U.S. Supreme Court Rejects 2257 Challenge

WASHINGTON — Without comment, the U.S. Supreme Court on Monday denied a challenge to 18 U.S.C. § 2257, the federal recordkeeping and labeling law for the adult entertainment industry.

The 14-year-old case weighed by the court, Connection Distributing Co. vs. Holder, involved the ability of a publishing company to post sexually explicit photos of swingers to accompany advertisements seeking like-minded adults.

But on Monday, the justices’ refused to reconsider a ruling by the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which reaffirmed the legality of 2257.

The justices’ denial is a big defeat for the Free Speech Coalition, which tapped attorney J. Michael Murray and the Cleveland-based law firm of Berkman, Gordon, Murray and DeVan to move forward with litigation earlier this year.

FSC attorneys argued that 2257 is overly broad because it requires age verification for older adults and because it applies to couples in their own homes.

Diane Duke, executive director of the FSC, told XBIZ that she was disappointed that the Supreme Court didn’t grant cert.

“2257 does nothing to stop child pornography; it does nothing more than overburden legal adult businesses,” she said. “It is outrageous it is unconstitutional and we are going to continue the fight.

“FSC is prepared to continue the fight challenging the new regulations and broadening the plaintiff base,” she said.

The government, in a brief to the court, argued that the 6th Circuit correctly held that 2257 is constitutional as applied to the Connections case.

“Not only is there no conflict among the courts of appeals on this issue, but as the [6th Circuit] en banc court recognized, Section 2257 ‘has withstood every as-applied 1st Amendment challenge to the law by the real people and businesses to whom it most naturally has been applied over the last 20 years,’” said the brief, noting that the record-keeping statute is content-neutral because it is justified without reference to the content of the regulated speech.

Government attorneys also argued that 2257 doesn’t necessarily ban sexually explicit images.

“As long as producers of sexually explicit depictions comply with the statute's recordkeeping and disclosure provisions, they are free to express any message they want,” the brief said. “Section 2257 regulates only the manner in which the images are produced, to combat the use of underage performers.”

On Monday, the justices agreed with the government in Connections vs. Holder, 08-1449.

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Japanese Manga Industry Hit by Credit Card Companies' Anti-Porn Restrictions

The immensely popular Japanese manga industry is reporting increasing pressure from multinational credit card companies — many based in the U.S. and directly targeted by anti-porn crusades by religious conservatives — to censor their contents to maintain their current payment processing arrangements.

Tru Kait: The Go! Go! Go! Girl

“I’m a ‘Go! Go! Go!’ person,” TruKait tells us in that charming, laid-back Texas-and-Tennessee twang so familiar to her legion of fans.

Netherlands Government Continues Porn Probe Following Abuse Allegations

The Dutch government plans to continue investigating the local porn industry in the Netherlands, following a series of abuse allegations involving photographer and self-styled “model scout” Daniël van der W.

Zariah Aura Toplines 'My TS Stepmom 7' From TransSensual

Zariah Aura headlines the seventh volume of "My TS Stepmon," from Mile High Media studio imprint TransSensual.

Bryan Gozzling Returns to Performing Alongside Myra Moans

Hookup Hotshot studio honcho Bryan Gozzling has returned to performing for the first time since 2023, alongside Myra Moans.

Karlee Grey, Vanna Bardot Star in Latest 'Lez Be Bad'

Karlee Grey stars with reigning and two-time XBIZ Female Performer of the Year Vanna Bardot in “Coming Out on Top,” the latest episode of Adult Time’s “Lez Be Bad.”

Hailey Rose, Max Fills Go for 'All or Nothing' With Indie Film

Back in college, before she ever shot any adult videos or content, Hailey Rose had a particularly memorable sexual experience. Now, Rose and her real-life partner, fellow award-winning creator Max Fills, have joined forces with a mainstream director to create a retelling of that encounter.

TeamSkeet Debuts 1st Installment of 'Swapception'

TeamSkeet has released the first installment of its latest feature, "Swapception," from its new studio brand Swappz.

May Hashira, Violet Myers Star in Latest From Ricky's Room

May Hashira and Violet Myers star in the latest threesome release from Ricky's Room, titled "Gold Medal Oral."

Clips4Sale Releases '20 Years of Fetish' Data Survey

Clips4Sale (C4S) has released a report based on 20 years of data and analysis to show how kink and fetish tastes have changed since the site began.

Show More