Victory for Domain Owners in Kentucky

LOUISVILLE — The Kentucky Court of Appeals has enacted an order prohibiting the Franklin Circuit Court from seizing scores of Internet domain names.

The move hopefully brings to an end the democratic Governor Steve Beshear's effort to seize the domain names of 141 gambling-related websites as a protectionist move to bolster the state's gaming industry, which centers on horse race wagering.

Beshear prompted Franklin Circuit Judge Thomas Wingate to issue the widely contested seizure order, which never had any real effect as the state cannot control a website's content until the names are forfeited to the state.

"We have Kentucky exercising worldwide jurisdiction," attorney William E. Johnson said of the proceedings, which have seen friend-of-the-court filings by the Electronic Frontier Foundation, the Center for Democracy and Technology, the American Civil Liberties Union of Kentucky, Network Solutions and The Poker Players Alliance.

According to Erik Lycan, an attorney representing the state, gambling sites are engaged "in a massive offshore criminal conspiracy [masquerading] as a legitimate business."

According to Larry Walters, an attorney representing Golden Palace in the underlying case, the site owners were obviously quite pleased with the court's decision.

"The parties raised so many legal and constitutional defects in the Commonwealth's position, that we were not sure which one would bring down the house of cards," Walters told XBIZ.

One issue at hand was whether or not domain names can be classified as gambling devices, since they do not meet the legal definition of being a manufactured electronic device and as such covered under Kentucky's 1974 gaming statutes which predate the commercial availability of the Internet.

"The Appellate Court decided to focus on whether domain names could constitute 'gambling devices' under Kentucky law," Walters said. "Not surprisingly, it found that they did not and therefore could not be seized."

Thus, the Constitutional conundrums were avoided.

"A basic principle of constitutional law requires the courts to avoid ruling on constitutional questions if there are other grounds on which to resolve a dispute," Walters noted. "In this appeal, the court avoided the difficult constitutional issues relating to Freedom of Speech and the Commerce Clause by honing in on the 'gambling device' issue, and shutting down this ill-conceived prosecution."

During a hearing in the appellate court last month, two of the three judges reportedly expressed skepticism as to the case's merits; with Judge Jeff Taylor raising concerns over how the government could seize domain names without prosecuting the website operators and giving them their day in court.

"We'll have to wait and see whether the Commonwealth decides to pursue this case any further, but for now, our clients are pleased with the result," Walters concluded.

View Document


Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Cosplayground Releases 'Furiosa XXX: A Porn Parody'

Cosplayground has released its seventh original production, “Furiosa XXX: A Porn Parody.”

Washington Post Profiles ECP VP Solomon Friedman's Appearance at XBIZ LA

The Washington Post published this weekend a lengthy feature about Pornhub and Aylo, focusing on Ethical Capital Partners’ VP of Compliance Solomon Friedman’s keynote address and other appearances at XBIZ Los Angeles in January.

'Sex Workers Deserve Protections': Congressional Candidate Joe Cohn Reaches Out to Adult Community

Veteran civil rights attorney Joe Cohn, who is currently running in a New Jersey Democratic primary for a seat in the U.S. House of Representatives, says he is reaching out to the adult community to champion an inclusive approach to civil liberties that encompasses all sex workers and adult businesses.

Mile High Unveils New Unscripted Studio 'Sex on Sight'

Mile High Media has launched a new unscripted-content studio, Sex on Sight.

Belgian Producer Dennis Black Magic Sentenced to 7 Years for Rape, CSAM

Belgian adult producer and director Dennis Black Magic has been sentenced to seven years in prison and a $4,000 fine for the rape of eight models and distribution of CSAM.

Seoul Authorities Force Cancellation of Adult Expo for 'Distorting Perceptions of Sex'

After Seoul authorities repeatedly prevented 2024 KXF The Fashion from finding a suitable venue, event organizers have canceled the popular Korean adult industry expo, which was scheduled for this week.

FSC to Hold Discussion on Adult Industry Rights With Congressional Candidate Joe Cohn

Free Speech Coalition will hold a virtual discussion with congressional candidate Joe Cohn, whom the organization calls a strong advocate for adult industry rights.

Sophie Dee, Ricky Johnson to Deliver 'XBIZ Talks' at Miami Conference

XBIZ is pleased to announce that Sophie Dee and Ricky Johnson will each deliver an “XBIZ Talk” at next month’s XBIZ Miami conference

FSC to Examine How 'Derisking' in Banking Affects Adult Industry

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) is hosting a webinar on derisking in the financial services industry, titled "Derisking: Examining Its Impact on the Adult Industry's Access to Banking," on April 24 at 11 a.m. (PDT).

Democratic Governor Fails to Veto Kansas Age Verification Bill

Kansas’ Democratic governor, Laura Kelly, expressed strong reservations about the state’s version of the age verification bills being sponsored around the country by anti-porn religious conservative activists, but ultimately decided not to veto it, allowing the legislation to become law by default without her signature.

Show More