Decision Goes Far to Limit Government Use of FOSTA, Attorney Says

Decision Goes Far to Limit Government Use of FOSTA, Attorney Says

WASHINGTON — A judge's dismissal of a legal challenge to FOSTA was plain and simple — the plaintiffs, including the Woodhull Freedom Foundation — lacked standing, or a vested interest, in the case.

Plaintiffs now are weighing what to do next after U.S. District Judge Richard Leon on Tuesday refused to grant relief over amendments to Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act that enable state prosecutors to apply their statutes against prostitution.

FOSTA, known formally as the Allow States and Victims to Fight Online Sex Trafficking Act, brings new tools for law enforcement, including the ability to bring criminal charges against the operators of sites that facilitate prostitution. The federal statute also allows for civil claims, as well.

Though Leon’s decision is certainly not what Woodhull and the other plaintiffs wanted, adult industry attorney Joe Obenberger — a former federal prosecutor who is not a party to the case challenging FOSTA — said the ruling is nonetheless “a decision rendering remarkable and profound protection concerning criminal liability under FOSTA.”

“Judge Leon's decision goes very far to limit the government's use of FOSTA against broad, vague claims that an online publisher somehow generally advanced prostitution,” Obenberger told XBIZ. “He used strong language to say that's just not enough for a conviction.”

Obenberger said that Leon’s wording in a memorandum opinion issued yesterday interpreted Section 2421A, the so-called centerpiece of FOSTA and this case.

There, the law creates a federal criminal offense for owning, managing or operating an online service with the intent to promote or facilitate the prostitution of another person or conspiring to do so.

"Section 2421A will require the government to show not simply that the defendant was aware of a potential result of the criminal offense, but instead that the defendant intended to 'explicitly further' a specified unlawful act," Leon wrote. “Of course, the mere promotion or facilitation of prostitution is not enough ….”

Obenberger said that Leon identified and coupled three parts of the statute to determine its sharp limitations.

“First, the prostitution must be linked specifically to ‘another person’ or ‘five or more,’" Obenberger said. “Second, the prostitution must be against the law of a particular jurisdiction. Third, the mens rea described in the statute — the criminal intent required — is one that he calls ‘stringent.’

“From these three factors, he reads the act to require that one is guilty of violation of FOSTA only when a specific act of illegal prostitution of a particular person in a particular jurisdiction is intended,” Obenberger said.

“It would be the difficult job of a prosecutor to prove a facilitation or promotion of a very particular, specified, identified act.”

Even though there was some clarification of Section 2421A, Obenberger said that the “major letdown” of the case is that Leon refused relief concerning the amendments to Section 230 that enable state prosecutors to apply their prostitution statutes.

“Judge Leon never really reaches Section 230, apparently because he does not believe that any of the parties have standing, a vested interest, strong enough to stay in court; this may be the weakest part of his reasoning,” Obenberger said.

“Until or unless he is reversed on appeal, the boots on the ground can be expected to challenge criminal prostitution laws on privacy grounds in court, or to agitate for their repeal in jurisdictions whose populations may accept the idea,” he said.

“Should even a small number of states do so, it is likely that a significant number of others would follow.”

View Judge Leon's decision

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Hollywood Cash Talks Style, Strategy, and XMA Gold

Hollywood Cash lounges in a hotel suite, relaxing after a long day on set. Draped in a thick designer bathrobe — ivory white with sleek black-and-gold trim — and matching slippers, he looks like he stepped out of a high-end lifestyle shoot.

Eva Angelina Makes Her MILFY Debut

Eva Angelina has made her debut for Vixen Media Group studio imprint MILFY in a gangbang scene titled “Yes Chief.”

Chloe Amour Toplines Latest 'Hardcore Anal Superstars' From Hard X

Chloe Amour headlines the fourth volume of "Hardcore Anal Superstars" from XEmpire studio brand Hard X.

Creator of Hentaied, Parasited Launches New Site 'Vampired'

Romero Mr. Alien, the creator of Parasited and Hentaied, has launched Vampired.com as both a stand-alone paysite and part of the Hentaied.Pro streaming platform.

Australian eSafety Commissioner Demands Stricter Child Protection Codes

Australia’s online safety regulator, eSafety, is once again reviewing a “final” draft of industry codes to protect children from pornography and other age-inappropriate content, after eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant rejected the previously announced “final” codes as insufficiently stringent.

Liz Flynt Debuts 'Hustler: 50 Years of Freedom' Book

Liz Flynt has released her new retrospective book, “Hustler: 50 Years of Freedom.”

Cubbi Thompson: On a Wild Ride All Her Own

How do you relax after a hard day’s work? A) Sprawl on the couch, B) Soak in the tub, or C) Head straight for the nearest theme park and jump on the roller coaster.

Nerdgasm: A Look at the Naughty Side of Pop Culture Geekdom

From “Call of Duty” to cosplay, from tabletop dice rolls to dungeon-inspired dirty talk, the worlds of geek fandom and fantasy are no longer confined to the basement. They’ve kicked down the door, shed the “Firefly” tee and gone full frontal.

Kyrgyzstan Parliament Moves to Outlaw Internet Pornography

A parliamentary committee of the Supreme Council of Kyrgyzstan on Tuesday approved a measure to outlaw online adult content in the country.

Elizabeth Skylar, Selena Ivy Topline 'My Friend's Lesbian Daughter 4'

Elizabeth Skylar and Selena Ivy headline the latest release from Girlfriends Films, titled “My Friend's Lesbian Daughter 4.”

Show More