FanCentro Sues OnlyFans Owner Over Alleged Social Media 'Blacklisting'

FanCentro Sues OnlyFans Owner Over Alleged Social Media 'Blacklisting'

FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. — Lawyers acting on behalf of FanCentro’s parent company have filed a civil lawsuit in Broward County, Florida against OnlyFans’ U.S. billing company, Fenix Internet LLC and owner Leonid Radvinsky, alleging “tortious interference with contract and intentional interference with prospective business.”

FanCentro’s lawyers allege that Radvinsky “engaged in a scheme to cause competitors of OnlyFans — including [FanCentro] — to be ‘blacklisted’ by social media platforms, for the purpose of interfering with [FanCentro’s] business and reducing competition with OnlyFans.”

The complaint defines this “blacklisting” as being “typically accomplished by automated classifiers of filters that keep particular websites or pages from appearing on social media platforms or appearing in the results shown in search engines pursuant to user queries.”

The lawsuit alleges a conspiracy between Radvinsky and unnamed persons in an unnamed company to blacklist OnlyFans competitors. This blacklisting, the suit alleges, suddenly halted FanCentro's growth in winter 2018, after which the company's growth “stagnated and then started declining because [models] who promoted FanCentro began losing their pages on Instagram or had their page visibility reduced.”

FanCentro alleges that before Radvinsky acquired OnlyFans parent company Fenix International Limited in October 2018, OnlyFans was “a medium size competitor” in a “vibrant, competitive market with more than 100 [adult entertainment] platforms.”

But after October 2018, according to the complaint, adult entertainment providers that had previously only promoted OnlyFans' competitors “suddenly began to experience a drop-off in traffic on social media platforms” and “experienced having many posts deleted by social media services, and the number of click-throughs from those posts that did appear on social media services dropped drastically.”

The complaint alleges that this alleged drop “was most noticeable on Instagram,” but “also occurred on Twitter, Facebook and other platforms.”

'Substantial Reduced Visibility'

FanCentro alleges that “the combination of deleted posts and reduced click-throughs resulted in substantially reduced visibility for the [adult entertainment] providers on social media,” and that this “extended as far as reduced visibility on Google’s search engine.”

According to FanCentro, the reduction on social media traffic “was so substantial and dramatic that it could not have been the result of filtering by human reviewers” and the drop “suggested that social media services were using computer algorithms that automatically classify/filter content.”

FanCentro alleges that models “who had only promoted OnlyFans online” and not any of their competitors — other than MyFreeCams and AVNStars, which the lawsuit names as companies also owned by Radvinsky — “appeared to be unaffected by these automated takedowns and reduced traffic.”

FanCentro also alleges that OnlyFans “obfuscated” its supposed participation in this “scheme” by claiming that some of the models who promoted OnlyFans and also other companies were affected by the social media blackout, although “in fact those who promoted exclusively OnlyFans were immune.”

The lawsuit claims that OnlyFans' current dominant position in the sector came as the result of this alleged drop in the traffic of models promoting other platforms.

The central claim of the FanCentro lawsuit concerns what the company calls “the disproportionate classification/filtering treatment” accorded OnlyFans’ competitors as compared with models who exclusively promoted OnlyFans.

Since, the complaint alleges, “there is no statistical or other benign explanation (such as better marketing)” for the alleged differential treatment, FanCentro has reached the conclusion that “it was caused by a manipulation of one or more of the individual databases (or sets of training data) that was then shared in part or in full among multiple companies,” a scheme designed “for the purpose of harming the competitors of OnlyFans and their [models], and to cause a net benefit to OnlyFans and its [adult entertainment] providers who never promoted any OnlyFans competitors.”

Allegations of a 'Mysterious Immunity' Against Blacklisting

Central to the lawsuit is what FanCentro’s lawyers called the “mysterious immunity of OnlyFans and two sites affiliated with Radvinsky […] to this new heightened classification/filtering activity” which FanCentro claims took place “soon after October 2018.”

The lawsuit also implies that one of the manipulated databases was the Global Internet Forum to Counter Terrorism, a shared hash database created in 2017 by Facebook, Microsoft, Twitter and YouTube.

FanCentro and “certain [adult entertainment] providers,” the lawsuit alleges, “were blacklisted as terrorist organizations or individuals, sympathizers, or otherwise as dangerous organization or individuals, and content associated with them was hashed and shared with the GIFCT, along with certain URL data, with the goal of harming [FanCentro’s] business (and through the scheme, the other [adult entertainment] platforms that competed with OnlyFans), in order to improve the market position, revenue, power and otherwise benefit OnlyFans and its owner, Radvinsky.”

The lawsuit claims that the alleged scheme “required and involved” individuals within a company “with the ability to add and/or manipulate content” on these databases, and that Radvinsky and others involved with OnlyFans “provided the information” to these individuals “to add false classifier/filtering information” to them.

The lawsuit conjectures that the alleged participants in the scheme must have been driven by “an economic incentive,” and implies Radvinsky and/or OnlyFans used an offshore company in Hong Kong and other Asian countries for these alleged transactions.

A Florida Lawsuit Leaked to a BBC Journalist

The FanCentro lawsuit was filed in November by FanCentro's lawyers: William R. Scherer of Fort Lauderdale, Florida firm Conrad & Scherer; Jeffrey C. Schneider of Miami firm Levine Kellog Lehman Schneider + Grossman; and David E. Azar of Beverly Hills firm Milberg Coleman Bryson Phillips Grossman. 

The lawsuit was leaked this morning to BBC News journalist Noel Titheradge.

According to Titheradge, “OnlyFans has not yet issued a legal response" to the FanCentro lawsuit, "but a spokesperson said the company was aware of the claims — describing them as having ‘no merit.’”

Last August, Titheradge authored a sensationalized report criticizing OnlyFans, which the notoriously anti-sex-worker and anti-porn BBC promoted by implying that it had caused the company to “ban sex videos.” The BBC later had to revise the report's headline to correct that implication.


Copyright © 2023 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Performers, Creators With LLCs Urged to Review Corporate Transparency Act Requirements

Performers and creators who have formed limited liability companies (LLCs) are being advised to consult with accounting and legal professionals before the Jan. 1, 2024 implementation of the new Corporate Transparency Act (CTA).

Byborg Enterprises Acquires SpankBang

LiveJasmin parent company Byborg Enterprises has acquired SpankBang, according to an email sent to partners from the Bigbang Media-owned tube site.

Australian Right Foregrounds Age Verification as Political Wedge Issue

Australia’s conservative Liberal Party and the country’s influential right-wing media have recently begun foregrounding age verification for viewing adult content as a political wedge issue against the Australian Labor Party government led by Prime Minister Norman Albanese.

Google Cracks Down on Adult Sites That Utilize Its 'Programmable Search Engine' Tool

Google disabled its Programmable Search Engine (ProSE) product on several adult sites on Tuesday, after ad industry trade publications sensationalized a report claiming that ads for major mainstream brands were appearing alongside pornographic and other controversial content.

FSC to Host Members' Briefing on Legislative Work

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) will host an end-of-year members’ briefing Monday, addressing the fight for industry rights in statehouses and Congress.

Adult All Access Joins Pineapple Support as Supporter-Level Sponsor

Adult All Access has enlisted as a supporter-level sponsor of Pineapple Support, joining the ranks of over 70 adult businesses and organizations committing funds and resources to the group.

JuicyAds Expands to 8th Data Center

JuicyAds has expanded to an eighth data center, located in Mumbai, India, to service the Asia-Pacific region.

Industry Vet Michael H. Klein Named YumyHub President

Industry veteran Michael H. Klein has been tapped to serve as the new president of fan platform YumyHub.

Researchers, ECP Release 1st 'Pornhub Creator Consultations Report'

Internet and sex work researchers Maggie MacDonald and Val Webber have released their first “Pornhub Creator Consultations Report,” probing issues such as banking access for sex workers, different types of platform discrimination, and advocacy.

Vendo to Host Next Payment Processing Conference on Thursday

Vendo Services will host the next edition of its online conference for high-risk ecommerce merchants on Thursday.

Show More