Appeals Court Won't Rehear Copyright Case Over DMCA Takedowns

Appeals Court Won't Rehear Copyright Case Over DMCA Takedowns

SAN FRANCISCO — The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday declined to rehear the so-called “dancing baby” case but made some amendments to its ruling on the Digital Millennium Copyright Act’s notice-and-takedown system.

The panel’s September ruling was the first time ever an appellate court held that “fair use” should be treated as a necessary consideration when copyright holders send takedown demands.  

Fair use permits limited use of copyrighted material without acquiring permission from the rights holders. It is one type of legal defense, called an affirmative defense, to the exclusive rights granted to the author of a creative work by copyright law.

Today’s amended appellate ruling left the original decision intact for the most part. But the new decision tossed out language on how automation might be used to evaluate fair use on a mass scale.

The 9th Circuit’s amended opinion excised several pages of its original ruling that said content owners’ fair use analysis need not be "searching or intensive” and that they could use automation through computer algorithms to help conduct the analysis.

In the September ruling, a three-judge panel of the 9th Circuit affirmed a lower court’s decision for summary judgment in an action under the DMCA alleging that Universal Music Group violated 17 U.S.C. § 512(f) by misrepresenting in a takedown notification that plaintiff Stephanie Lenz’s home video of her “dancing baby” constituted an infringing use of a portion of a Prince composition, "Let's Go Crazy."

In 2007, Universal sent a takedown notice to YouTube, claiming Lenz didn't have permission to use the song and YouTube removed her video.

Lenz later successfully petitioned YouTube to restore the 29-second video and then sued Universal, stating the company failed to properly review the home video before submitting the takedown notice.

The appeals court said in the September decision that copyright owners like Universal can only send takedown notices if they’ve come to a good faith conclusion that the targeted upload is not a protected fair use of the copyrighted work.

As a result, Universal must stand trial over whether it wrongfully sent a copyright takedown notice to her.

Adult industry attorney Marc Randazza of Randazza Legal Group told XBIZ that the amended decision released today was a mixed bag.

“I like that it makes it clear that fair use is a right, not an affirmative defense,” Randazza said. “At the same time, I find it sort of lame that they still leave the burden of proof of fair use on the fair user.”  

View today's amended ruling

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Wyoming Governor Signs Age Verification Law

Wyoming Governor Mark Gordon signed the state's new age verification bill into law yesterday.

2025 XMAs Awards Show Now Streaming

The 2025 XMAs awards ceremony, presented by Fansly and held Jan. 19 at the historic Hollywood Palladium, is now available for streaming on the XMA website.

Florida Bill Would Auto-Filter Porn for All Users, Not Just Minors

Florida lawmakers have introduced legislation to require manufacturers to equip tablets and smartphones with a filter that would prevent all users from accessing material deemed harmful to minors, to be automatically enabled on devices activated in that state.

TeamSkeet, MYLF Launch New Website 'Pervz'

Sister studios TeamSkeet and MYLF have launched a new website, Pervz.com.

AEBN Publishes Popular Searches for January, February

AEBN has announced the top search terms for January and February from its straight and gay theaters in all 50 states and the District of Columbia.

Porn Fidelity Signs Exclusive Partnership Deal With NMG Management

Adult studio Porn Fidelity has signed an exclusive partnership deal with brand management firm NMG Management.

Nigeria to Ban All Porn Websites, Penalize Non-Compliant ISPs

Nigeria's House of Representatives on Tuesday directed its telecom regulator, the Nigerian Communications Commission (NCC), to immediately block all porn websites across the country and to enforce that ban.

FSC Launches Action Modal for Adult Sites to Fight AV Laws

Free Speech Coalition (FSC) has launched its new action modal web script for adult websites to help combat state age verification legislation.

SkyPrivate Announces New Communications Options

SkyPrivate has announced new communications options as alternatives to Skype, which Microsoft is retiring in May.

Cruel Reell Joins Pineapple Support as Supporter-Level Sponsor

Cruel Reell has joined the ranks of over 60 adult businesses and organizations committing funds and resources to Pineapple Support.

Show More