N.Y. Man Files Suit to Reclaim Pornographic Pictures of Himself

ALBANY, N.Y. — An Albany man is waging a legal battle against U.S. Attorney General John Ashcroft and New York Attorney General Eliot Spitzer, claiming that laws barring him from possessing childhood photos of himself should be ruled unconstitutional.

The problem is that the laws in question pertain to child pornography and the childhood photographs depict Mark Horgarth engaging in solo masturbation and sexual acts with others.

Originally filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of New York at the end of June, the lawsuit contends that the 269 pictures, currently located in a foreign country for fear that they would give the government grounds to bring child pornography charges against Hogarth, should be constitutionally protected under the right to privacy and the First Amendment.

“The 269 photos are of deep personal importance to me,” wrote Hogarth in his pro se complaint. “I have become increasingly indignant that I am obligated to travel to a foreign nation to view these personal photos, and that I may not legally possess them here in the State of New York, my home for most of my life since birth.”

Hogarth contends that the pictures, taken when he was between 11 and 15 years old, hold “artistic merit,” were not illegal at the time and that he “enthusiastically consented” to the activities depicted in the pictures.

“If I could go back in time I would do it all over again with even more good-natured gusto,” wrote Hogarth. “I was not the pawn of anyone, nor were the photographs created for sale nor for any commercial or ‘evil’ purpose.”

The government, though, alleged that since Hogarth was a minor at the time the photographs were taken, they are inherently illegal.

“The mere fact that decades later the plaintiff alleges that all the sexual conduct was consensual does not alter the fact that the plaintiff was incapable of consenting,” wrote the government. “The unlawful exploitation of children is not dependant upon the plaintiff’s whim.”

The government also alleged that one of the major reasons for prohibiting the possession of child pornography is to prevent the pictures from being used to lure other children into same activities.

“Once the photographs are in [Hogarth’s] possession, the State would have no control over the advertent or inadvertent disbursement of the material or the use of the material to lure unsuspecting victims,” it wrote.

Hogarth, though, insists that the photographs will only be kept as memories of his youth and that most people wouldn’t be interested in them anyway.

“It is preposterous to propose that […] antique photos from decades ago could be more alluring to minors or to commercial pornographers than images tailor-made using the latest wonders of technology,” Hogarth wrote in a response. “I wish to import and possess the photos as keepsakes, as purely private memorabilia.”

Both sides declined to comment on the lawsuit.

The lawsuit was dismissed in July for jurisdictional and administrative reasons and then refiled with an amended complaint in August.

A status hearing originally scheduled for Oct. 26 has been postponed indefinitely until dispositive matters are resolved.

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Kyrgyzstan President Signs Measure Outlawing Internet Porn

President Sadyr Japarov of Kyrgyzstan on Tuesday signed into law legislation outlawing online adult content in the country.

NC Legislature Overrides Veto of Extreme Anti-Adult Industry Bill

The North Carolina state legislature on Tuesday voted to override Gov. Josh Stein’s veto of a bill imposing regulations that industry observers have warned could push adult websites and platforms to ban most creators and content.

Report: VPN Downloads Soar in UK Following Age Verification Deadline

Virtual private network apps, which can be used to circumvent geo-specific age verification requirements, are topping Apple App Store downloads in the U.K. in the wake of new Online Safety Act rules, the BBC is reporting.

Strike 3 Holdings Sues Meta for Pirating Vixen Media Group Content to Train AI

Vixen Media Group owner Strike 3 Holdings filed suit in federal court this week, accusing Facebook parent company Meta of copyright infringement and alleging that Meta has extensively pirated VMG content to train its artificial intelligence models.

Friday is Final AV Compliance Deadline in UK

Friday, July 25 marks U.K. media regulator Ofcom’s deadline for user-to-user services such as tube, cam and fan sites to implement its requisite “highly effective age assurance” measures for preventing minors from viewing adult content.

Two Texas Bills Restricting Sex Toy Sales Fail to Pass

Two bills aimed at restricting sales of sex toys have failed to pass the Texas state legislature during its 2025 session.

NYC Adult Stores Petition for Rehearing in Zoning Law Case

A group of adult businesses on Tuesday petitioned the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit to rehear a case involving a zoning law that could severely limit adult stores’ operations in New York City.

Ofcom Releases Transparency Reporting Guidelines

Ofcom, the U.K. media regulator, has made public its official guidance detailing how online service providers — including adult sites — will be required to publish annual transparency reports on their efforts to protect children from online harms.

New AV Rules Take Effect for Ireland-Based Sites

Ireland’s Online Safety Code came into force Monday, including a provision requiring adult sites headquartered in Ireland to implement age assurance measures beyond self-declaration.

Texas Resumes AV Lawsuit Against Aylo Following SCOTUS Decision

A district court judge in Texas has unfrozen the state’s $1.6 million lawsuit against Aylo for allegedly failing to comply with age verification requirements, Bloomberg Law is reporting.

Show More