of New 'Impact' Honors

XBIZ is pleased to announce that the pre-nomination period for the 2026 XBIZ Exec Awards, the adult industry’s premier career honor, begins today and runs through Oct. 14.

MYM Rolls Out New Traffic Features for German Creators

German platform MYM has launched a new traffic system for its creators.

Ukrainian Content Creators on Hook for Nearly $10M in Back Taxes

Content creators in Ukraine owe the equivalent of $9.3 million in back taxes, according to the country's State Tax Service.

Show More