Federal Circuit: U.S. Cannot Deny Trademarks Over Offensive Names

Federal Circuit: U.S. Cannot Deny Trademarks Over Offensive Names

WASHINGTON — In an appellate decision of significant importance for the adult entertainment and sex toys and novelties industries, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit ruled today that the U.S. government can’t deny trademarks over offensive names.

The case at hand involved the trademark registration of "The Slants," the name of a Portland, Ore., pop-rock band whose founders and members are Asian Americans.

Upon Simon Tam’s registration of his band’s trademark, the examining attorney at the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office found the mark The Slants disparaging and declined to register it.

The Trademark Trial and Appeal Board later affirmed the examiner’s decision. But later, the Federal Circuit agreed to rehear the case en banc after it originally sided with the examining attorney.

At issue in the The Slants case was § 2(a) of the Lanham Act, which allows the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office to deny or cancel a trademark if it is "disparaging" of persons, institutions or national symbols.

The Federal Circuit, 10-2, ruled today that the band’s name is private speech and therefore protected by the First Amendment. The government, the appeals court decided, has no business trying to regulate it.

"The government cannot refuse to register disparaging marks because it disapproves of the expressive messages conveyed by the marks," Federal Circuit Judge Kimberly Ann Moore wrote. "It cannot refuse to register marks because it concludes that such marks will be disparaging to others.

“The government regulation at issue amounts to viewpoint discrimination, and under the strict scrutiny review appropriate for government regulation of message or viewpoint, we conclude that the disparagement proscription of § 2(a) is unconstitutional,” she said.

“Because the government has offered no legitimate interests justifying § 2(a), we conclude that it would also be unconstitutional under the intermediate scrutiny traditionally applied to regulation of the commercial aspects of speech."

Moore, in a footnote, said that the ruling was limited to the constitutionality of the disparagement provision in the § 2(a) and might not be applicable on the “immoral and scandalous” provisions.  

Industry attorney Marc Randazza of Randazza Legal Group authored an amicus brief on behalf of the First Amendment Lawyers Association over The Slants case this past summer.

Randazza told XBIZ today that in the brief, "we argued that all of § 2(a) should be struck down, including its 'immoral and scandalous’ clause. That is the clause that most affects the adult entertainment industry."

“The court did not throw that part out explicitly, but what it did was explicitly overrule the case that the USPTO relies on when it rules against adult entertainment companies,” Randazza said. “Further, the order seems to invite a challenge to the immoral and scandalous clause.  

“Therefore, I think this is a great decision for all,” he said.  

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Eva Angelina on Stepping Back Into the Spotlight With Purpose

Eva Angelina is back in front of the camera, stronger and sharper than ever. Making her triumphant return in her own inimitable badass style, the veteran performer recently reentered the industry not just with a bang, but a dazzling signal flare.

Cassie Del Isla, Ama Rio Topline Latest 'Secret Lesbian Diaries'

Cassie Del Isla and Ama Rio headline the 15th volume of "Secret Lesbian Diaries" from Girlfriends Films.

Cailey Katt Fronts Latest From GroobyVR

Cailey Katt stars alongside Luke London in the latest release from GroobyVR, titled "A Katt in Your Lap."

Madi Collins Signs Exclusive Contract With Vixen Media Group

Vixen Media Group (VMG) has signed Madi Collins to an exclusive contract.

Zariah Aura Leads Latest From Transfixed

Zariah Aura stars with Summer Col and Robby Apples in the latest release from Transfixed, titled “Catching His Cheating Girlfriend.”

Penny Barber Featured in Latest From Kink.com

Reigning XMAs MILF Performer of the Year Penny Barber stars with Max Mabry in the new scene from Kink.com, titled “Mommy’s Cock-Hungry Hole.”

Yhivi, Ryan Reid Star in 'Pornstar Matchmaker: Episode 2' From Brazzers

Yhivi stars with Ryan Reid and 2024 XMA Europas Male Performer of the Year Christian Clay in the second episode of the new Brazzers series, “Pornstar Matchmaker.”

River Lynn Leads 'The Fucket List: Pizza With A Side Of Nuru' From Adult Time

River Lynn stars with Axel Haze in the latest Jim Powers-helmed scene "The Fucket List: Pizza With A Side Of Nuru," from studio brand Nuru Massage.

New Membership Site 'Sluts Corner' Launches

R18 Entertainment has launched a new membership site, SlutsCorner.com.

Avery Lust, Cliff Jensen Star in Latest From TransSensual

Avery Lust and Cliff Jensen star in the latest release from Mile High Media studio imprint TransSensual.

Show More