INDIANAPOLIS — A Marion Superior Court judge on Wednesday dismissed Indiana’s lawsuit alleging that Aylo violated the state’s age verification law by failing to prevent access by users who employ VPNs and similar means to avoid geolocation.
In December, Attorney General Todd Rokita filed a complaint contending that IP address restrictions implemented by Pornhub and other Aylo sites were “insufficient to comply with Indiana’s Age Verification Law because Indiana residents, including minors, can still easily access the Defendants’ websites with a VPN IP or proxy address from another jurisdiction or through the use of location spoofing software.”
Investigators working for Rokita’s office accessed Pornhub and other Aylo sites from Indiana using a VPN with a Chicago IP address. The state contended that the fact that they were then able to view adult content on Aylo sites indicated that those sites “lacked any reasonable form of age verification.”
Aylo moved to dismiss the case, asserting — among other arguments — that 1) Indiana’s claims burdened the company’s exercise of free speech substantially more than necessary in order to protect minors under the state’s AV law; 2) Indiana’s interpretation of the law violated the 14th Amendment’s Due Process Clause by applying the law outside of the state without notice, thus rendering the statute “unconstitutionally vague”; and 3) Indiana’s interpretation of the law violated the Commerce Clause of the U.S. Constitution by seeking to regulate conduct in other states.
Judge Patrick J. Dietrick agreed with Aylo, noting in his ruling that an adult website is not “publicly accessible” in Indiana “merely because a user can disguise his or her location,” and stating that the law does not include or imply “an actual-location rule or a duty to defeat VPN circumvention.”
Citing the Supreme Court ruling in Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton, which declared state AV laws constitutional so long as they pass “intermediate scrutiny,” Dietrick notes that that pivotal case “did not address applying a State’s regime to users presenting out-of-state IP addresses after the operator has withheld adult content from users it identifies as being in the State.”
“Indiana has a substantial interest in regulating access by users it can identify as being in Indiana, but no comparable interest in requiring adults in other States or countries to submit to Indiana age verification, or to prove that they are not in Indiana, before accessing lawful speech,” Dietrick writes. “Forcing publishers to conform their nationwide and worldwide practices to Indiana’s most restrictive application would burden substantially more speech than necessary and is not narrow tailoring under intermediate scrutiny.”
Since the Indiana AV law “says nothing about VPNs, proxy servers, or liability for content served to users presenting out-of-state IP addresses, and so gives no notice that an operator that blocks or age-verifies the users it identifies as being in Indiana remains liable based on a physical location the user concealed,” it also denies the company due process, the ruling continues.
Dietrick also deemed the state’s interpretation of the law to be a violation of the Commerce Clause.
“The Internet is a channel of interstate commerce, and a State may not require out-of-state transactions to satisfy its law before they may occur,” he writes. “The State’s theory would eliminate the safe harbor of withdrawing from Indiana and require operators to apply Indiana age or location verification to traffic that appears to come from other States or countries, which is direct regulation of interstate and foreign commerce.”
The ruling comes on the heels of a related court battle in Utah, where a federal court recently paused Aylo’s suit over a state law making adult websites liable if minors bypass age verification by circumventing geolocation efforts. The Utah statute differs in that it specifically imposes liability based on a user's actual physical location, regardless of whether the user employs a VPN. A federal court ruled that the VPN provision in the Utah law is likely unconstitutional under the dormant Commerce Clause and issued a preliminary injunction against it. That litigation is now on hold while Utah considers potential legislative changes.
Industry attorney Corey Silverstein told XBIZ that Wednesday’s ruling in the Indiana case constitutes “a significant victory for Aylo and a potentially important development for the adult entertainment industry.”
“What makes the decision particularly significant is that the court did not simply rely on jurisdictional grounds,” Silverstein said. “It also concluded that Indiana's complaint failed to state a viable claim and that the state's proposed interpretation of its age verification statute would violate the First Amendment, Due Process Clause, and Commerce Clause.
He added that the Indiana and Utah courts approached the issue under somewhat different statutory frameworks.
“Both recognized the same fundamental problem,” Silverstein explained. “States cannot impose effectively impossible compliance obligations on website operators simply because internet users can conceal their geographic locations. I find it especially significant that the Indiana court expressly relied on the Utah ruling. That demonstrates that these decisions are not necessarily isolated developments and that courts are beginning to recognize the broader constitutional implications of attempting to regulate internet traffic based on geographic locations that website operators cannot reliably determine.”
Perhaps the most important takeaway, Silverstein said, is that the Supreme Court's decision in Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton did not give states unlimited authority to regulate adult websites.
“While Paxton upheld age verification requirements under intermediate scrutiny, it did not authorize states to impose liability for conduct occurring outside their borders or require website operators to achieve technological perfection,” Silverstein said. “The Indiana court expressly recognized that distinction. I also believe the decision sends a powerful message to lawmakers and attorneys general who believe that increasingly aggressive enforcement is the solution to VPN circumvention.”
Silverstein cautioned, however, that while the decision demonstrates that courts remain willing to impose meaningful constitutional limits on state age verification enforcement, even after the Paxton decision, operators should remember that limits on VPN-related liability do not limit the states’ underlying authority to impose other, constitutional AV requirements.
Additionally, although he sees the Utah and Indiana cases as representing the beginning of a potentially meaningful judicial trend, Silverstein cautions against declaring the issue “definitively settled.”
“It is not an absolutely final resolution of every possible issue,” he explained. “Certain claims were dismissed without prejudice for lack of personal jurisdiction. Indiana may also appeal the ruling.”
The broader message, however, is straightforward as Silverstein sees it: “Protecting minors is a legitimate governmental objective, but that objective does not excuse unconstitutional legislation, unreasonable enforcement theories, or compliance obligations that are technologically impossible to satisfy.”