Justice Stevens, Hero of Online Freedom of Expression, Dies at 99

Justice Stevens, Hero of Online Freedom of Expression, Dies at 99

WASHINGTON, D.C. — Retired Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens, who led the Court majority that upheld online freedom of speech in the mid 1990s when Congress attempted to establish government censorship of “obscene” material, has died at 99.

Stevens, a World War II veteran appointed by Republican President Gerald Ford, became recognized as an unlikely champion of liberal causes during his time on the Supreme Court (1975-2010). His opinions crucially shaped the direction of the Internet.

In 1992, years before most Americans could conceive of anything like Amazon.com — or even having the Internet at home — as anything but sci-fi, Stevens authored the opinion that online retailers should not be required to collect taxes on out-of-state sales, paving the way for the unstoppable growth of online commerce.

Then, in 1997, Stevens authored the opinion that resulted in the protection of sexually explicit material on the Internet.

After Congress enacted a broad censorship law, prudishly named the Communications Decency Act (CDA), making it a federal crime to post "indecent" material on public websites that could be accessed by minors, Stevens wrote an opinion upholding the most basic principles of free speech.

“If upheld,” as CNet’s Declan McCullagh explained in a 2010 article celebrating Stevens’ legacy upon his retirement, “the CDA would have levied broadcast-style regulations on the internet, making it a felony for even a news organization to post certain four-letter expletives of the sort that landed the late comedian George Carlin in trouble with the Federal Communications Commission. The Internet would have been left heavily censored, while DVDs, magazines, newspapers, and satellite radio, and TV were not.”

“Online porn,” continues McCullagh, would have been completely forbidden — unless, that is, “every single salacious image or video stayed behind a pay wall requiring credit card verification for proof of age.”

As CNet speculated, “if the CDA had remained in effect, the Internet porn industry may have moved offshore instead of being headquartered in California's San Fernando Valley.”

Stevens was far-seeing in his vision of digital freedom of expression. “The record demonstrates that the growth of the Internet has been and continues to be phenomenal,” he wrote. “As a matter of constitutional tradition, in the absence of evidence to the contrary, we presume that governmental regulation of the content of speech is more likely to interfere with the free exchange of ideas than to encourage it. The interest in encouraging freedom of expression in a democratic society outweighs any theoretical but unproven benefit of censorship.”

With the current Supreme Court packed with religiously motivated ideologues like Justices Thomas, Alito, Gorsuch and Kavanaugh, Stevens’ cautious take on freedom of expression seems like a relic of a much quainter era, when the Internet was seen as a new frontier of knowledge and information rather than a battlefield of contention and deceit in need of governmental oversight.

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Congressional Republicans, Democrats Renew Attack on Section 230

The ranking members from both parties in the U.S. House of Representatives Communications and Technology Subcommittee have teamed up to propose an end to current liability protections under Section 230, known to digital rights activists as “the First Amendment of the internet.”

UK Tory Minister Blames Joblessness Crisis on Pornography, Video Games

The U.K. Tory government’s Work and Pensions Secretary this week blamed “pornography and video games” for what he called “a mental health crisis among young men” that he claims has resulted in them leaving the workforce.

Sexologist Dr. Susan Block Reports Legal Action Against Meta for Deplatforming

Sexologist Dr. Susan Block has reported that she has filed a complaint against Meta seeking arbitration for “wrongful business practices,” including lack of accountability, algorithmic discrimination and deactivation of her sex advice accounts.

Democratic Senator Dick Durbin Joins Press Conference Alongside Anti-Porn Crusading Group NCOSE

Democratic U.S. Senator for Illinois Dick Durbin participated in a joint press conference Wednesday organized by Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham to marshal support for the controversial Eliminating Abusive and Rampant Neglect of Interactive Technologies Act (EARN IT), alongside crusading anti-porn group NCOSE (formerly Morality in Media).

YouPay, Layers Accountancy Partner to Offer Financial Advice to UK Creators

Gifting platform YouPay has partnered with accounting firm Layers Accountancy to offer U.K.-based creators financial and tax advice to operate their businesses successfully.

U of Wisconsin Professor Pens Essay About Crusade to Get Him Fired for Creating Adult Content

A veteran University of Wisconsin professor, who was removed from his post as chancellor last year due to creating and appearing in adult content, has penned a piece for The Chronicle of Higher Education detailing his ordeal and ongoing attempts to fire him from his tenured position.

Fans Utopia Launches Fans Utopia+

Creator merch platform Fans Utopia has launched a new website, Fans Utopia+, designed to support up-and-coming performers who seek to connect with their fans and sell merchandise without committing to the full-service model offered by the flagship service.

AEBN Trends Article Probes Threesomes

AEBN has published a report on threesomes, comparing theory with practice, and fantasy with reality.

Centrobill Now Offering Fully Licensed PIX Payments in Brazil

Centrobill has integrated PIX payments into its services for the Brazilian market.

Spain's Government Fails in Attempt to Recriminalize, 'Abolish' Sex Work

Spain’s Socialist Party (PSOE) suffered a sound defeat on Tuesday in its attempt to recriminalize sex work in Spain, as a controversial bill promoted by Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez’s government failed to gain parliamentary support among the party’s ruling coalition allies.

Show More