Why Is Intellectual Property Theft Tolerated?

Why Is Intellectual Property Theft Tolerated?

For those who know me, you’ll already know I have strong feelings on the subject of intellectual property. As innovators, we are constantly finding our best ideas — whether or not we have protected the intellectual property (IP) with patents — copied by other manufacturers.

This can happen shamelessly, where there isn’t even a difference in the color of the product — it is an exact copy, outright theft of someone else’s design. This is very distressing for the many innovators that are smaller companies, like mine. Losing revenues due to stolen intellectual property has a direct effect on the industry’s ability to grow. The companies that create dupes often rob sales from the innovators, creating an endless cycle of innovation and theft.

Someone needs to stand up for the innovators who take chances and bring new ideas to fruition.

To understand the true impact of a loss in revenue, you have to assess the costs of developing a radical, game-changing product, including the value of time spent. The life cycle of product design and development for a new innovation takes, on average, a minimum of two years. I’ve even hired companies to conduct focus groups for some of our innovations and in one case this added two additional years to the development cycle.

Every development starts with a “breakthrough” idea. This drives new thinking on how to create a product based on a single thought. Before an initial design is made, significant research needs to be completed in order to understand the parameters and key elements of the project. The research process alone can take six months to over a year’s time.

Once you have enough background information to design the product, you begin drawing it. The process of designing, drawing and creating a prototype of a new idea often takes six months. After executing the idea, it still needs to be tested, adding an additional few months. This cycle, an average of eight months in total, is almost always done twice. The first round is theorizing and creating an initial prototype. The second is the development of a fully functional prototype that, when tested, proves the concept. If all goes well, the next stage is production.

Imagine that we are now at the two-and-a-half-year mark. Ideally, the time and money spent thus far is now supposed to yield a return via sales. But the reality is that new concepts take many months — and more likely, years — to gain traction within the target market. So, for the first year, you spend time educating the distributors and retailers on the idea. But no matter how innovative the idea is, if the product does not sell out of the gate, you will lose support for promotions and restocking from certain channels.

Therefore, the burden of education, selling and promotion falls back onto the manufacturer. This costs money. For instance, our company has not only one but two public relations firms to help promote our new concepts. Without promotion, it’s a hard sell, making all that time and money spent go to waste. A product usually doesn't gain traction until at least two years following its launch — usually three to four years, after substantial investment in marketing and training.

So, how does company that steals your intellectual property benefit? They don’t have to do anything aside from designing a copy. They receive the benefits by taking a shortcut and mooching your time, money and effort. The real kicker is that the copycats have no sales risk, considering the product has already proved its success.

Although patenting your designs is an important step in preventing intellectual property theft, the truth is that it does not guarantee protection. Legal battles can be quite costly and rarely is a product so successful that it justifies such an expense. But more importantly, this is yet another cost for the innovators. Another consideration, which should not be taken lightly, is that larger companies that have the means to engage in a legal dispute have an arsenal of moves they can leverage if provoked. It is best to have a very strong case on a profitable product or multiple cases if this it to be initiated. It can take years to collect all the data you need to build that case.

Consumers, unaware of this injustice, are reaping the benefits of having a wide selection of products to choose from based on your idea and design. To make matters worse, more often than not the innovator is a relatively small company without the resources to market as effectively as larger companies. They get lost in the clutter.

How do knock-offs get sold anyway? It has everything to do with distributors and retailers. I believe the first tier of distributors have the ability to act in good faith. I’ve seen plenty of buyers discontinue carrying a knock-off because they could clearly see someone else was trying to profit off of our efforts.

It is reasonable to ask a distributor or retailer not to sell dupes. They are the purchasers of the product and they should have their own set of ethics including selling original works only. But my experience is that some of the largest distributors require the law to intervene first. In other words, if you don’t show them a lawsuit then they won't take sides. Once again, the burden is back on the innovators by requiring a lawsuit, while the competitors are profiting from the sales. If the first tier of buyers won’t stand up for the innovators, then who exactly will? And if they don't, are they any better than the company that is stealing the idea?

In reality, distributors decide all the time not to carry products, and so do retailers. They exercise their right to be selective all the time such as when they think a product won’t sell, or already stock an assortment that is too similar. So, it is not unreasonable for them to exercise good judgment in this scenario.

This is where real values come into action. I can think of a company (no, not mine) that has been a horrific victim of shameless stealing. I know that if the distributors and retailers had supported the original inventor, without requiring the law to intervene, we would have seen more amazing innovations from them. It’s unlikely at this point, and so our industry has lost a genius inventor who is being robbed his rightful revenue. Meanwhile, those distributors and retailers are making money on the knock-off.

Someone needs to stand up for the innovators who take chances and bring new ideas to fruition. If innovations are to be stolen by larger companies, where is the incentive to keep conceptualizing products that yield a better way of life? Distributors and retailers need to take action or our industry will become stagnant and cluttered. I have never seen a knock-off that works as well as the original version, so why not buy the one that works, the one the innovator makes?

Steve Callow is the inventor, designer and CEO of Florida-based Perfect Fit Brand. Established in 2011, Perfect Fit is the manufacturer of innovative, high-quality and easy-to-use sexual health aids and sex toys for the full gender and sexuality spectrum. Callow founded the company based on the principle that sex toys should not only look and feel great, but must, above all, perform.


Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles


The ABCs of POS Systems for Adult Store Owners

What point-of-sale system is best for your adult business? Figuring that out can be frustrating, since the numerous options and acronyms don’t easily translate into a clear checklist of features and benefits you can weigh.

Sean Quinn ·

How Pleasure Brands Can Leverage Strategic PR Amid Mainstream Media Layoffs

Thanks to the mainstreaming of pleasure products, pleasure brands can now gain broad exposure in all kinds of publications, from Cosmo to Allure to Good Housekeeping. Unfortunately, the economic uncertainty dominating the world and challenging businesses has hit the media sector particularly hard.

Kathryn Byberg ·

WIA Profile: Ruth Arceo

In the beginning, all Ruth Arceo knew was that she dreamed of being a buyer — but when the opportunity presented itself for a career in the adult world, she found she’d struck it rich. Arceo is the lucky lady who gets to pick and choose how to line the shelves at The Pleasure Chest in West Hollywood, California.

Women In Adult ·

CalExotics Founder and CEO Susan Colvin Reflects on Brand's 30-Year Legacy

Thirty years ago, back when there were only hard plastic sex toys in tan and black, Susan Colvin had a vision of what sex toys could be. And so she set out to create her own company, California Exotic Novelties, which for three decades has been a pioneer, continually reimagining and expanding the pleasure products market.

Kim Airs ·

How to Sell Shoppers on Water-Friendly Toys

From soothing self-care in the bath to the invigorating spray of a shower, water can introduce new dimensions of pleasure, unlock unique sensations and provide a sensual backdrop for intimate exploration.

Carly S. ·

Why BDSM Furniture and Sex Machines Make an Ideal Match

For BDSM enthusiasts and curious newbies alike, a big part of the fun is discovering and exploring exciting new sensations and scenarios. One way to level up is by combining or layering pleasures you already enjoy, and one surefire way to do that is with BDSM furniture.

Rebecca Weinberg ·

Tips for Boosting Ecommerce Revenue With Behavioral Insights

At our marketing agency, we focus on using real data to make better decisions for our clients. We believe every action a visitor takes on a website can tell us something important. This helps us shape our strategies and assist our clients in turning casual website visitors into loyal customers.

Lauren Bailey ·

A Look at the Do's and Don'ts of Gift-With-Purchase Promos

Imagine you’re at a store, deciding between two products with similar packaging, features and pricing. You’re not predisposed toward either brand and you haven’t seen any reviews — but one of them offers, “Free gift with purchase!” Does that win you over?

Vanessa Rose ·

Tips for Navigating a Completely Remote Job in Sexual Wellness

Anyone working in the sexual wellness and pleasure sector has at some point had to deal with issues like bias against the industry, as well as limited marketing and advertising options.

Bryony Lees ·

Meet the 2024 Class of Up-and-Coming Pleasure Brands to Watch

With each new year that rolls in, new pleasure brands emerge, and 2024 is no exception. Already this year, a slew of new entrants are rapidly gaining traction and recognition via social media, among retailers and distributors — and most importantly, end consumers.

Show More