Sex Workers to Continue Challenge of Calif. Prostitution Law

Sex Workers to Continue Challenge of Calif. Prostitution Law

SAN FRANCISCO — Counsel for the ESPLER Project have vowed to ask for a rehearing in an appellate case decided last week that upheld the constitutionality of California’s prostitution statute.

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday rejected the contention that states are precluded from criminalizing prostitution based on the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2003 decision in Lawrence v. Texas. With that case, the high court declared unconstitutional laws that prohibit homosexual sodomy.

Industry attorney Gill Sperlein, who represents ESPLER Project, told XBIZ that the organization will be filing a request for rehearing en banc, or in front of the full court, by its deadline, Thursday, Feb. 1.

“We are disappointed with the decision,” Sperlein said. “We feel that if we are given a chance to dispute the arguments the state advances in support of the laws limiting people's fundamental rights, we will be able to show that none of them hold water. 

“All logic and reason supports the notion that decriminalization and regulation of prostitution would serve society better than continuing to force the industry to operate in black markets.”

Last week’s opinion rejected ESPLER Project’s challenges to Penal Code §647(b) on the bases of a substantive due process right to sexual privacy, a substantive due process right to earn a living, freedom of association, and freedom of speech.

Lawrence has not previously been interpreted as creating a liberty interest that invalidates laws criminalizing prostitution,” wrote Judge Jane Restani of the U.S. Court of International Trade, sitting by designation.

Restani noted that the bounds of Lawrence were unclear and that the U.S. Supreme Court has not had occasion to elaborate on the intended breadth of the decision.

 “But whatever the nature of the right protected in Lawrence, one thing Lawrence does make explicit is that the Lawrence case … does not involve ... prostitution.”

Maxine Doogan, who serves as president of ESPLERP, known formally as the Erotic Service Provider Legal Education and Research Project, said she was bothered by the decision. 

“It is mind boggling that today’s Ninth Circuit decision relied on a 1998 case (IDK Inc. v. Clark County), which relied on the 1986 Bowers v. Hardwick case (which upheld a Georgia sodomy law), when both have since clearly been superseded by Lawrence v. Texas, the 2003 Supreme Court case which struck down sodomy laws nationwide.”

About three years ago, ESPLER Project filed a complaint at U.S. federal court claiming that the state’s anti-prostitution statute unfairly deprives adults the right to private consensual activity, criminalizes the discussion of such activity and unconstitutionally places prohibitions on individuals’ right to freely associate.

Sperlein and another industry attorney, Louis Sirkin, asked the appeals panel to toss a lower court's judgment, remand the case to the lower court and declare the anti-prostitution law unconstitutionality. In the appeal, ESPLER Project also was seeking a permanent injunction.

The appeal was based on an earlier decision by a federal judge that dismissed the group's suit against California's attorney general and four district attorneys across the state.

The case is supported by amicus briefs from more than 30 civil rights and LGBTQ organizations, including the ACLU, the First Amendment Lawyers Association, Transgender Law Center and the Woodhull Freedom Foundation and the Free Speech Coalition.

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

FSC Unpacks SCOTUS Age Verification Ruling in Webinar

The Free Speech Coalition conducted a public webinar Tuesday to help adult industry stakeholders understand the Supreme Court’s recent decision in FSC v. Paxton, and its potential implications.

Bad Bella Fronts Latest From MYLF

Bad Bella stars with Hayden Wild in the latest release from MYLF.

Abella Danger Opens Up Like Never Before in X3 Magazine

Powerhouse star Abella Danger lights up the latest issue of X3 magazine, the industry’s premier “authenticity first” publication spotlighting the real personalities, passions, and stories behind today’s top creators.

Pure Taboo Debuts Bree Mills Thriller 'Let Me In Too'

Reagan Foxx stars with Shay Sights in the latest thriller from Pure Taboo, titled “Let Me In Too.”

UK Lawmaker Calls for Appointment of 'Porn Minister'

Baroness Gabrielle Bertin, the Conservative member of Parliament who recently convened a new anti-pornography task force, is calling for the appointment of a “minister for porn,” according to British news outlet The Guardian.

FSC Toasts Jeffrey Douglas for 30 Years of Service

n the very same evening when the adult industry was hit hard by the Supreme Court ruling supporting Texas’ controversial age verification law, HB 1181, members of the Free Speech Coalition board, staff and supporters gathered to celebrate Jeffrey Douglas’ 30 years as board chair — a fitting reflection of his reputation as an eternal optimist.

Hookup Hotshot Adds TobyDick.com

Hookup Hotshot (HUHS) has added U.K. paysite TobyDick.com to its network.

TTS Opens UK Testing Location

Talent Testing Service (TTS) has opened a new U.K. location in Ware, Hertfordshire.

FSC: Age-Verification Laws Go Into Effect South Dakota, Georgia, Wyoming on July 1

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) has published a statement regarding new age verification laws set to go into effect tomorrow in South Dakota, Georgia, and Wyoming.

Leana Lovings, Shay Sights Front 'Substance' Parody From Brazzers

Leana Lovings stars with Shay Sights in the latest release from Brazzers, a parody of "The Substance.”

Show More