Texas Judge Upholds Under-21 Stripper Ban, Claims 'Belief' It May Curb 'Human Trafficking' Trumps 1st Amendment

Texas Judge Upholds Under-21 Stripper Ban, Claims 'Belief' It May Curb 'Human Trafficking' Trumps 1st Amendment

AUSTIN — A U.S. District Court Judge in Texas has denied a proposed preliminary injunction against the recent state law preventing sex workers aged 18-21 from being employed at strip clubs and other “sexually oriented businesses.”

The denial by Judge Robert Pitman — including a questionable claim that the Texas legislators can go against constitutional protections if they have a mere “belief” that it may lead to curbing “human trafficking” — effectively upholds the new state law, S.B. 315, prohibiting the employment of people between the ages of 18 and 21 in adult businesses. Such businesses are defined by the Texas legislators as “sex parlor, nude studio, modeling studio, love parlor, adult bookstore, adult movie theater, adult video arcade, adult movie arcade, adult video store, adult motel or other commercial enterprise the primary business of which is the offering of a service or the selling, renting or exhibiting of devices or any other items intended to provide sexual stimulation or sexual gratification to the customer.”

The plaintiffs are described in court papers as “four young people between the ages of 18 and 20 years old, who have been laid off or fear losing their jobs because of Texas’s enactment of S.B. 315.” Two of them, Feliz Valdez and Abigail Reyes, are described as “19-year-old clerks at New Fine Arts, an adult bookstore in Dallas, Texas that sells books, movies and ‘novelty’ items.” They were joined in the case by the Texas Entertainment Association (TEA), described as “a non-profit organization that represents [sexually-oriented businesses] in Texas.”

Judge Pitman, a prominent Texas Democrat, denied the proposed injunction which alleges that “the State of Texas may not raise the minimum age for employment in businesses the legislature has deemed to be sexually-oriented.” A copy of the proposed injunction had mistakenly circulated last week with erroneous information that that law had been halted.

Judge Pitman’s introductory statement included several mentions of “human trafficking” and “human trafficking training,” even though it is a labor discrimination case based on age and type of business.

Judge Pitman also stated, in his denial of the Plaintiff’s First Amendment standing, that “S.B. 315 codifies one of the [Texas Human Trafficking Prevention] Task Force’s legislative recommendations to curb human trafficking by raising the age of employment at sexually-oriented businesses from 18 to 21.”

“In the hearing on the motion for preliminary injunction,” Judge Pitman continued, “Plaintiffs made much of the fact that the Texas legislature did not rely on any studies showing that 18-to 20-year-olds who work at SOBs are more vulnerable to human trafficking than others. Yet the State ‘need not demonstrate through empirical data [. . .] that its regulation will reduce such trafficking,’ but instead must show that the State has a ‘reasonable belief that there is a link between the regulation and the curbing of the identified secondary effects.’”

The judge told the plaintiffs they had “failed to show a likelihood of success on the merits of their First Amendment and Fourteenth Amendment due process claims.”

First Amendment Expert: 'This Is an Important Case'

First Amendment expert Lawrence Walters, from the Walters Law Group, told XBIZ, "This is a difficult decision on an important and developing legal issue for adult entertainment establishments. Fortunately, it is only a preliminary decision which can be appealed or challenged at trial."

Walters opined that "the plaintiff may be able to eventually demonstrate that the state did not meet its burden of proving a substantial governmental interest justifying the broad age restriction, or that the statute was not narrowly tailored to meet any such interest."

"This is an important case to follow as state and local governments use the issue of trafficking to infringe on more and more constitutional rights of adults," Walters concluded.

Main Image: Judge Robert Pitman

Denial of Injunction Against Under-21 Work at Sexually Oriented Businesses

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Romi Rain Fronts Latest From New Sensations

Romi Rain and Codey Steele star in the latest release from New Sensations.

JD Directs New Grazyeli Silva Showcase

Evil Angel has released JD’s Grazyeli Silva showcase, titled "Grazyeli Silva Sexcapades."

Heidi Jo Makes Her WIFEY Debut

Heidi Jo stars with her husband Jerri, Isiah Maxwell, and Hollywood Cash in the latest release from Vixen Media Group studio imprint WIFEY.

Anna Claire Clouds Leads Elegant Angel's 'Shared: A Hotwife Origin Story'

Reigning XMAs Female Performer of the Year Anna Claire Clouds stars in Elegant Angel's new feature thriller "Shared: A Hotwife Origin Story," part of the site's annual "Superstar September" initiative.

Gender X Drops 'Vampirella' Parody

Gender X Films has released its latest feature, "Transpirella," a parody of the 1970s sci-fi horror comic book "Vampirella," directed by Jim Powers.

Jonni Darkko Directs New Chloe Amour Showcase

Evil Angel has released Jonni Darrko’s Chloe Amour showcase, titled "Mon Amour."

Bella Reid Named Penthouse's 'Pet of the Month' for September

Penthouse Magazine has named Bella Reid as Pet of the Month for September.

Andi Avalon Fronts Latest From New Sensations

Andi Avalon and Ken Feels star in the latest release from New Sensations.

Ricky's Room Drops Final Installment of Baby Gemini Showcase

Ricky’s Room has released the final installment of its Baby Gemini showcase, titled "Six Bodies In Motion."

XBIZ Amsterdam to Debut 'Behind the Lens' Screening Series

XBIZ is pleased to announce the debut of “Behind the Lens,” a new screening series presenting discussions with noted directors, taking place at the upcoming annual European conference, XBIZ Amsterdam.

Show More