Judge Denies Motion to Dismiss Extreme Associates Case

PITTSBURGH — A federal judge who had previously dismissed the case against Extreme Associates, only to have the dismissal overturned on appeal, has denied a second motion to dismiss the case.

Following the reversal of U.S. District Judge Gary Lancaster’s earlier dismissal of the case, Extreme Associates’ attorneys H. Louis Sirkin and Jennifer M. Kinsley filed another motion to dismiss, on the grounds that federal obscenity statutes are unconstitutional and do not apply to the Internet.

As an alternative to dismissal of the case, Sirkin and Kinsley moved for a pretrial ruling regarding how the Miller obscenity test would be applied to the case. The defense argued in their motion that the Miller test’s reliance on “community standards” is not viable in when the material in question is distributed via the Internet.

In his latest ruling issued July 30, Lancaster denied the motion to dismiss but granted the pretrial hearing requested as an alternative to dismissal.

“The criminal obscenity statutes at issue, as well as the Miller test, have repeatedly been deemed constitutional,” Lancaster wrote in his order.

Lancaster wrote that the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, in overturning his prior dismissal of the case, held that “even if the statutes, and applicable standards, have been called into question due to subsequent events, if there is going to be a change in the law it must come from the top down, not from the bottom up.”

Lancaster added that his declining of the defense motion to dismiss does not mean “that the issues raised by the defendants, and the case law they have cited in support, are irrelevant.”

“Indeed, what is meant by ‘community standards’ and ‘as a whole’ in relation to materials transported via the Internet are centrally important to the trial of this matter,” Lancaster wrote. “These factors will affect the court’s ruling on relevant evidentiary issues and the admissibility of evidence, as well as the drafting of jury instructions and perhaps even jury selection.”

Kinsley told XBIZ that Lancaster simply “couldn’t go to the extent of throwing the whole case out like he did last time [because] there is no case that has answered the specific questions” raised in the latest motion to dismiss.

Kinsley said that the upcoming hearing on the question of how the Miller test will be applied could prove “very critical as to what the jury would see” presented as evidence in the case.

“The hearing will address what the jury can consider as part of their ‘community,’” Kinsley said. Kinsley added that even though some of the material indicted as obscene in the case came in the form of DVDs and not online files, that fact “still leaves a fundamental question of ‘community,’ because [investigators] ordered the DVDs via the Internet.”

Kinsley told XBIZ that a status hearing will be held on Aug. 17 to pick a date for the pretrial hearing concerning the application of the Miller test in the case.

“There’s still a long road to go even before we reach a trial,” Kinsley said.

Noting that the case is now well into its third year, Kinsley told XBIZ that while the drawn out progress can be frustrating, there is a bright side to the slow pace involved.

“Every day that there’s not a trial is another day that there can’t be a conviction,” Kinsley said.

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Apple 'Approves' 1st Porn App for iPhone in Europe

Apple has begrudgingly "approved" the first porn app for use on iPhones, which is now available in Europe.

Leana Lovings, Blake Blossom Star in Latest 'All-Girl Massage' From Adult Time

Leana Lovings and Blake Blossom star in the latest installment of Adult Time series "All-Girl Massage," titled "Lonely Nights To Come."

UN Special Rapporteur: Porn Violates Human Rights

Fervent anti-sex work activist Reem Alsalem, a special rapporteur on violence against women and girls at the United Nations Human Rights Council, said in an interview this week that porn represents a serious human rights violation.

Dorcel Premieres Inka Winter's 'Olivia'

ForPlay Films founder Inka Winter directs “Olivia,” the latest release from Dorcel.

2025 XRCO Awards Scheduled for May 25

The X-Rated Critics Organization (XRCO) has scheduled the 41st annual XRCO Awards for May 25.

Cherry Kiss, Alison Rey Topline Latest 'Lesbian Anal' From Sweetheart Video

2021 XMA Europas Female Performer of the Year Cherry Kiss and Alison Rey headline "Lesbian Anal 7," from Mile High Media studio imprint Sweetheart Video.

MyMember.site Debuts New Biometric Age Verification Feature

MyMember.site has introduced a biometric age estimation system for age verification in the EU and UK.

Ofcom Closes OnlyFans Age-Gating Investigation

U.K. communications regulator Ofcom has discontinued an investigation into whether OnlyFans violated the Online Safety Act (OSA) by failing to prevent minors from viewing adult content.

Pin-Up Wow Relaunches Site, Debuts Affiliate Program

British website Pin-Up Wow has relaunched its subscription site.

Show More