9th Circuit: Fair Use Must Be Weighed Before Issuing DMCA Notice

9th Circuit: Fair Use Must Be Weighed Before Issuing DMCA Notice

SAN FRANCISCO — In a decision of particular interest to adult content and tube site owners, the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has found that copyright owners must consider the fair use doctrine before sending Digital Millennium Copyright Act takedown notices to online hosts.

The ruling issued today by a three-judge panel could change the shape and form of fair use and copyright takedown notices after it found that Universal Music Group's view of fair use is flawed.

The panel affirmed a lower court’s decision for summary judgment in an action under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act alleging that Universal violated 17 U.S.C. § 512(f) by misrepresenting in a takedown notification that plaintiff Stephanie Lenz’s home video constituted an infringing use of a portion of a Prince composition.

The appeals court said copyright owners like Universal can only send takedown notices if they’ve come to a good faith conclusion that the targeted upload is not a protected fair use of the copyrighted work.

The appellate ruling “is a pretty big deal for content companies and tube sites alike,” adult industry attorney Marc Randazza of Randazza Legal Group told XBIZ.  

“When you send a DMCA notice, you need to be careful. Fair use is an important exception to copyright infringement — it allows copyright to act as the engine of further expression,” Randazza said.

“If a content producer sends a DMCA notice without considering fair use, licenses or other reasons that the content should not come down, that content producer is going to be pretty upset when all of a sudden the tube site has a claim against them.

“So, to content producers, I say make sure you consider all these issues before sending DMCA notices. To other lawyers, I say to do the same doubly. To tube sites: This can be a way to push back at content producers.”

With the 9th Circuit’s decision, Universal now must face a trial over whether it wrongfully sent a copyright takedown notice over a 29-second YouTube video of Lenz’s toddler dancing to the Prince song "Let's Go Crazy" blaring in the background.

Lenz, who acquired pro bono counsel from the Electronic Frontier Foundation, sued Universal in 2007, arguing that the media giant’s takedown practices violated the DMCA. The litigation was known as the “dancing baby case.”

“All in all, it is a good decision — it just makes people have to play by the rules, respect copyright, but also respect freedom of expression,” Randazza said.

View today's ruling

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Isa Bella, Selena Ivy Topline 'Lesbian Sex 28'

Isa Bella and Selena Ivy headline the latest release from Girlfriends Films, titled “Lesbian Sex 28.”

Catherine Knight Stars in Latest From Brazzers

Catherine Knight stars in the latest release from Brazzers, titled "GRWM (To Fuck)."

Federal Appeals Court Vacates FTC 'Click to Cancel' Rule Pending Review

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit on Tuesday vacated the Federal Trade Commission’s “click-to-cancel” rule aimed at making it easier for consumers to cancel online subscriptions, pending further review.

Elegant Angel Premieres Nicole Kitt Showcase 'Cats Eye'

Nicole Kitt gets the spotlight in a new four-part showcase release from Elegant Angel.

Private Releases 'The Love Hotel 2'

Private has released “The Love Hotel 2,” directed by Dave Menich.

Ember Fiera, Jesse Pony Headline 'TS Girls Do It Best' Sequel From TransSensual

Ember Fiera and Jesse Pony topline the sequel to “TS Girls Do It Best” from Mile High Media studio imprint TransSensual.

Khloe Kapri, Melissa Stratton Topline 'Lesbian Trainer 3' From Sweetheart Video

Khloe Kapri and Melissa Stratton headline the third volume of “Lesbian Trainer” from Mile High Media studio imprint Sweetheart Video.

FSC Drops Florida AV Lawsuit in Wake of SCOTUS Decision

A U.S. district court judge granted on Tuesday a motion by Free Speech Coalition to dismiss the trade association’s lawsuit over Florida’s age verification law, a case that had been on hold pending the Supreme Court’s recent ruling on the constitutionality of state AV laws.

Gal Ritchie Toplines Dorcel's 'Pigalle'

2025 XMAs winner Gal Ritchie stars with Clara Mia in the latest feature from Dorcel, titled “Pigalle.”

Ukrainian President Responds to Porn Legalization Petition

President Volodymyr Zelensky responded Tuesday to an OnlyFans model’s petition to decriminalize pornography in Ukraine, stating that he would wait for the legislative process to play out “in accordance with established procedure.”

Show More