Review Site Can't Be Ordered to Remove Posts, California Justices Rule

Review Site Can't Be Ordered to Remove Posts, California Justices Rule

SAN FRANCISCO — The California Supreme Court yesterday reversed an appellate court ruling that upheld an order that required Yelp to remove a negative review of a business.

State justices held in their decision that federal immunity under Section 230 applies to a website that is a repository of views posted by third parties.

The case has been closely watched because removal orders such as the one obtained against Yelp could be used to silence online speech and undermine the viability of a platform.

Industry attorney Corey D. Silverstein told XBIZ that the decision is a “much needed win for Section 230, which has been under a tremendous amount of attack as of late.”

“Good for Yelp for having the guts to make its own decision when it ignored a judgment from the trial court that was riddled with irregularities,” Silverstein said. “Yelp took a chance in ignoring the trial court and ultimately won. Unfortunately, most ISPs would have probably gone along with the trial court’s original judgment.”

The ruling comes in a case where a woman, Ava Bird, posted a one-star review of the Hassell Law Group on Yelp, expressing her displeasure with its representation in her personal injury action, advising, “[T]o save your case, steer clear of this law firm!”

The San Francisco law firm and its owner, attorney Dawn Hassell, sued Bird, claiming the review was libelous. That lawsuit resulted in a default judgment.

A San Francisco Superior Court judge awarded Hassell and her firm damages and ordered Bird to remove the “steer clear” review, which she has not done.

The judgment also required Yelp to remove the offending review.

Yelp, which was not a party to the lawsuit, was served with the judgment. It moved to set aside the default, claiming in part that it violated both due process and Section 230.

The San Francisco judge denied Yelp’s motion, and a state court of appeal affirmed on several bases.

California justices granted review solely on the due process and Section 230 issues.

By requiring Yelp to delete the offending review, Chief Justice Tani Cantil-Sakauye explained in the ruling, Yelp was being treated as the publisher of the content in violation of the statute.

“The question here is whether a different result should obtain because plaintiffs made the tactical decision not to name Yelp as a defendant,” Cantil-Sakauye wrote. “Put another way, we must decide whether plaintiffs’ litigation strategy allows them to accomplish indirectly what Congress has clearly forbidden them to achieve directly. We believe the answer is no.”

Silverstein noted that the California Supreme Court got this decision "100 percent correct" and that the ruling showed why Section 230 is important for free-speech liberties.

“In this case had the plaintiff named Yelp as a defendant from the beginning of the lawsuit, Yelp would have surely sought dismissal on Section 230 grounds and would most likely have prevailed,” Silverstein said. “I suspect that plaintiff/their counsel recognized that they had little to no chance in prevailing against Yelp and so they strategically proceeded against the named defendant, who incidentally put up no fight and lost by default.

“Could you imagine an internet where review sites, blogs, and web hosts could be held liable for content posted by third parties?” Silverstein asked.

“This case should be viewed as a reminder to everyone about the importance of Section 230 and why government at all levels must be challenged when it attempts to shrink the breadth of Section 230 protection.”

Related:  

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Orion Debuts 'Ride On 2' Vibepad

Orion Wholesale has introduced its new Ride On 2 vibepad.

PAYSITE Integrates With Multi-Platform Posting Tool ModelPlug

PAYSITE has integrated with multi-site posting tool ModelPlug, enabling clients to upload to a number of fan platforms simultaneously when adding content to their membership sites.

Report: TDR Capital Reaches $460M Deal to Acquire Lovehoney Group

Private equity firm TDR Capital has reached an agreement to acquire Lovehoney Group in a deal valued at approximately €400 million ($460 million), according to a report by Sky News.

Aylo Defeats Indiana Lawsuit Over VPN Use to Bypass Age Verification

A Marion Superior Court judge on Wednesday dismissed Indiana’s lawsuit alleging that Aylo violated the state’s age verification law by failing to prevent access by users who employ VPNs and similar means to avoid geolocation.

'Swing Nation' Hosts Lacy and Dan Star With Serenity Cox in WIFEY Return

Lacy and Dan, hosts of the "Swing Nation" lifestyle podcast, star alongside Serenity Cox and Anton Harden in their return to Vixen Media Group studio imprint WIFEY.

FSC, Texas Ask for Summary Judgment in AV Law 'Health Warnings' Case

Both sides in a lawsuit challenging the “health warning” requirements of Texas’ age verification law for adult websites have motioned for summary judgment in the case.

AEBN Publishes Popular Searches for September, October

AEBN has published the top search terms for September and October from its straight and gay theaters in all 50 states and the District of Columbia.

Lauren Phillips, Cali Sweets Front New 'Buttman' Release

Lauren Phillips and Cali Sweets star with director Glenn King in the latest release featuring Evil Angel studio honcho John Stagliano's iconic Buttman character.The scene opens with Buttman concerned about King's recent unreliability, as he's been missing deadlines for submitting videos.

Amy Nosferatu Leads Latest From TGirls.xxx

Amy Nosferatu stars with Jason Leescott in a release from Grooby paysite TGirls.xxx, titled "The Tattoo Parlour."

Wild Brands to Unveil 1st Product Collection at XBIZ Expo

Sexual wellness company Wild Brands will introduce its debut product collection at XBIZ Expo in January.

Show More