Kentucky Court Stops Domain Seizures

LOS ANGELES — Kentucky's Court of Appeals has granted a motion to stay the state's transfer and seizure of 141 Internet domain names.

The case involves a move by Kentucky Governor Stephen Beshear and state Secretary of Justice and Public Safety, Michael J. Brown, to seize domain names belonging to online gambling websites. As a result, Franklin County Circuit Judge Thomas Wingate ordered a forfeiture hearing; while the Justice Cabinet also asked the court to order domain name registrars to transfer the targeted names to the state in advance of the forfeiture hearing.

"Unlicensed, unregulated, illegal Internet gambling poses a tremendous threat to the citizens of the commonwealth because of its ease, availability and anonymity," Beshear said. "The owners and operators of these illegal sites prey on Kentucky citizens, including our youth, and deprive the commonwealth of millions of dollars in revenue. It's an underworld wrought with scams and schemes."

Brown echoed Beshear's sentiments, and added another reason why the state should be allowed to seize these websites — to protect the children:

"Illegal Internet gambling poses a unique threat to our commonwealth. For individuals — particularly our youth — it is tantamount to a virtual home invasion. For some of our vital and most venerable legitimate enterprises, it undermines their exemplary regulatory compliance and siphons away their constituents," Brown said. "We are hopeful that once this litigation is concluded, the commonwealth will be off limits to these illegal purveyors."

Critics of the state's "block Kentucky residents from your website or have it seized" tactics, however, claim that the real motivation behind the seizure attempt is financial, as the comments by Brown about the "vital and most venerable legitimate enterprises" that have shown "exemplary regulatory compliance" (meaning, horse racing), illustrate. What is really happening is that the state is making way for established race track betting to go online, and wants to clear away the competition, which it sees as "siphon[ing] away their constituents" — and thus, tax income.

Washington-based Internet trade association Interactive Media Entertainment & Gaming Association (iMEGA) petitioned the appeals court to stay the forfeiture hearing while the lower court seizure ruling was appealed. The appeals court combined iMEGA's petition with one filed by the Interactive Gaming Council (IGC) of Vancouver, B.C.

"We're pleased that the Court of Appeals has given us the opportunity to challenge these seizures," Joe Brennan Jr., iMEGA's chairman, said. "The commonwealth has tried to take these domains for their own financial gain, violating Kentucky law, exceeding their jurisdiction, and setting a terrible precedent in the process."

The groups assert that the lower court did not have the jurisdiction to order the seizures and that it misused the state's "gambling devices" law to provide an excuse for permitting the seizures, among other claims.

"This matter has generated concerns across the online world about abuse of governmental power," Brennan said. "Kentucky is opening the door for any government — state and local, foreign and domestic — to use what amounts to blackmail to achieve its ends."

According to iMEGA, none of the 141 contested domain names are owned by individuals or companies located in Kentucky.

"If this precedent is allowed to stand, it's not hard to imagine a government like China utilizing this kind of seizure power to prevent free media, like the New York Times, from reaching their citizens," Brennan added.

A comment by "JMG" on the Techdirt blog summed it up nicely: "Kentucky has a bipolar disorder when it comes to gambling. On- and off-track horse race betting — good," JMG wrote. "Any other form of legalized gambling leads to organized crime, prostitution, broken homes and families, and other evils that harm the children."


Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Adult Site Broker Talk's Bruce Friedman Reflects on Podcast Success

The 200th episode of Adult Site Broker Talk will air next week, with 2023 XBIZ Performer of the Year Cherie DeVille as a very special guest.

FSC Asks Supreme Court to Overturn 5th Circuit Decision, Strike Texas' Age Verification Law

Free Speech Coalition (FSC) filed a petition for certiorari on Friday asking the U.S. Supreme Court to overturn the Fifth Circuit panel decision that partially upheld Texas’ controversial age verification law.

Details Emerge About Capture, Arrest of GirlsDoPorn's Michael Pratt

Further details have emerged in the past week about the capture and arrest of GirlsDoPorn owner Michael Pratt in Spain in December 2022, following his extradition to the U.S. last month.

Magdalene St. Michaels, Andy Rodrigues Named as AEBN Top Stars for Q1 of 2024

AEBN has announced its top-selling stars for the first quarter of 2024, with Magdalene St. Michaels landing atop the leader board for straight theaters and Andy Rodrigues heading up the gay rankings.

YouPay Partners With IP Security Solution Sidenty

Australian gifting platform YouPay has joined forces with IP security solution Sidenty to help creators guard against online theft and unauthorized use of their content.

Grooby Launches Fetish Site 'Joey's Trans Feet Girls'

Grooby has debuted Joey's Trans Feet Girls, a new fetish membership site featuring foot content by top trans performers.

Lady Lyne Launches New Paysite Through AdultPrime

IMC’s AdultPrime has expanded its network of paysites with the launch performer Lady Lyne's official site.

UK Media Regulator Encourages Companies, Creators to Provide Feedback on 'Categorized Services'

U.K. media regulator Ofcom is again asking adult industry companies, creators and other stakeholders to provide feedback to help it establish new regulations under the Online Safety Act (OSA) — regulations that will impact the accessibility of online adult content.

Internet Researcher Maggie MacDonald Pens Op-Ed on the Risks of Canada's Age Verification Proposals

Online safety academic and Ethical Capital Partners’ advisory board member Maggie MacDonald penned an editorial for the Toronto Globe and Mail arguing that although mandatory age-verification for adult content will not work to prevent online harms for minors, it will erode everyone’s privacy instead.

LoyalFans to Hold 'Master Class' Event With Ezada Sinn

LoyalFans will hold a special "Master Class" livestream with content creator Ezada Sinn, titled "Growing Your LoyalFans Account & Creating Passive Income," on Saturday at 2 p.m. EDT.

Show More