ACLU, EFF File Amicus Brief in FSC's Appeal of 2257 Case

PHILADELPHIA — In an amicus brief filed Monday, the ACLU and the Electronic Frontier Foundation sided with the Free Speech Coalition and other co-plaintiffs, asking the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeal to reverse a lower court ruling finding the federal record-keeping statutes for adult producers constitutional.

U.S. District Judge Michael Baylson last year found 18 U.S.C. §§ 2257, 2257A constitutional under the Fourth Amendment, except for in one regard — "the allowance of inspections at the residences of producers, without prior notice, cannot be justified on this record." The case is now on appeal at the 3rd Circuit.

The ACLU and EFF told the 3rd Circuit in the friend-of-the-court brief that they “seek to protect the rights of the millions of ordinary Americans who create sexually explicit ‘depictions’ for personal non-commercial use that put them at risk of criminal liability under 18 U.S.C. §§ 2257 and 2257A.”

The groups said that there is nothing narrow about the statutes, and that it stomps on free speech in a wide swath. They also noted that the district court should not have relied on governmental assurances relative to how the Justice Department would apply the statute.

Further, the groups said that the statute as written unnecessarily burdens those who might be “sexting” on a cellphone or those who use a social network or partake in adding content to tube sites. They also said that statute applies to a wide variety of professionals who use sexual images in their jobs for purposes completely unrelated to adult entertainment.

It covers a broad array of sexually explicit speech, and requires even private individuals who have produced images in the context of their own intimate relationships unintended for public distribution to label those images with identifying information; wait at home 20 hours a week in case the government should wish to drop by unannounced (or hire a third-party custodian), or run the risk of a felony conviction and up to five years in prison.”

Because it is obvious that the Constitution forbids Congress from criminalizing personal sexual expression, even the government itself has urged the court to construe the statute to apply only to depictions that are created for commercial sale or trade, the groups said.

“Unfortunately, however, the statute is not so limited; it clearly applies as well to noncommercial personal expression,” the groups said. “And as this court already held when it reversed and remanded this case to the district court, the statute cannot be saved by construing it narrowly when Congress chose instead to write it so broadly.”

Attorneys J. Michael Murray and Lorraine Baumgardner, representing the FSC, have asked the 3rd Circuit panel to reverse Baylson's ruling and remand with instructions to enter a judgment declaring 18 U.S.C. §§ 2257, 2257A and their implementing regulations unconstitutional under the First and Fourth Amendments and permanently enjoining their enforcement.

View amicus brief


Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Canada: Age Verification of Adult Content Becomes Election Issue

Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau criticized on Thursday at an event in Cape Breton comments by Conservative Party leader Pierre Poilievre stating that his government would require age verification for adult content if elected.

Agatha Vega Stars in 'The Path of Seduction' From Dorcel

2021 XBIZ Europas Best New Performer award winner Agatha Vega stars with Kristof Cale in "The Path of Seduction," from Dorcel.

Nebraska Republican Asserts Age Verification Aims to 'Protect Women' From Adult Content

The Nebraska Republican legislator behind the state’s copycat version of the age verification legislation being sponsored around the country by anti-porn religious conservative activists asserted Wednesday that his bill aims not only to shield minors from adult content but also to “protect women.”

Shay Sights Stars in 'Working Hard or Hardly Working' From TeamSkeet

Shay Sights stars with Max Fills in "Working Hard or Hardly Working," from TeamSkeet studio brand PervMom.

Blake Blossom Toplines 'Busty Hotties 2' From Dark X

Blake Blossom headlines "Busty Hotties 2," the latest title from Mile High Media studio brand Dark X.

Zariah Aura Headlines 'My Best Friend's TS Sister 2' From TransSensual

Zariah Aura stars with Haven Rose and Itzel Saenz in "My Best Friend's TS Sistser 2," from Mile High Media studio brand TransSensual.

MindBrowse Spotlights 'Minx' Creators at XBIZ LA, Session Now Streaming

Mindbrowse and have made available for streaming the full-length recording of “The Making of 'Minx' – Comedy, Culture, and Fictionalized Porn,” a discussion panel held at XBIZ LA in January.

Reagan Foxx Stars in 'Wedding Jitters' From Pure Taboo

2023 XBIZ MILF Performer of the Year Reagan Foxx stars with Maya Woulfe and Nathan Bronson in "Wedding Jitters" from Pure Taboo.

Carollina Cherry Toplines Dorcel's 'Room 212'

French star Carollina Cherry headlines "Room 212," the latest feature from Dorcel.

Evil Angel Premieres 'Oily Anal Play' From SecretCrush

Evil Angel has released the latest solo scene from Australian star Scarlet Chase's SecretCrush brand, titled "Oily Anal Play."

Show More