Federal Judge Refuses Spam Guilty Plea

NEW YORK — A federal judge rejected the guilty plea of a former America Online employee who allegedly stole nearly 100 million email addresses and sold them to spammers, saying that he wasn’t sure the employee had actually committed a crime.

The Tuesday hearing in which Jason Smathers had agreed to plead guilty to conspriracy and interstate trafficking as part of a bargain with federal with federal prosecutors was halted after U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein said that he had “technical questions” about the nature of the crime.

Hellerstein, who also mentioned that he had canceled his AOL account after receiving massive amounts of junk email, said he was unsure about whether Smathers actions were actually in violating of the Can-Spam act, which requires that spam be both annoying and deceptive.

“Everybody has spamsters, but mine is a technical question,” said Hellerstein. “I don’t think it’s deceptive or misleading to the recipient.”

Hellerstein then asked prosecutors to submit legal briefs by Jan. 12 so he could decide on whether Smathers was in violation of the law.

“I need to be independently satisfied that a crime has been committed,” the judge said.

If convicted, Smathers could face up to 15 years in prison, but the deal he cut with prosecutors would leave him with a potential prison term of 18 months to 24 months.

The Can-Spam Act, passed by the legislature in 2003 in response to mounting concerns about the quantity of junk email transmitted over the Internet, prohibits unscrupulous email marketing. Provisions of the act make it illegal to send email with the intent to deceive or mislead recipients about the origins or subject matter of the messages, and neglecting to state in the subject header whether the email contains pornographic material.

While Hellerstein is not questioning the constitutionality of the law itself, his questions echo similar concerns expressed by U.S. lawmakers when the bill was passed in November 2003.

“The bill doesn’t can spam, it legalizes it,” Debra Bowen, a Democrat state senator in California told the New York Times at the time. “It’s full of loopholes. It’s difficult to enforce. It’s weaken than many state laws.”

Before the act’s passage, eight state attorneys general who sit on the Internet committee of the National Association of Attorneys General wrote a letter to the legislature, saying that the Can-Spam Act “creates so many loopholes, exceptions and high standards of proof, that it provides minimal consumer protections and creates too many burdens for effective enforcement.”

The next hearing in the case is scheduled for Jan. 28.

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

France Reinstates Age Verification Rule for EU Sites

France’s highest court, the Council of State, on Tuesday reinstated age verification rules for EU-based sites under the country’s Security and Regulation of the Digital Space (SREN) law, ruling in favor of the French government and against Hammy Media.

European Commission Approves AV Guidelines, Unveils Prototype App

The European Commission on Monday released its final, approved guidelines for protecting minors online under the EU’s Digital Services Act (DSA) and made public a “white label” age verification app intended to help sites and platforms comply with age verification rules under the DSA.

Federal Appeals Court Vacates FTC 'Click to Cancel' Rule Pending Review

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit on Tuesday vacated the Federal Trade Commission’s “click-to-cancel” rule aimed at making it easier for consumers to cancel online subscriptions, pending further review.

NYC Adult Stores Lose Challenge to Zoning Law, May Face Relocation

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit on Tuesday upheld a lower court’s decision to allow enforcement of a 2001 zoning law aimed at forcing adult retail stores out of most parts of New York City.

FSC Drops Florida AV Lawsuit in Wake of SCOTUS Decision

A U.S. district court judge granted on Tuesday a motion by Free Speech Coalition to dismiss the trade association’s lawsuit over Florida’s age verification law, a case that had been on hold pending the Supreme Court’s recent ruling on the constitutionality of state AV laws.

Ukrainian President Responds to Porn Legalization Petition

President Volodymyr Zelensky responded Tuesday to an OnlyFans model’s petition to decriminalize pornography in Ukraine, stating that he would wait for the legislative process to play out “in accordance with established procedure.”

NC Governor Vetoes Bill Targeting Adult Industry, Override Possible

North Carolina Governor Josh Stein today vetoed a bill imposing new regulations that adult industry observers have warned could push adult websites and platforms to ban most adult creators and content.

25,000 Sign Petition to Legalize Pornography in Ukraine

An OnlyFans model’s petition to decriminalize pornography in Ukraine has amassed the 25,000 signatures required for official consideration by President Volodymyr Zelensky.

FSC Unpacks SCOTUS Age Verification Ruling in Webinar

The Free Speech Coalition conducted a public webinar Tuesday to help adult industry stakeholders understand the Supreme Court’s recent decision in FSC v. Paxton, and its potential implications.

Show More