opinion

Part One: Can Copyright Be Fixed?

If there’s one thing that just about everybody agrees upon with respect to the current state of copyright laws and intellectual property rights-enforcement, it’s that the system is broken.

Whether you are a rightsholder who has grown weary of the ceaseless game of whack-a-mole that issuing DMCA take-down notices represents, or an advocate for the outright abolishment of copyright, you see the need for copyright to be reformed. Can it be done? Can copyright be fixed? Perhaps more to the point, can copyright learn to live in harmony with the very technologies that have made intellectual property rights so hard to enforce in an online context?

The good news is that there’s hope for a systemic reform of both copyright law and digital media distribution protocols ...

I believe that the answer to each of these questions is “yes,” but I also believe the crucial first step is to quit bickering about the root causes of the current copyright quagmire, and instead focus on the desired outcome of the effort to reform copyright.

Too often, discussions about copyright become mired in blame assessment, with extremists from either end of the copyright reform spectrum dominating the conversation. We hear accusations of corporate greed, we hear about “copyright troll” attorneys and allegations of their ethical abuses, we hear about “freetards” and a growing sense of entitlement among young consumers, but we never get to the important part. We never address the question: What can be done about this mess?

By directing our attention first to crafting a vision of what a post-reform copyright system might look like, and how it would function, hopefully we can abandon the generally useless debate concerning who’s to blame for the current state of affairs, and get to work on building a system that all of us can live with.

To me, any such discussion has to start with a recitation of a basic market fact that has been foisted upon the world by the forward march of communications and entertainment technology: As a producer and/or rights-holder, the days of dictating exactly how, when and where people consume the works you create are over, dead, kaput — and they are NOT coming back.

Looking for ways to stuff that particular genie back in the bottle, or seeking to impose a ‘scheduled broadcast’ model onto a unruly beast like the Internet is like trying to force the rain falling on your roof to go upward, instead; it’s an exercise in futility, and an entirely senseless one, at that. So, if your goal as a content producer is to exercise total control over your creations post-publication, you can forget about that idea, right here and now.

The answer is clearly not to curse, bemoan and/or attempt to “work around” the existence of the technologies used to illegally distribute your intellectual property, either; if that approach worked, Hollywood would have nothing to worry about with respect to piracy. The answer is to concoct a way to put those same technologies to use for you — and no, I’m not talking about simply seeding files out there and hoping for some sort of difficult-to-measure branding benefit; I’m talking about making money, directly off of consumption of free content, even if that content is displayed on a thirdparty’s website, consumed via some manner of peer-to-peer protocol, or any other modern mechanism for digital content distribution. Exactly how that can be accomplished will be addressed in a future installment of this series; for now, I’d like to get back to picturing the end state and goal for our collective copyright “fix.”

To me, the post-fix world would be one in which rights-holders no longer feel compelled to constantly police the Web in order to enforce their IP rights, including the compulsion to sue consumers for downloading illicit copies of their works. Ideally, there would be no such thing as a “copyright troll,” because no rights-holder would feel the need to target end-users for downloading their works.

It would be an environment in which monetization of online content distribution is accomplished in an automated way, essentially running on “autopilot.”

From a consumer perspective, a post-fix world would include an expansion (or at least a clarification) of their fair use rights in the context of increasingly common online activities. For example, consumers would be able to send a friend a link to their favorite movies without having to fret about whether a demand letter from attorneys representing the studios that created those movies would someday land in their mailbox.

This all might sound like a pipe dream, and perhaps it is. Given the current situation, however, in which some of the world’s most prolific digital pirates largely operate with impunity, end-users who do far less damage than the prolific pirates find themselves facing lawsuits over their indulgence in ill-gotten media files, and rights-holders watch helplessly as their annual revenues plummet in the face of rampant online copyright infringement, doesn’t it behoove all involved to at least try to come up with a workable system for ensuring that everyone gets a fair shake?

The good news is that there’s hope for a systemic reform of both copyright law and digital media distribution protocols, and that hope stems from the very same technologies that many rights-holders have come to resent due to their central role in facilitating (intentionally or otherwise) widespread piracy of digital goods.

The second installment of this series will lay out one approach to such reform that I believe has serious promise — and reveal that it isn’t a new idea, at all, just one that was substantially ahead of its time when first conceived … in the 1980s.

Stay tuned.

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

profile

WIA Profile: Salima

When Salima first entered the adult space in her mid-20s, becoming a power player wasn’t even on her radar. She was simply looking to learn. Over the years, however, her instinct for strategy, trust in her teams and commitment to creator-first innovation led her from the trade show floor to the executive suite.

Women in Adult ·
opinion

How the Interstate Obscenity Definition Act Could Impact Adult Businesses

Congress is considering a bill that would change the well-settled definition of obscenity and create extensive new risks for the adult industry. The Interstate Obscenity Definition Act, introduced by Sen. Mike Lee, makes a mockery of the First Amendment and should be roundly rejected.

Lawrence G. Walters ·
opinion

What US Sites Need to Know About UK's Online Safety Act

In a high-risk space like the adult industry, overlooking or ignoring ever-changing rules and regulations can cost you dearly. In the United Kingdom, significant change has now arrived in the form of the Online Safety Act — and failure to comply with its requirements could cost merchants millions of dollars in fines.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

Understanding the MATCH List and How to Avoid Getting Blacklisted

Business is booming, sales are steady and your customer base is growing. Everything seems to be running smoothly — until suddenly, Stripe pulls the plug. With one cold, automated email, your payment processing is shut down. No warning, no explanation.

Jonathan Corona ·
profile

WIA Profile: Leah Koons

If you’ve been to an industry event lately, odds are you’ve heard Leah Koons even before you’ve seen her. As Fansly’s director of marketing, Koons helps steer one of the fastest-growing creator platforms on the web.

Women in Adult ·
opinion

What France's New Law Means for Age Verification Worldwide

When France implemented its Security and Regulation of the Digital Space (SREN) law on April 11, it marked a pivotal moment in the ongoing global debate surrounding online safety and access to adult content.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
opinion

From Tariffs to Trends: Staying Resilient in a Shaky Online Adult Market

Whenever I check in with clients these days, I encounter the same concerns. For many, business has not quite bounced back after the typical post-holiday-season slowdown. Instead, consumers have been holding back due to the economic uncertainty around the Trump administration’s new tariffs and their impact on prices.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

Optimizing Payment Strategies for High Ticket Sales

Payment processing for more expensive items, such as those exceeding $1,000 per order, can create unique challenges. For adult businesses, those challenges are magnified. Increased fraud risk, elevated chargeback ratios and heavier scrutiny from banks and processors are only the beginning.

Jonathan Corona ·
profile

WIA Profile: Lexi Morin

Lexi Morin’s journey into the adult industry began with a Craigslist ad and a leap of faith. In 2011, fresh-faced and ambitious, she was scrolling through job ads on Craigslist when she stumbled upon a listing for an assistant makeup artist.

Women In Adult ·
profile

Still Rocking: The Hun Celebrates 30 Years in the Game

In the ever-changing landscape of adult entertainment, The Hun’s Yellow Pages stands out for its endurance. As one of the internet’s original fixtures, literally nearly as old as the web itself, The Hun has functioned as a living archive for online adult content, quietly maintaining its relevance with an interface that feels more nostalgic than flashy.

Jackie Backman ·
Show More