Dating Site Operator to Pay Restitution, Fine for Auto Renewals

Dating Site Operator to Pay Restitution, Fine for Auto Renewals

SANTA MONICA, Calif. — Spark Networks USA, the parent company of niche dating sites Jdate.com and ChristianMingle.com, can now be added to a growing list of dating website operators that have been probed, prosecuted and punished for unfair or deceptive acts.

Los Angeles-based Spark Networks recently agreed to pay $500,000 in penalties and up to $985,000 in restitution to customers whose subscriptions automatically renewed or who were denied refunds when requested.

In a final court judgment signed by a Los Angeles County Superior Court judge earlier this month, Spark Networks also agreed to change its website and sales practices after being sued by the Santa Monica city attorney and district attorneys in San Diego, Los Angeles, Santa Clara and Santa Cruz counties.

Industry attorney Corey D. Silverstein of Silverstein Legal told XBIZ that the judgment sends a message to all website operators — that California authorities won’t hesitate to use their resources to go after businesses that are doing harm to consumers.

“The State of California is taking the lead once again, reminding website operators that government is no longer tolerating billing practices (most notably automatic renewal billing) that aren’t fully transparent and require express consent by consumers,” Silverstein said.

“The Federal Trade Commission has been especially aggressive in pursuing and prosecuting website operators for violations of the Restore Online Shopper’s Confidence Act (ROSCA) and ‘unfair or deceptive acts or practices in or affecting commerce,’” Silverstein said. “Dating websites in particular have been prime targets and Spark Networks can now be added to a growing list of dating websites that have been investigated, prosecuted and ultimately punished.

“At this point, it would be crazy for any website operator to engage in business practices that aren’t fully compliant with ROSCA and the growing number of state consumer protection laws that are now more than ever being aggressively enforced,” Silverstein said.

“If you are running an online business and aren’t sure if you are necessarily compliant, then now would be the time to have a proper legal review.”

The Spark Networks judgment requires all of its dating websites to clearly and conspicuously disclose renewal terms and obtain consumers’ consent through a separate check box or similar mechanism that does not include other terms and conditions.

Spark Networks also must send a summary of its renewal terms to consumers after they pay, and the Los Angeles company must allow consumers to cancel easily. Federal and state law requires businesses to make auto-renewals clear to consumers and to get “express, affirmative consent” before funds are collected.

California consumers who paid certain membership fees between May 26, 2012, and Oct. 10, 2017, would be able to seek reimbursement if they were charged for at least one automatically renewed cycle without their knowledge and consent.

Consumers who previously requested cancellation of an automatic renewal or continuous service plan and were denied were also eligible for restitution.

Each eligible recipient would receive a restitution check for $25 unless the total restitution claimed would exceed $985,000. If that occurs, the recipient amount would be lowered, according to terms of the settlement.

“Nobody should be surprised by this story,” Silverstein said. "And Spark Networks should be counting their blessings because this could have ended far worse for the publicly traded company whose market cap is $139.8 million and whose revenue in 2017 was just shy of $86 million.

"$500,000 in penalties and up to $985,000 in potential restitution will be considered by many as nothing more than a slap on the wrist," he said. "However, if you put aside the financial fines, all website operators are being sent a message by the State of California that the state will not hesitate to use their resources to go after businesses that are doing harm to California consumers.”

Copyright © 2024 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Adult Site Broker Talk's Bruce Friedman Reflects on Podcast Success

The 200th episode of Adult Site Broker Talk will air next week, with 2023 XBIZ Performer of the Year Cherie DeVille as a very special guest.

FSC Asks Supreme Court to Overturn 5th Circuit Decision, Strike Texas' Age Verification Law

Free Speech Coalition (FSC) filed a petition for certiorari on Friday asking the U.S. Supreme Court to overturn the Fifth Circuit panel decision that partially upheld Texas’ controversial age verification law.

Details Emerge About Capture, Arrest of GirlsDoPorn's Michael Pratt

Further details have emerged in the past week about the capture and arrest of GirlsDoPorn owner Michael Pratt in Spain in December 2022, following his extradition to the U.S. last month.

Magdalene St. Michaels, Andy Rodrigues Named as AEBN Top Stars for Q1 of 2024

AEBN has announced its top-selling stars for the first quarter of 2024, with Magdalene St. Michaels landing atop the leader board for straight theaters and Andy Rodrigues heading up the gay rankings.

YouPay Partners With IP Security Solution Sidenty

Australian gifting platform YouPay has joined forces with IP security solution Sidenty to help creators guard against online theft and unauthorized use of their content.

Grooby Launches Fetish Site 'Joey's Trans Feet Girls'

Grooby has debuted Joey's Trans Feet Girls, a new fetish membership site featuring foot content by top trans performers.

Lady Lyne Launches New Paysite Through AdultPrime

IMC’s AdultPrime has expanded its network of paysites with the launch performer Lady Lyne's official site.

UK Media Regulator Encourages Companies, Creators to Provide Feedback on 'Categorized Services'

U.K. media regulator Ofcom is again asking adult industry companies, creators and other stakeholders to provide feedback to help it establish new regulations under the Online Safety Act (OSA) — regulations that will impact the accessibility of online adult content.

Internet Researcher Maggie MacDonald Pens Op-Ed on the Risks of Canada's Age Verification Proposals

Online safety academic and Ethical Capital Partners’ advisory board member Maggie MacDonald penned an editorial for the Toronto Globe and Mail arguing that although mandatory age-verification for adult content will not work to prevent online harms for minors, it will erode everyone’s privacy instead.

LoyalFans to Hold 'Master Class' Event With Ezada Sinn

LoyalFans will hold a special "Master Class" livestream with content creator Ezada Sinn, titled "Growing Your LoyalFans Account & Creating Passive Income," on Saturday at 2 p.m. EDT.

Show More