9th Circuit Affirms Ira Isaacs' Obscenity Conviction

PASADENA, Calif. — A federal appeals court today affirmed a lower court ruling over fetish filmmaker Ira Isaacs' obscenity conviction.

Isaacs, who has spent no time behind bars since the conviction in 2012, faces four years in prison over the mail distribution of "Mako’s First Time Scat, " "Hollywood Scat Amateurs #7," "Hollywood Scat Amateurs #10" and "Japanese Doggie 3 Way" — all deemed obscene by a jury.

Isaacs was convicted on one count of engaging in the business of producing and selling obscene matter,18 U.S.C. § 1466(a), one count of transportation of obscene matter for sale or distribution, 18 U.S.C. § 1465, one count of transportation of obscene matter, 18 U.S.C. § 1462(a), and two counts of mailing obscene matter, 18 U.S.C. § 1461.

He had appealed the final judgment in his third trial over obscenity charges; two other earlier trials had been declared mistrials.

Today's ruling by a three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals — Judges Ferdinand Fernandez, Susan Graber and Mary  Murguia — was based on several arguments made by Isaacs attorney Roger Jon Diamond, both in his appeal made last year and at oral arguments earlier this month.

Isaacs in one argument said that an alteration of jury instructions over the concept of "prurient interest" in the Miller test undermined the credibility of Diamond at the lower court.

The 1973 case, Miller vs. California, set a precedent on obscenity, making a film or artwork considered obscene only if  three conditions are satisfied. One of the conditions ask whether the average person, applying contemporary community standards would find that the work, taken as a whole, appeals to the prurient interest.

Diamond said he used the phrase "morbid, degrading and unhealthy" during closing arguments to define "prurient interest" but he also said "morbid, degrading or unhealthy" in reference to the lower court's jury instruction. The judge at the lower court, U.S. District Judge George King, instructed the jury that they could convict if a movie fit any of the three terms. But later King reinstructed the jury.

"Here, defense counsel himself used both conjunctive and disjunctive formulations in referring to the instruction during his argument, so it is unclear how the revision might have implied to the jury that Isaacs misled it as to the applicable law," the panel said in its ruling.

Isaacs also argued that the district court erred in sustaining objections. At oral arguments last month, Diamond told the panel that his closing argument was "substantially impaired" by a combination of constant interruptions and objections by the government and by King.

"I was instructed what to say and what not to say and I couldn't draw inferences; I couldn't do anything even though in an obscenity case [according to a Supreme Court ruling] all the government has to do in obscenity get the movie to the jury and let the jury look at the movie," Diamond told the panel last month.

The panel, however, ruled that the court did not abuse its discretion in requiring Diamond to confine his remarks to the record

Isaacs further challenged the district court’s exclusion of his proposed opinion testimony about "artistic value" but the panel rejected that as well.

Lastly, Isaacs unsuccessfully argued that the district court should not have permitted an FBI agent to sit with a computer at government counsel’s table and perform searches of publicly available information during voir dire.

The panel said it saw no abuse of judicial discretion and even noted that Isaacs conceded that the claim had no basis in existing law.

Isaacs, who was out on bond during the appeal, was unavailable at XBIZ post time for comment. His attorney, Diamond, declined comment at post time.

Isaacs, according to court procedure, can petition for a panel rehearing or an en banc (full court) rehearing over today's decision.

View ruling issued by 9th Circuit

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Rachael Cavalli, Tanya Tate & Phoenix Marie Star in Latest From MILFY

Rachael Cavalli, Tanya Tate, and Phoenix Marie star with Chocolate God in the latest release from Vixen Media Group (VMG) studio imprint MILFY.

Penthouse Names Zoey Luna February's 'Pet of the Month'

Penthouse Magazine has named model Zoey Luna as Pet of the Month for February.

New York Joins List of States Weighing AV Bills

New York has become the latest state to consider legislation that would require adult sites to verify the ages of users seeking to access adult content.

Vanessa Vega, Lilly Bell Make Their Transfixed Debuts

Vanessa Vega and newly crowned XMAs Girl/Girl Performer of the Year Lilly Bell have made their Transfixed debuts alongside Zariah Aura in “Caught By Their Coworker.”

Chloe Amour Headlines Jonni Darkko's Latest 'Double Penetration Fixation'

Chloe Amour toplines director Jonni Darkko’s “Double Penetration Fixation 5,” from Evil Angel.

Private Debuts 'An Orgy to Save My Marriage'

Private has released its latest title, "An Orgy to Save My Marriage," directed by Xavi Rocka.

Sedona Reign Stars in Latest From New Sensations

Sedona Reign stars with Jay Romero in the latest installment of New Sensations series "He's in Charge."

Violet Voss, Aria Banks Topline 'Dad's Lesbian Lover 2'

Violet Voss and Aria Banks headline the latest release from Girlfriends Films, titled “Dad’s Lesbian Lover 2.”

Grooby Names Avery Lust Brand Ambassador

Grooby has named Avery Lust as its 2025 brand ambassador.

Rana Katana Stars in Latest From TransAngels

Rana Katana stars with William Seed in the latest release from TransAngels, titled “Valentine Vixen.”

Show More