Strike 3 Holdings: Defendant Allowed Copyright Countersuit

Strike 3 Holdings: Defendant Allowed Copyright Countersuit

LOS ANGELES — The Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals granted summary judgment to a man who had been accused of downloading via BitTorrent copyrighted adult videos by Strike 3 Holdings, confirming his standing in his request for a declaration that he was not a copyright infringer and awarding him $47,776.63 in attorney fees and costs.

The John Doe, only identified as an ex-police officer in his 70s, had been identified by Strike 3 Holdings — copyright holder for the Vixen Media Group content — based on a IP address. He countersued Strike 3, rejecting their accusation and accusing them of “extortion through sham litigation.”

The individual testified he had been “married for 40 years, and, until he was sued, had never heard of the pornographic websites: ‘Blacked,' ‘Vixen,’ or ‘Tushy,’” Metropolitan News-Enterprise reported. He also testified that he “does not know who downloaded these movies.”

Strike 3 had already dropped their copyright infringement suit, and had appealed to the Ninth District to toss out the countersuit as well, claiming it was now moot.

The court opined that the John Doe retained a cause of action because he had a real concern that Strike 3 might sue him again.

“The pending litigation between Doe and Strike 3, coupled with the real threat of future litigation between the parties, constitutes the type of injury that confers constitutional standing,” wrote the three-judge panel.

Circuit Judge Johnnie Rawlinson, Senior Circuit Judge Jay Bybee and Senior District Court Judge Morrison C. England Jr. of the Eastern District of California, sitting by designation, affirmed a previous decision of District Court Judge Thomas S. Zilly of the Western District of Washington.

“Strike 3’s voluntary dismissal of its infringement claims against Doe placed him in the precarious position of deciding whether to pursue his non-infringement counterclaim or to surrender the claim and hope that Strike 3 would not bring further action based on his prior alleged infringement,” the judges continued.

“Doe’s fear of future prosecution, based on the very real prosecution to that point and the thinly veiled threats of fixture contributory-infringement claims, was concrete and imminent,” they added.

The opinion also noted that according to Strike 3’s lawyers’ own admission “it was nearly certain that Doe’s son was the infringer, making it likely that Strike 3 would pursue other infringement claims against Doe in the future.”

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Adult Creative Unveils PPC Services

Adult Creative has launched its new Pay-Per-Click (PPC) service.

Gov. DeSantis Vetoes Florida's Age Verification Bill, Endorses Forthcoming Alternative

Gov. Ron DeSantis has vetoed HB 1, a bill in the Florida state legislature that originally restricted anyone under 16 from accessing social media, but was then combined with a separate bill mandating age verification of adult content. Launches Through YourPaysitePartner, the official website of fetish and gonzo studio Bemefi Video, has launched through YourPaysitePartner (YPP).

OnlyFans CEO: 'We're Very Proud of Our Adult-Content Creators'

The Financial Times has published an interview with OnlyFans CEO Keily Blair, in which she discusses the popular creator platform and her current vision for the company, and explicitly states that the company is “very proud” of its adult content creators.

Jasmine Teaa Is LoyalFans' 'Featured Creator' for March

LoyalFans has named Jasmine Teaa as its Featured Creator for March.

FSC Submits Statement for the Record to U.S. Congress About Financial Discrimination

The Free Speech Coalition has submitted a statement for the record to Congress, detailing the ways in which Treasury regulations aimed at preventing financial crime may be unintentionally leading to de-banking adult businesses and workers. Releases 2023 'Annual Report' has released its Annual Report, highlighting tendencies and popular search terms on the site in 2023.

Aylo Responds to Canada's Privacy Commissioner Report on User-Generated Content Protocols

Aylo has released a statement responding to a report released by Canada’s privacy commissioner, regarding a complaint about user-generated content.

PASS Adds Indie Producer Fivestar to Board of Directors

The Performer Availability Screening Service (PASS) has tapped independent producer Fivestar to join its board of directors.

Kentucky Republicans Revive 'Public Health Crisis' Claims to Justify Anti-Porn Bills

Republican lawmakers in the Kentucky House and Senate are renewing claims that adult content is part of a “public health crisis,” to justify introducing matching copycat versions of the age verification legislation being sponsored around the country by anti-porn religious conservative activists.

Show More