Isaacs Given Green Light for Testimony in Obscenity Trial

LOS ANGELES — Ira Isaacs won't be able to give expert testimony in his defense over federal obscenity violations, but he will be able to testify about what he aimed to achieve in creating one of the scat movies named in his indictment.

A federal judge in a pretrial ruling on Wednesday ordered trial to begin May 17 and will allow Isaacs to take the stand, a decision that allows him to offer "layperson testimony."

"This is a big victory," Isaacs told XBIZ. "Fact is that the prosecution did not want me to take the stand."

Isaacs has been charged with federal obscenity violations over the mail distribution of “Gang Bang Horse — ‘Pony Sex Game’” and “Mako’s First Time Scat,” as well as “Hollywood Scat Amateurs No. 7,” the film he created and the one he will be able to offer testimony for.

Isaacs has been pushing to offer testimony since a January pretrial hearing, but in Wednesday's ruling U.S. District Judge George King said that Isaacs proposal does not meet the standards for expert testimony.

"First, the court is concerned that [Isaacs] could provide no methodology in determining whether something qualifies as art or has serious artistic value," King said. "Defendant also points to the articles that have been written about the prosecution of him as evidence that his work has received the requisite amount of attention to distinguish it as art.

"This cannot be a proper methodology because prosecution for obscenity cannot have the legal affect of shielding the work from prosecution for the offense. Finally, defendant does not provide any examples of what is obscene or characteristics that would make some images obscene (short of some film director declaring his own work obscene)."

King, in his ruling, noted that the federal obscenity trial targeting Evil Angel founder John Stagliano faced a similar situation in deciding whether to certify Constance Penley, a professor of film studies at UC Santa Barbara, as an expert.

"That court ruled that although the professor possessed impressive credentials to discuss film studies, those credentials were not directly relevant to the task of distinguishing art from obscenity, and she had never written or lectured on the topic," King said.

But King in the ruling said that Isaacs' layman's testimony about art could be relevant in relation to the film he created, “Hollywood Scat Amateurs No. 7.”

"Given its inherent subjectivity, and the vast range of considerations a viewer of art might consider determinative in assessing a work of art, testimony concerning the artist’s goals, inspirations, and intended meaning is at least relevant," he said in the ruling.

"If testifying as a nonexpert, defendant would purportedly testify about his intentions in creating the video. The applicable legal standard here is whether a reasonable person, applying a nationwide standard, would think the work has serious artistic value."

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Peachy Alice Fronts Latest From Immoral Productions

Peachy Alice stars in a new trilogy from Immoral Productions, alongside Charlie Dean, Matt Bird, and studio honcho “Porno Dan” Leal.

Jessi Rae Signs Exclusive Contract With Vixen Media Group

Vixen Media Group (VMG) has signed Jessi Rae to an exclusive contract.

BranditScan Launches 'Referral Rush' Promo

BranditScan has launched its Referral Rush promotion for creators.

Pure Taboo Debuts Bree Mills Thriller 'The Party's Over'

Hazel Moore stars with Liz Jordan and Hailey Rose in the latest thriller from Pure Taboo, titled “The Party’s Over.”

Athena Heart Stars in Latest From TeamSkeet

Athena Heart stars with Jason Sarcinelli, Axel Haze, and Nick Strokes in the latest release from TeamSkeet.

Violet Myers, Valentina Nappi Star in Latest From Brazzers

2025 XMAs Premium Social Creator of the Year Violet Myers stars with Valentina Nappi and Ricky Johnson in the latest release from Brazzers, titled “V and V Share a Big D.”

2025 AltStar Awards Nominees Announced

Nominations have been announced for the 2025 AltStar Awards, aka the AltPorn Awards, presented by Bad Dragon.

AI Erotic Storytelling Platform 'AIEroticSmut' Launches

AIEroticSmut.com, a DIY erotic storytelling platform, has officially launched.

Angela White Stars in New Interactive Scene From Brazzers

Multi-XMAs winner Angela White stars with reigning and two-time XMAs Europas Male Performer of the Year Christian Clay in a new interactive release from Brazzers, titled “Taking Angela Back To Your Place.”

Marvin Love Directs 'Rich and Horny Weirdos' for Brazzers

Brazzers has released a new scene directed by Marvin Love, titled “Rich and Horny Weirdos.”

Show More