9th Circuit May Stay YouTube Takedown Decision

SAN FRANCISCO — The full 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals will decide whether to stay a panel’s decision that requires YouTube to take down clips from the anti-Islamic film “Innocence of Muslims."

The original 9th Circuit ruling, made in late February, has implications for the adult entertainment because it gives with wide latitude a strong tool for performers who claim "actor's remorse," according to industry attorney Marc Randazza in an analysis for XBIZ.

Last week, the court’s en banc coordinator said an unidentified active judge of the court had requested en banc review of the panel’s denial of a stay.

Randazza, when reached on Monday about the court's decision to meet en banc over the case, said that the 9th Circuit's original ruling was the "right result but for all the wrong reasons" and that the decision to go the full panel was "interesting."

"I would think that the ruling ultimately would be reversed over this brand new interpretation by the court," Randazza told XBIZ.

The 9th Circuit found that Cindy Lee Garcia had created an original work in her performance, “Innocence of Muslims," and that she retained copyrightable rights because she did not execute a valid model release transferring them to the film’s creator.

The 9th Circuit also found that film producers typically have an implied license in the performance of actors appearing in their creations, but that the film’s creator far exceeded that license in this case.

"Under the Copyright Act, it is novel — though not unprecedented — for the court to find a performer has copyright rights in his or her performance," Randazza said in the analysis of the decision. "An actor’s performance contains originality and may be preserved in a fixed form, satisfying the standards for copyrightability under the Copyright Act ."

Garcia, an actress who answered a casting call for a role in a film to be titled “Desert Warrior,” was paid $500 for her part. She said she thought the film was about the life of a typical Egyptian 2,000 years ago but later was shocked to find out the film was a short anti-Islamic video called “Innocence of Muslims” streaming on YouTube.

In the video, she was portrayed as making anti-Muslim statements.  Later, according to court records, an Egyptian cleric issued a fatwa, calling for actors and production crew involved in the video to be killed.

Garcia repeatedly ordered Google and subsidiary YouTube to take down the video, but Google repeatedly declined.

Garcia later sued Google and YouTube, arguing that her performance in the film was copyrightable and that copyright interest entitled her to demand that YouTube pull the film.

A federal court denied Garcia’s request, so she took the case to the 9th Circuit where a three-judge panel sided with her last month.

The 9th Circuit panel held that she had a sufficient copyright right in her performance, despite the fact that she only appeared in the film for a few seconds, to remove the film from circulation.

On Monday, it wasn't determined when the full panel would hear Garcia's appeal.

Related:  

Copyright © 2025 Adnet Media. All Rights Reserved. XBIZ is a trademark of Adnet Media.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission is prohibited.

More News

Hookup Hotshot Adds TobyDick.com

Hookup Hotshot (HUHS) has added U.K. paysite TobyDick.com to its network.

TTS Opens UK Testing Location

Talent Testing Service (TTS) has opened a new U.K. location in Ware, Hertfordshire.

FSC: Age-Verification Laws Go Into Effect South Dakota, Georgia, Wyoming on July 1

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) has published a statement regarding new age verification laws set to go into effect tomorrow in South Dakota, Georgia, and Wyoming.

Leana Lovings, Shay Sights Front 'Substance' Parody From Brazzers

Leana Lovings stars with Shay Sights in the latest release from Brazzers, a parody of "The Substance.”

FSC Responds to Supreme Court Decision on Texas AV Law

The Free Speech Coalition (FSC) has released a statement responding to last week's Supreme Court decision on FSC v. Paxton, the Texas age verification law.

Sex Work CEO Debuts Upgraded 'GPTease' AI Assistant

Sex Work CEO has introduced the new Canvas in-chat editing feature to its AI-powered, NSFW text generator, GPTease.

Little Puck Stars in Latest Episode of 'The Bottom Floor' From Adult Time

Little Puck stars in the second episode of Adult Time series “The Bottom Floor,” titled “The Second Coming.”

Haley Spades Stars in Latest From Immoral

Haley Spades stars with Charlie Dean, Matt Bird, and Dean Van Damme in a new three-part release from Immoral Productions, directed by "Porno Dan" Leal.

Octavia Red Makes Her Vampired Debut

Octavia Red has made her Vampired debut alongside Talia Mint and 2023 XMA Europas Female Performer of the Year Tiffany Tatum in the new feature “Hunters.”

Lily Starfire Fronts Latest From Brazzers

Lily Starfire stars with Kyle Mason in the latest release from Brazzers, titled "Eating Ass Is the Game."

Show More