L.A. County Supervisors OK Settlement Over Measure B Suit

L.A. County Supervisors OK Settlement Over Measure B Suit

LOS ANGELES — Los Angeles County officials yesterday signed off on a settlement with Vivid Entertainment, which challenged in a federal lawsuit the constitutionality of the Measure B requirement for porn performers to wear condoms.

The settlement was announced by the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors following a closed-door session of the board during their weekly Tuesday meeting, according to City News Service.

The suit was initiated after Vivid Entertainment sought to block implementation of the county’s 2012 Measure B ballot measure that was eventually approved by 56 percent of voters.

With Measure B, adult filmmakers with productions in Los Angeles must require the use of condoms in all vaginal and anal sex scenes. The law goes further, requiring producers to obtain a health permit prior to production and to post the permit and a notice to performers regarding condom use during production.

Vivid Entertainment had argued that Measure B, formally called “County of Los Angeles Safer Sex in the Adult Film Industry,” violated First Amendment rights and was unnecessary in an industry that already has protocols in place to protect its performers from STI transmission.

The AIDS Healthcare Foundation acted as intervenors in the suit, insisting that the protocols weren’t enough.

U.S. District Judge Dean Pregerson struck down portions of the law, including a $2,000 to $2,500 permit fee, but upheld the constitutionality of requiring condoms in adult films and any fee that was “revenue neutral” to cover enforcement costs. He denied Vivid Entertainment’s motion for a preliminary injunction.

Vivid Entertainment appealed Pregerson’s ruling that upheld the measure, and in December 2014 the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed the federal jurist’s order denying a motion to overturn the ordinance.

The 9th Circuit, however, held that Pregerson did not abuse his discretion in declining to enjoin the enforcement of Measure B’s condom mandate.

Yesterday, county supervisors did not offer any details of the settlement; however, the AIDS Healthcare Foundation’s president, Michael Weinstein, earlier told XBIZ that the agreement means Vivid will no longer legally challenge the constitutionality of Measure B; that AHF and the county will not challenge the parts of the decision that limit inspections; and that the county will do a study to determine what the fee for the health permit should be.

Industry attorney Paul Cambria, who is litigating the case on behalf of Vivid Entertainment, did not confirm or deny Weinstein’s assertion to the settlement because court papers haven’t been signed over the accord. But he said that the studio will offer a statement soon on the matter.

“When all parties have signed we will explain what the status of the litigation and [what] the law is,” he told XBIZ.

Pregerson, who is presiding over the suit, is slated to sign off on a settlement between the parties within 30 days.

Weinstein, in a statement last night, said that “by declining to pursue their lawsuit any further, the porn industry has thrown in the towel on Measure B.”

However, Eric Paul Leue, the adult trade group Free Speech Coalition's executive director, said that Weinstein's statement was disingenuous.

"The settlement has not yet been signed by all parties involved," Leue told XBIZ. "AHF's press release is, as always, premature and sensationalistic. The industry is far from having 'thrown in the towel' and we commend Vivid for having fought such a successful fight."

Last month, the adult industry scored a big victory over new condom and bloodborne pathogens requirements, created and advocated by the AHF, that were weighed by the state Occupational Safety and Health’s Standards Board in Oakland, Calif., in front of more than 100 performers who trekked up to the Bay Area to add their voices to the five-hour discussion.

By a 3-2 vote (four votes were needed for it to pass) the Standards Board chose to not move forward with the proposed § 5193.1 (California’s Code of Regulations) that not only required condoms for all filmed sex but also "barrier protection for eyes, skin, mouth and mucous membranes."

But after the Oakland victory, the AHF drafted and submitted another plan to the Standards Board, which plans to review it and report its direction over it within six months.

In the direct eye of another battle, the adult industry has its radar on one more existential threat — the AHF’s California porn-condom voter initiative, which cost the organization a reported $1.5 million to be placed on the statewide ballot.

If California voters approve, the proposal would require performers in adult films to use condoms during shoots and require producers to pay for performer vaccinations, testing and medical examinations related to STIs.

The ballot proposal also forces producers to obtain state health license at beginning of filming and to post condom requirements at film sites.

For violations, the ballot proposal also imposes liability on producers, distributors, performers if they have a financial interest in the violating film, and on talent agents who knowingly refer performers to noncomplying producers.


Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Kazumi Does 1st Anal, DP for Vixen Media Group

Kazumi has performed her first anal and her first DP alongside Isiah Maxwell and Hollywood Cash for Vixen Media Group (VMG) studio imprint Blacked Raw.

Lauren Walker Toplines 'Hard' From Dorcel

Lauren Walker headlines "Hard," the latest release from Dorcel.

Phoenix Marie Makes Her Vixen Media Group Debut

Phoenix Marie has made her Vixen Media Group (VMG) debut with exclusive Jason Luv for studio imprint Blacked.

Child Protection, Civil Liberties Groups File Amicus Briefs in Support of FSC Court Petition

Several child protection and civil liberties groups have filed amicus briefs in support of the Free Speech Coalition's (FSC) petition to the Supreme Court.

MixedX Releases 'Love's Enigmatic Dance'

MixedX has released "Love's Enigmatic Dance" from its new studio banner, GetWitched, starring Candee Licious, Nata Gold and Zazie.

Queenie Sateen Headlines Final Installment of Seth Gamble's 'Luminati'

LucidFlix has released the fourth and final installment of "Luminati," the new cinemacore directing collaboration between reigning XBIZ Performer of the Year Seth Gamble and Siren Obscura, starring XBIZ Best New Performer Queenie Sateen.

PASS to Hold Comedy Fundraiser Next Week

PASS will host a comedy festival fundraiser next Friday, May 24.

Jada Stevens, Hollywood Cash Star in Latest From Ricky's Room

Jada Stevens stars with Hollywood Cash in "A Legendary Ass," from Ricky's Room.

Woodhull Urges the Supreme Court to Find Texas AV Law Unconstitutional

The Woodhull Freedom Foundation and the Electronic Frontier Foundation submitted a brief to the United States Supreme Court on Thursday, urging the justices to rule against Texas’ age verification law.

AEBN Publishes Popular Searches for March and April

AEBN has released the top search terms for the months of  March and April from its straight and gay theaters in all 50 states and the District of Columbia.

Show More