9th Circuit Hears Duty-to-Warn Case Involving ModelMayhem.com

PASADENA, Calif. — In a closely watched case, the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals yesterday heard from both sides in a civil suit alleging liability of ModelMayhem.com after two of its users drugged and raped a woman by luring her to a bogus casting call.

Emerson Callum and accomplice Lavont Flanders Jr. were given consecutive life sentences in prison for their misdeeds in Florida, and Internet Brands, the parent company of ModelMayhem.com, won an appellate re-hearing over whether it should be civilly liable in the case.

The woman, known as Jane Doe No. 12, sued the site’s operators for negligent failure to warn, claiming the company knew but failed to warn users.

But a federal judge dismissed her case under Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, which limits the liability of a website's publisher for content posted by third parties — in this case, Doe’s posting of her contact information.

On appeal, a 9th Circuit panel last year tossed the lower court decision and ruled that the Communications Decency Act did not bar the woman’s “failure to warn” claim against ModelMayhem.com. But the website’s counsel won a rehearing in the case in February, which was heard yesterday.

Doe’s attorney, Jeff Herman, argued that the case has nothing to do with ModelMayhem.com’s role as a publisher and that the CDA does not give Internet service providers "blanket immunity."

Herman argued that ModelMayhem.com had a duty to warn users of potential predatory danger because the company knew that the two predators had used the site to find victims before.

“We don’t want to hold them liable for third-party content,” Herman said. “What we are seeking to do is hold them liable over that they knew: That my client was at risk and there was a failure to warn.”

Attorney Daniel Collins, who represents ModelMayhem.com, said that the site's alleged duty has only to do with its status as the publisher since the duty "is alleged to arise from the fact that we brought her information into the world without giving a warning."

But panelist Judge Richard Clifton said that the case is in “an entirely different context” because ModelMayhem.com knew about the “miscreants in Florida.”

“How is the CDA intended to protect your client?” he asked Collins. “What suggests that the policy does go further in a case like this?”

The “problem is that predators were out there and could contact anybody who posted on your website,” the jurist remarked. “You could satisfy the duty to warn not by editing, but just by giving a warning.”

Clifton noted that the case, which he characterized as "complicated," "is going to open the door to numerous duty-to-warn cases."

"We know that there are predators out there," he said. "Does that mean that every [site] has to provide notice somewhere by saying, 'Use this website at your own risk'?"

"I can imagine Internet service providers being concerned and asking, 'How do we protect ourselves?'" he said.

The case has attracted the attention of numerous Internet companies and organizations that have sided with ModelMayhem.com.

In an amicus brief, Facebook, Craigslist, Tumblr, the Computer and Communications Industry Association, The Internet Association and Care.com said that they have settled on interpretations granting broad immunity to online intermediaries for harms arising from third-party content.

Yesterday’s 9th Circuit hearing can be heard here.

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

AEBN Announces Peter Green as Top Male Boy/Girl Performer for Summer 2025

AEBN has revealed its top 10 male Boy/Girl performers for summer 2025, with Peter Green landing atop the leaderboard.

Spicey AI Relaunches Site, Debuts $Spicey Tokens

Interactive voice chat platform Spicey AI has relaunched its website and introduced $Spicey tokens.

FSC: Missouri Age Verification Rule Will Not Take Effect August 30

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) announced that Missouri's proposed age verification legislation will not take effect on August 30, as it had originally estimated.

Little Caprice, Marcello Bravo to Co-Host 2025 XMA Europa Awards

XBIZ is pleased to announce that husband-and-wife duo Little Caprice and Marcello Bravo will co-host adult’s biggest night in Europe: the 2025 XMA Europa Awards on Sept. 4, in the epic climax to XBIZ’s fall events series.

Germany Will Block Payments to AV-Noncompliant Adult Sites as of Dec. 1

Starting Dec. 1, Germany will implement new rules prohibiting financial institutions from providing payment services to adult sites deemed to have inadequate age verification systems and making it easier for the government to target websites mirroring the content of such sites.

Jerkmate Joins Pineapple Support as Partner-Level Sponsor

Jerkmate has joined the ranks of over 70 adult businesses and organizations committing funds and resources to Pineapple Support.

FSC Launches Age Verification Toolkit for Adult Websites

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) announced today that it has launched a comprehensive toolkit to help adult websites navigate age verification laws.

Romero Mr. Alien to Present XBIZ Talk at Amsterdam Conference

XBIZ is pleased to announce that noted producer/director Romero Mr. Alien, the impresario of the XMAs award-winning studio Hentaied, will present an exclusive talk at next month’s Amsterdam conference.

New Fansly Analytics Platform 'SlyKiwi' Launches

SlyKiwi, a new analytics platform exclusively designed for Fansly content, has officially launched.

FPNCash Appoints Kimi Evans Head of Business Development

FPNCash has appointed Kimi Evans as its new head of business development.

Show More