U.S. Supreme Court Considers Patent Reform

WASHINGTON — In what could prove to be a landmark patent case, the U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments addressing the so-called “obviousness test.” A ruling that tosses out the test, which many lawyers call the cornerstone of patent law, could make it easier to challenge patents in the future, something many in the adult entertainment industry who rely on new technologies to deliver their content, think is a good thing.

The case at bar, in which Teleflex brought suit against KSR International alleging that it infringed on its patent for an adjustable gas pedal system, raises the question of obviousness because the defendant contends that the plaintiff’s design simply combines existing products, making it ineligible for patent protection.

Patent attorney Sharon Barner said the case could prove to be monumental.

“All indications are that they will reverse [the Federal Circuit],” she said. “There's a notion out there that there are too many patents. They do not enhance the patent system."

According to patent lawyer Dennis Crouch, who teaches at Boston University Law School, the obviousness test consists of a threefold analysis. A party challenging a patent by saying that it simply combines previous inventions must show that there was a “teaching, suggestion or motivation” to put the earlier inventions together.

“The test, known by the acronym ‘TSM,’ has been labeled as a poster-child for bad patent behavior,” Crouch said. “According to opponents of the test, the bright-line test makes patents too easy to obtain resulting in a glut of patents covering trivial improvements. Those patents, in turn, hold-up industry research and greatly increase transaction costs and legal fees.”

Homegrown Video President Spike Goldberg, a member of the Joint Defense Group — an adult entertainment industry coalition created to battle a wave of lawsuits filed by patent portfolio firm Acacia Technologies Group — told XBIZ the patent system is in desperate need of overhaul.

“Any decision that makes it easier to challenge a patent is a good thing,” Goldberg said.

Patent attorney Anna Vradenburgh told XBIZ the U.S. Supreme Court hears few patent cases, and likely chose to take up the obviousness test to clarify an issue that has long left room for interpretation.

According to reports from the court’s oral arguments, Justices may agree with Goldberg that the patent system is in need of reform, with Justice Antonin Scalia taking aim at the three elements of the obviousness test.

“It is misleading to say that the whole world is embraced within these three nouns,” Scalia said. “This is gobbledygook. It really is. It's irrational.”

But according to Crouch, Scalia and the rest of his colleagues must play catch-up with patent attorneys, many of whom filed amicus briefs in support of the rule through their bar associations.

“Much of the oral argument was filled with an attempt to simply understand the TSM test,” Crouch said. “If they cannot figure out the test, they would likely completely trash it as unworkable.”

With a decision expected in early February, Crouch cautioned against reading too much into comments made at oral argument.

“Reports from the hearing noted that Justice who used the term TSM spoke with disdain and were highly critical of the test,” Crouch said. “Although oral arguments are always full of counterfactuals and wild-theory testing, the level of criticism supports the conventional wisdom that the TSM test is likely to be eliminated as the exclusive test.”

In other words, change will come slowly to the patent system, if it is to come at all.

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

FSC Unpacks SCOTUS Age Verification Ruling in Webinar

The Free Speech Coalition conducted a public webinar Tuesday to help adult industry stakeholders understand the Supreme Court’s recent decision in FSC v. Paxton, and its potential implications.

UK Lawmaker Calls for Appointment of 'Porn Minister'

Baroness Gabrielle Bertin, the Conservative member of Parliament who recently convened a new anti-pornography task force, is calling for the appointment of a “minister for porn,” according to British news outlet The Guardian.

FSC Toasts Jeffrey Douglas for 30 Years of Service

n the very same evening when the adult industry was hit hard by the Supreme Court ruling supporting Texas’ controversial age verification law, HB 1181, members of the Free Speech Coalition board, staff and supporters gathered to celebrate Jeffrey Douglas’ 30 years as board chair — a fitting reflection of his reputation as an eternal optimist.

FSC: Age-Verification Laws Go Into Effect in South Dakota, Georgia, Wyoming on July 1

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) has published a statement regarding new age verification laws set to go into effect tomorrow in South Dakota, Georgia, and Wyoming.

FSC Responds to Supreme Court Decision on Texas AV Law

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) has released a statement responding to last week's Supreme Court decision on FSC v. Paxton, the Texas age verification law.

UPDATED: Supreme Court Rules Against Adult Industry in Pivotal Texas AV Case

The U.S. Supreme Court on Friday issued its decision in Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton, striking a blow against the online adult industry by ruling in support of Texas’ controversial age verification law, HB 1181.

North Carolina Passes Extreme Bill Targeting Adult Sites

The North Carolina state legislature this week ratified a bill that would impose new regulations that industry observers have warned could push adult websites and platforms to ban most adult creators and content.

Supreme Court Ruling Due Friday in FSC v. Paxton AV Case

The U.S. Supreme Court will rule on Friday in Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton, the adult industry trade association's challenge to Texas’ controversial age verification law, HB 1181.

Ofcom: More Porn Providers Commit to Age Assurance Measures

A number of adult content providers operating in the U.K. have confirmed that they plan to introduce age checks in compliance with the Online Safety Act by the July 25 deadline, according to U.K. media regulator Ofcom.

Aylo Says It Will Comply With UK Age Assurance Requirements

Tech and media company Aylo, which owns various adult properties including Pornhub, YouPorn and Redtube, plans to introduce age assurance methods in the United Kingdom that satisfy government rules under the Online Safety Act, the company has announced.

Show More