opinion

Does Caveat Emptor Apply When it's for Free?

The current hoo-ha over pre-checked cross sales is mostly much ado about nothing, except when it isn't. Simply put, a straightforward issue when pre-checked boxes are clearly visible to the consumer and bordered by as much signage as possible becomes quickly crooked when the boxes are under the fold and far below the submit button. At that point, the accusation of consumer abuse that reflects negatively on the industry seems reasonable, no matter how much money the companies employing such practices are making. Those who argue otherwise are in most cases simply justifying money that they or their bosses are obtaining fraudulently.

But generally speaking those who use pre-checked cross sales are engaging in the exact type of aggressive marketing that merchants around the world have employed since the beginning of time and still employ today, and indeed many of the ploys used in adult are almost quaint in their efforts to deceive. If you want to get your pocket picked by a pro, which means not even knowing you were scammed, there is no finer grifter on the planet than your average everyday mainstream businessman.

I recently was snared by one such scam that is currently being perpetrated by a company spending many millions of dollars advertising on TV. As wary as I am about these things, they got me hook, line and sinker and though I succeeded in getting my money back (after calling several times and threatening to file a report) I do feel as if I didn't fully employ caveat emptor vigilance and that I am at least partly to blame.

It's not a good feeling, especially since I wasn't buying anything and didn't give my credit card to anyone. I was ordering something that I thought was free because it was advertised as free with no fine print in sight. I was even sent away from the page where I knew hidden costs were involved to a site which I was explicitly told had no hidden costs, in a highly sophisticated (and in this case successful) attempt to confuse me, the consumer. Without even providing any financial information to anyone, one of my credit cards was nonetheless charged and I didn't realize it for months.

I'm too old to have any illusions about the lengths people will go to make money, and have developed a level of cynicism that holds trebly true for the adult industry, which over the past decade has indulged in its share of consumer rip offs, many involving the fluid leveraging of the promise of free. I also am well aware that the industry is seeing a sharp increase in scam-type behavior, with some of the methods old as the hills while others are new and creative.

But with Wall Street in a shambles, I expect to see more money eyeing adult as a potential haven during the hard times. We've already seen that happening but expect it to intensify. Personally, I don't think this trend if it persists will bring a greater level of maturity to the business. To the contrary, the adult entertainment industry reflects the sense of insecurity that so many economic sectors are currently experiencing. The difference is that there is no huge spotlight on the way we do business, and even if there were we proceed with lesser expectations than other marketplaces. Deserved or not, the anticipated scum factor is one reason why we are a high risk industry.

All I know is, in a world of free content the doctrine of caveat emptor is increasingly relevant, not less.

Related:  

Copyright © 2026 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More Articles

opinion

Outlook 2026: Industry Execs Weigh In on Strategy, Monetization and Risk

The adult industry enters 2026 at a moment of concentrated change. Over the past year, the sector’s evolution has accelerated. Creators have become full-scale businesses, managing branding, compliance, distribution and community under intensifying competition. Studios and platforms are refining production and business models in response to pressures ranging from regulatory mandates to shifting consumer preferences.

Jackie Backman ·
opinion

How Platforms Can Tap AI to Moderate Content at Scale

Every day, billions of posts, images and videos are uploaded to platforms like Facebook, Instagram, TikTok and X. As social media has grown, so has the amount of content that must be reviewed — including hate speech, misinformation, deepfakes, violent material and coordinated manipulation campaigns.

Christoph Hermes ·
opinion

What DSA and GDPR Enforcement Means for Adult Platforms

Adult platforms have never been more visible to regulators than they are right now. For years, the industry operated in a gray zone: enormous traffic, massive data volume and minimal oversight. Those days are over.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
opinion

Making the Case for Network Tokens in Recurring Billing

A declined transaction isn’t just a technical error; it’s lost revenue you fought hard to earn. But here’s some good news for adult merchants: The same technology that helps the world’s largest subscription services smoothly process millions of monthly subscriptions is now available to you as well.

Jonathan Corona ·
opinion

Navigating Age Verification Laws Without Disrupting Revenue

With age verification laws now firmly in place across multiple markets, merchants are asking practical questions: How is this affecting traffic? What happens during onboarding? Which approaches are proving workable in real payment flows?

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

How Adult Businesses Can Navigate Global Compliance Demands

The internet has made the world feel small. Case in point: Adult websites based in the U.S. are now getting letters from regulators demanding compliance with foreign laws, even if they don’t operate in those countries. Meanwhile, some U.S. website operators dealing with the patchwork of state-level age verification laws have considered incorporating offshore in the hopes of avoiding these new obligations — but even operators with no physical presence in the U.S. have been sued or threatened with claims for not following state AV laws.

Larry Walters ·
opinion

Top Tips for Bulletproof Creator Management Contracts

The creator management business is booming. Every week, it seems, a new agency emerges, promising to turn creators into stars, automate their fan interactions or triple their revenue through “secret” social strategies. The reality? Many of these agencies are operating with contracts that wouldn’t survive a single serious dispute — if they even have contracts at all.

Corey D. Silverstein ·
opinion

Building Sustainable Revenue Without Opt-Out Cross-Sales

Over the past year, we’ve seen growing pushback from acquirers on merchants using opt-out cross-sales — also known as negative option offers. This has been especially noticeable in the U.S. In fact, one of our acquirers now declines new merchants during onboarding if an opt-out flow is detected. Existing merchants submitting new URLs with opt-out cross-sales are being asked to remove them.

Cathy Beardsley ·
opinion

How to Handle Payment Disputes Without Sacrificing Trust

You can run the best-managed and most compliant website out there, but that still doesn’t completely shield you from the risks tied to payment disputes. Buyer’s remorse, an unclear billing description or even a simple misunderstanding can lead a customer to dispute a transaction. Accumulate enough disputes, and both your reputation and revenue could be at risk.

Jonathan Corona ·
profile

WIA Profile: Taylor Moore

With a 70-person team and a growing slate of tools for content creators, the Teasy Agency has developed a reputation for putting talent first. That commitment owes a lot to co-founder Taylor Moore’s own experiences as a cam model.

Jackie Backman ·
Show More