5th Circuit Upholds Texas Age Verification Law, Strikes Down 'Health Warnings'

5th Circuit Upholds Texas Age Verification Law, Strikes Down 'Health Warnings'

AUSTIN, Texas — In a mixed decision, the United States Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit has ruled on Texas’ controversial age verification law, overturning a lower court’s injunction against enforcement, but striking down the provision that mandated that adult websites post a “health warning” perpetuating religious anti-porn propaganda myths.

The opinion was penned by Judge Jerry E. Smith, who stated that the law “doesn’t violate the First Amendment because it serves the government’s ‘legitimate interest’ of keeping children from viewing porn,” Bloomberg Law reported.

In a partial dissent, Judge Patrick E. Higginbotham argued that the law “would also restrict speech that is constitutionally protected for adults — like romance novels, scenes from the popular TV show ‘Game of Thrones,’ and Marlon Brando movies,” Bloomberg Law reported.

“Such action ‘is to burn the house to roast the pig,’” Higginbotham wrote.

The Texas law (HB 1181) requires companies distributing “harmful” and “obscene” material on the internet to verify each user’s age, and carries a fine of $10,000 per violation. Attorney General Ken Paxton began enforcing the law in February, bringing a $1.6 million lawsuit against Aylo, the company that owns PornHub.

In overturning the preliminary injunction, the 5th Circuit signaled that the case brought by the Free Speech Coalition, which represents the adult industry, is not likely to succeed on the merits.

The FSC released a statement citing Higginbotham’s dissent.

“We disagree strenuously with the analysis of the Court majority,” the FSC statement reads. “As the dissenting opinion by Judge Higginbotham makes clear, this ruling violates decades of precedent from the Supreme Court: ‘[T]he Supreme Court has unswervingly applied strict scrutiny to content-based regulations that limit adults’ access to protected speech.’ In the case of HB 1181, ‘the law must face strict scrutiny review because it limits adults’ access to protected speech using a content-based distinction — whether that speech is harmful to minors.’”

The 5th Circuit “kept the district court’s injunction over the health disclaimers intact, saying the required messages unconstitutionally forced speech,” Bloomberg Law reported.

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

North Dakota Legislature Backs Off on Device-Based AV

A North Dakota state senator who sponsored a device-based age verification bill that Free Speech Coalition (FSC) endorsed is now seeking to amend the bill to require site-based age verification instead.

PLBY Group Taps Byborg Principal Gyorgy Gattyan for Board of Directors

Playboy parent company PLBY Group has appointed Gyorgy Gattyan to its board of directors.

NYC Adult Stores May Face Enforcement of 2001 Zoning Law

Adult retail stores in New York City are bracing for a potential crisis as an appeals court considers whether to allow enforcement of a 2001 city zoning law aimed at forcing them out of most parts of the city.

FSC Brings Adult Industry Debanking Issues to Congressional Hearing

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) recently had its "Statement for the Record" on the debanking of adult industry members read to the U.S. House of Representatives.

Clips4Sale Releases '2025 US Fetish Map'

Clips4Sale (C4S) has released its 2025 Fetish Map of the United States, showing the most searched-for fetish in each U.S. state.

Star Factory PR Relaunches Website

Star Factory PR has relaunched its official website, with several new features.

Solomon Friedman of Ethical Capital Partners Profiled in Canada's National Post

Solomon Friedman of Ethical Capital Partners, the investment group that controls Aylo and its flagship website, Pornhub, is profiled this week in Canada's National Post newspaper.

New Content Platform 'RM11' Launches

The new content platform RM11 has launched.

DripDrop Relaunches Through YourPaysitePartner

DripDrop Productions has relaunched through YourPaysitePartner (YPP).

Angie Bloom Launches New Paysite

Producer and content creator Angie Bloom has launched a new gangbang-themed membership site, Bloom.Shop, through MyMember.site.

Show More